# Why no 'distinguished jurist' has ever been appointed to the Supreme Court

URL: https://upsc.help/current-affairs/2026-09-02/distinguished-jurist-article-124/
Date: 2 September 2026 (2026-09-02)
Source: Indian Express, Explained
UPSC papers: GS2
Publisher: upsc.help (Pratidin), free and open-source UPSC Civil Services current affairs. Not affiliated with UPSC. Every fact was checked against the source reports by a separate review before publishing.

**In one line:** Article 124(3)(c) lets the President appoint a "distinguished jurist" to the Supreme Court, but in 76 years no one has been appointed that way, and Justice Ujjal Bhuyan wants that to change.

On 30 August 2026, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan of the Supreme Court, speaking at the 13th convocation of National Law University Delhi, asked why no "distinguished jurist" has been appointed to the Supreme Court in the 76 years the Constitution has allowed it. The Indian Express examined this unused route in an Explained piece on 2 September. Article 124(3) says a citizen of India is qualified to be a Supreme Court judge if he or she (a) has been a High Court judge for at least five years, (b) has been an advocate of a High Court for at least ten years, or (c) is, in the opinion of the President, a distinguished jurist. Every appointment so far has come through the first two routes.

Justice Bhuyan said legal academics with brilliant minds have been left out, and called the usual objection, lack of practical experience, "very shallow". He argued that a distinguished jurist "can be a great value addition to the Bench" through scholarship, helping the Court engage with public law questions beyond narrow technicalities. He cited Felix Frankfurter, a Harvard law professor who became a judge of the U.S. Supreme Court, and appointments of academics to top courts in the United Kingdom, Canada and Kenya. He also said the Bench should better reflect the diversity of academia, the Bar and the Bench.

The idea was debated in the Constituent Assembly on 24 May 1949, when H.V. Kamath argued that appointments should not be confined to judges and practising advocates; B.R. Ambedkar accepted the principle but had reservations about the word "distinguished". The 42nd Amendment (1976) added a similar route for High Court judges in Article 217, and the 44th Amendment (1978) removed it. Reasons offered for the route's disuse include a view that Indian legal academia lacks the required distinction, the collegium's habit of choosing from High Courts and the Bar, and limits on full-time law teachers practising in court. Sceptics of the route say Supreme Court judges also decide appeals on evidence and procedure, where courtroom experience matters.

## Prelims facts

- Article 124(3) allows three routes to the Supreme Court: five years as a High Court judge, ten years as a High Court advocate, or being a distinguished jurist in the President's opinion.
- No distinguished jurist has ever been appointed; Justice Ujjal Bhuyan raised this at NLU Delhi's 13th convocation on 30 August 2026.
- The Constituent Assembly debated the route on 24 May 1949; H.V. Kamath pressed for going beyond judges and practising advocates.
- The 42nd Amendment (1976) added a distinguished jurist route for High Court judges under Article 217; the 44th Amendment (1978) removed it.
- Under the Third Judges case (1998), the Supreme Court collegium is the Chief Justice of India and the four senior-most judges.

## Quick recall

- **Which clause of Article 124 allows a distinguished jurist to be a Supreme Court judge?** Article 124(3)(c).
- **Who decides whether a person is a distinguished jurist?** The President, in his or her opinion.
- **How many years as a High Court judge qualify a person for the Supreme Court?** At least five years.
- **How many years as a High Court advocate qualify a person for the Supreme Court?** At least ten years.
- **Where did Justice Ujjal Bhuyan raise the jurist question?** At the 13th convocation of National Law University Delhi, 30 August 2026.
- **Which amendment added, and which removed, a distinguished jurist route for High Court judges?** Added by the 42nd Amendment (1976); removed by the 44th Amendment (1978).
- **Who make up the Supreme Court collegium for Supreme Court appointments?** The Chief Justice of India and the four senior-most judges (Third Judges case, 1998).
- **When was the NJAC struck down?** 16 October 2015.

## Prelims practice question

Under Article 124(3) of the Constitution of India, a citizen of India is qualified for appointment as a judge of the Supreme Court if he or she
1. has been a judge of a High Court for at least five years
2. has been an advocate of a High Court for at least ten years
3. is, in the opinion of the President, a distinguished jurist
Select the correct answer using the code given below.

(a) 1 and 2 only
(b) 2 and 3 only
(c) 1 and 3 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3

Answer: (d) 1, 2 and 3. All three are qualifying routes under Article 124(3)(a), (b) and (c). The third, the distinguished jurist route, has never been used, but it is valid in law.

## UPSC previous-year questions this connects to

- UPSC Mains 2025, GS2: Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q024-evolution-collegium-system-india-advantages-disadvantages-system/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Use the unused jurist route to add an eligibility dimension to the India-USA comparison: India's collegium draws only from judges and advocates, while the US has appointed academics.
- UPSC Mains 2017, GS2: Critically examine the Supreme Court's judgement on 'National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014' with reference to appointment of judges of higher judiciary in India. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q025-supreme-court-s-judgement-national-judicial-appointments/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Use the jurist debate to suggest that, within the collegium-led system, appointments need transparent criteria and a wider pool.
- UPSC Mains 2023, GS2: "Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy". Comment. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q026-constitutionally-guaranteed-judicial-independence-prerequisite-democracy/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Argue that a wider, more diverse pool of judges, including jurists, can strengthen an independent and credible judiciary.

## Mains practice question

The 'distinguished jurist' route under Article 124(3) has never been used. Discuss the reasons, and examine whether it should be revived to diversify the higher judiciary. (150 words)

### Model answer

Article 124(3)(c) allows the President to appoint a "distinguished jurist" to the Supreme Court, but the route has never been used in 76 years. Justice Ujjal Bhuyan raised this on 30 August 2026.

## Reasons for disuse
- The collegium draws from High Court judges and senior advocates whose work it has seen in court.
- A perception that Indian legal academia lacks the needed distinction.
- "Distinguished" is undefined, leaving no benchmark.
- Limits on full-time law teachers practising reduce their visibility.

## Why revive it
- Depth in constitutional and public law, beyond narrow technicalities.
- Diversity of experience on the Bench.
- Precedents abroad, such as Felix Frankfurter in the U.S.

## Cautions
- The Court also hears appeals on evidence and procedure, where courtroom experience helps.

## Way forward
- Set transparent criteria for "distinguished jurist" in the memorandum of procedure.

Used sparingly and transparently, the route can enrich the Court without weakening it.

## The basics

## Why this matters
The Constitution opens three doors to the Supreme Court. Two are used all the time; the third has stayed shut since 1950. On 30 August 2026 Justice Ujjal Bhuyan asked why. Prelims tests the exact qualifications; Mains asks about the collegium, diversity on the Bench and judicial reform.

## Three doors
Article 124(3) says a citizen of India is qualified to be a Supreme Court judge if he or she has been a High Court judge for at least five years, an advocate of a High Court for at least ten years, or is, in the opinion of the President, a distinguished jurist. See Article 124 and Supreme Court appointments.

## Where the idea came from
The framers debated the route in the Constituent Assembly in May 1949, as The jurist route in the Constituent Assembly explains. A similar clause was added for High Court judges in 1976 and removed in 1978, the story told in Article 217 and High Court judges.

## The argument today
Appointments are driven by the The collegium system, which in practice draws from High Court judges and senior advocates it knows. Justice Bhuyan argues that academics would add scholarship and diversity; the usual reply is that judges need courtroom experience.

## Sources

- https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/delhi/why-no-distinguished-jurist-appointed-as-supreme-court-judge-asks-justice-ujjal-bhuyan
- https://vajiramandravi.com/current-affairs/article-1243-and-the-unused-route-to-the-supreme-court/
- https://www.rostrumlegal.com/distinguished-jurist-a-tale-of-a-failed-constitutional-experiment/
- https://www.advocatekhoj.com/library/lawreports/methodofappointment/38.php?Title=Method+of+appointments+of+Judges&STitle=Articles+124+and+217
