# Punjab asks Centre to hold High Court Chief Justice appointment, citing MoP breach

URL: https://upsc.help/current-affairs/2026-09-07/punjab-hc-chief-justice-mop/
Date: 7 September 2026 (2026-09-07)
Source: Indian Express, Page 3
UPSC papers: GS2
Publisher: upsc.help (Pratidin), free and open-source UPSC Civil Services current affairs. Not affiliated with UPSC. Every fact was checked against the source reports by a separate review before publishing.

**In one line:** Punjab says the Centre appointed the Chief Justice of its High Court without taking the State's views, and wants the appointment put on hold.

The Punjab Cabinet has passed a resolution asking the Centre to put on hold the appointment of Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra as Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, the Indian Express reported on 7 September 2026. The State says the Centre went ahead without obtaining its views, in violation of the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP), the executive document that sets out the steps for appointing High Court judges. Justice Mishra had been the Acting Chief Justice of the High Court since June 2026. The Supreme Court Collegium recommended him on 6 August and the Centre notified the appointment on 5 September. Chief Minister Bhagwant Singh Mann wrote to the President, the Prime Minister and the Punjab Governor, enclosing the Cabinet resolution.

According to the report, the MoP conventionally requires the Centre to seek the State government's views, but it lays down no time limit for them. Mann also linked the episode to other disputes with the Centre, including over the Rural Development Fund and changes to the rules of the Bhakra Beas Management Board. The Punjab and Haryana High Court Bar Association opposed the State's stand and cautioned against executive interference in judicial appointments. A separate Indian Express report noted that the appointment was one of eight recent Chief Justice appointments, seven of them made on the Collegium's recommendations of 6 and 31 August and one separately for Chhattisgarh, after which all 25 High Courts have regular Chief Justices.

The constitutional frame is Article 217: a High Court judge is appointed by the President after consultation with the Chief Justice of India (CJI), the Governor of the State and, for judges other than the Chief Justice, the Chief Justice of that High Court. Since the Punjab and Haryana High Court is a common High Court for Punjab, Haryana and the Union Territory of Chandigarh, Article 231 reads the reference to the Governor as the Governors of all the States concerned. After the Second (1993) and Third (1998) Judges Cases, a High Court Chief Justice is recommended by a collegium of the CJI and the two senior-most Supreme Court judges, and the State's role is consultative. Punjab's case is that consultation has meaning only if the State is actually heard. The Bar Association sees the demand as executive overreach. The MoP itself follows a policy of appointing Chief Justices from outside their own State, which is meant to keep local influence away from the office.

## Prelims facts

- Article 217(1) requires the President to consult the Chief Justice of India and the Governor of the State before appointing a High Court judge, and also the High Court's Chief Justice for judges other than the Chief Justice.
- For a common High Court, Article 231 makes the reference to the Governor in Article 217 mean the Governors of all the States over which the court has jurisdiction.
- Under the collegium system, a High Court Chief Justice is recommended by the CJI and the two senior-most judges of the Supreme Court, and the MoP's policy is to appoint Chief Justices from outside the State.
- Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra, Acting Chief Justice since June 2026, was recommended on 6 August and notified as Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court on 5 September 2026.
- Article 223 lets the President appoint an Acting Chief Justice when the office of Chief Justice of a High Court is vacant.

## Quick recall

- **Which Article provides for the appointment of High Court judges?** Article 217.
- **Whom must the President consult before appointing a High Court Chief Justice?** The Chief Justice of India and the Governor of the State (Article 217(1)).
- **Which Article allows a common High Court for two or more States?** Article 231.
- **Which Article provides for an Acting Chief Justice of a High Court?** Article 223.
- **Retirement age of a High Court judge?** 62 years.
- **Who forms the collegium for High Court appointments?** The CJI and the two senior-most judges of the Supreme Court.
- **Which case gave primacy to the judiciary in appointments?** The Second Judges Case (1993).
- **Which territories does the Punjab and Haryana High Court serve?** Punjab, Haryana and the Union Territory of Chandigarh.

## Prelims practice question

Under Article 217(1) of the Constitution of India, the President must consult which of the following before appointing the Chief Justice of a High Court?
1. The Chief Justice of India
2. The Governor of the State
3. The Chief Justice of that High Court
4. The Chief Minister of the State
Select the correct answer using the code given below.

(a) 1 and 2 only
(b) 1, 2 and 3 only
(c) 1, 2 and 4 only
(d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 1 and 2 only. Article 217(1) names the Chief Justice of India and the Governor of the State for every High Court judge, and adds the Chief Justice of the High Court only for judges other than the Chief Justice. The Chief Minister is not named in the Constitution; the State government's views are sought under the Memorandum of Procedure, and the Governor acts on the advice of the State Council of Ministers.

## UPSC previous-year questions this connects to

- UPSC Mains 2025, GS2: Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q024-evolution-collegium-system-india-advantages-disadvantages-system/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Use the Punjab dispute as a current example of how the collegium system works for High Court Chief Justices and where the executive and States fit.
- UPSC Mains 2017, GS2: Critically examine the Supreme Court's judgement on 'National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014' with reference to appointment of judges of higher judiciary in India. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q025-supreme-court-s-judgement-national-judicial-appointments/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Use the Punjab episode to show that, with the collegium in place, gaps in the Memorandum of Procedure still cause friction, and to propose MoP reform.

## Mains practice question

The Constitution requires the Governor to be consulted in the appointment of High Court judges, yet the collegium system has made the State's role marginal. Critically examine in the light of recent friction over judicial appointments. (250 words)

### Model answer

Article 217 requires the President to consult the Chief Justice of India (CJI) and the Governor before appointing a High Court judge. Punjab's demand in September 2026 that the Chief Justice appointment to the Punjab and Haryana High Court be put on hold, because its views were not obtained, revives the question of the State's role.

## Why the State's role has shrunk
- The Second (1993) and Third (1998) Judges Cases gave primacy to the judiciary's opinion, exercised through the collegium.
- A High Court Chief Justice is recommended by the CJI and the two senior-most Supreme Court judges; the Governor acts on the State government's advice and is only consulted.
- The Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) asks the Centre to seek the State's views but sets no time limit, so the process can move on without them.

## Why the State's role still matters
- Article 231 requires consultation with every State served by a common High Court, a sign that the Constitution wants every State concerned to be heard.
- Effective consultation builds trust; its absence feeds Centre-State friction.

## Concerns about the State's demand
- A State veto would expose judicial appointments to political bargaining and threaten judicial independence.
- The Bar Association has warned against executive interference.

## Way forward
- A revised MoP with fixed timelines for the State's views, after which the file proceeds.
- Recorded reasons when State objections are overruled.

The State's voice should be heard in time, but it cannot become a veto over judicial appointments.

## The basics

## Why this matters
Who gets a say in appointing High Court judges? The Constitution gives the executive a role, including the State through its Governor, but Supreme Court judgments have moved the real decision to judges. Punjab's objection to the appointment of the Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in September 2026 shows the gap between the text and the practice. To follow the debate, you need the basics of Article 217 and High Court appointments, The Judges Cases, which built the collegium, and the Memorandum of Procedure that runs the process.

## What the Constitution says
Article 217(1) says the President appoints a High Court judge after consulting the Chief Justice of India, the Governor of the State and, for judges other than the Chief Justice, the Chief Justice of the High Court. Some High Courts serve more than one State or Union Territory; for them Article 231 makes 'the Governor' mean the Governors of all the States concerned. The Punjab and Haryana High Court, for example, serves Punjab, Haryana and Chandigarh, which is why it is a Common High Courts under Article 231.

## How the collegium came to decide
In the First Judges Case (1981), the Supreme Court held that 'consultation' did not mean 'concurrence', which left the executive with the final say. The Second Judges Case (1993) reversed this and gave primacy to the opinion of the CJI, formed with senior colleagues. The Third Judges Case (1998) fixed the collegium's size. In 2015 the Court struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission, so the collegium continues.

## How a Chief Justice is appointed today
The steps are set out in the MoP, an executive document, not a law.

## The tension
The State's role is real in the text but thin in practice. A revised MoP with timelines would let the State be heard without holding a veto.

## Sources

- https://superkalam.com/current-affairs/07-09-2026/state-consent-not-taken-put-hc-chief-justice-appointment-on-hold-punjab-govt-pg3-13eaee50-82eb-471c-b590-35a12eca944a
- https://superkalam.com/current-affairs/07-09-2026/next-on-collegium-agenda-filling-up-vacancies-in-supreme-court-pg8-7d46d20f-b906-44b9-b1b3-8c68586d4dc7
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punjab_and_Haryana_High_Court
