# Supreme Court strikes down Maharashtra's methanol rules, calls prohibition no solution

URL: https://upsc.help/current-affairs/2026-09-20/sc-methanol-rules-prohibition/
Date: 20 September 2026 (2026-09-20)
Source: The Hindu, Page 9
UPSC papers: GS2, GS3
Publisher: upsc.help (Pratidin), free and open-source UPSC Civil Services current affairs. Not affiliated with UPSC. Every fact was checked against the source reports by a separate review before publishing.

**In one line:** The Supreme Court struck down Maharashtra's rules requiring methanol to be dyed and made bitter, and observed that 'forced temperance is not a solution to alcoholism'.

The Hindu reported on 20 September 2026 that a Supreme Court Bench headed by Justice J.B. Pardiwala has struck down Rules 18A and 18B of the Maharashtra Poisons Rules, 1972, holding that they violate Article 14 (equality before law) and Article 19(1)(g) (freedom to practise any profession or carry on any trade or business). Rule 18A allowed methanol to be sold only to holders of a 'Form A' licence and required sellers to mix a colourant (methylene carmine) and a bitterant (denatonium saccharide) into methanol before selling it to anyone other than drug manufacturers. Rule 18B allowed unlicensed methanol to be confiscated. Methanol is a toxic industrial alcohol: when it is passed off as drinkable liquor it can cause blindness, organ failure and death. The rules were Maharashtra's response to the 1991 hooch tragedy in Mumbai.

Applying the proportionality test, the Court accepted that preventing hooch deaths is a legitimate aim but found the rules neither suitable nor necessary: dyeing methanol does not touch the real causes, which are pilferage and corruption, while it burdens lawful users such as paint makers. The Court observed that 'forced temperance is not a solution to alcoholism'. It pointed to Gujarat, a dry State since 1960 under the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949, where more than 10 major hooch tragedies have killed over 600 people, and to recent tragedies in Bhavnagar (Gujarat) and Sagar (Madhya Pradesh) that killed 13 and 15 people. It listed 'five evils' of prohibition: loss of tax revenue, high enforcement costs, corruption in the police and excise departments, illegal distilling, and a rise in the drug menace.

Instead, the Bench asked authorities to break illicit liquor supply chains, tighten vigilance at inter-State borders, watch for chemical solvents being diverted to unlicensed producers, and move methanol only in dedicated tankers to prevent pilferage. The constitutional frame is layered. Article 47, a Directive Principle, asks the State to 'endeavour to bring about prohibition' of intoxicating drinks except for medicinal purposes, but Directive Principles cannot be enforced in court (Article 37). Intoxicating liquor is a State subject (Entry 8 of List II), so policy varies: Gujarat, Bihar (since April 2016), Nagaland (since 1989) and Mizoram (reimposed in 2019) prohibit liquor. Supporters of prohibition cite Article 47 and harm to families; the Court's observations side with critics who say bans push the trade underground. The ruling itself strikes down only the Maharashtra methanol rules, not any State's prohibition law.

## Prelims facts

- The Supreme Court struck down Rules 18A and 18B of the Maharashtra Poisons Rules, 1972 for violating Articles 14 and 19(1)(g).
- Rule 18A required a colourant (methylene carmine) and a bitterant (denatonium saccharide) to be mixed into methanol sold to buyers other than drug manufacturers.
- The Court observed that 'forced temperance is not a solution to alcoholism', citing more than 600 deaths in over 10 major hooch tragedies in dry Gujarat since 1960.
- Article 47, a Directive Principle, asks the State to endeavour to bring about prohibition of intoxicating drinks except for medicinal purposes; it is not enforceable in court.
- Intoxicating liquor falls in Entry 8 of the State List, which is why prohibition differs from State to State.

## Quick recall

- **Which rules did the Supreme Court strike down in September 2026?** Rules 18A and 18B of the Maharashtra Poisons Rules, 1972.
- **Which Articles did the struck-down rules violate?** Article 14 (equality) and Article 19(1)(g) (freedom of trade and business).
- **What did Rule 18A require sellers to add to methanol?** A colourant, methylene carmine, and a bitterant, denatonium saccharide.
- **Which Article asks the State to endeavour to bring about prohibition?** Article 47, a Directive Principle of State Policy.
- **Where are intoxicating liquors placed in the Seventh Schedule?** Entry 8 of List II (State List).
- **Under which law has Gujarat enforced prohibition since 1960?** The Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949.
- **What are the 'five evils' of prohibition the Court listed?** Loss of tax revenue, high enforcement costs, police and excise corruption, illegal distilling and a rise in the drug menace.
- **Since when has Bihar had total prohibition?** April 2016.

## Prelims practice question

With reference to the Constitution of India, consider the following statements:
1. Article 47 directs the State to endeavour to bring about prohibition of the consumption of intoxicating drinks, except for medicinal purposes.
2. Intoxicating liquors are a subject in the Union List of the Seventh Schedule.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

(a) 1 only
(b) 2 only
(c) Both 1 and 2
(d) Neither 1 nor 2

Answer: (a) 1 only. Statement 1 is correct: Article 47 (a Directive Principle) asks the State to endeavour to bring about prohibition of intoxicating drinks and injurious drugs, except for medicinal purposes. Statement 2 is incorrect: intoxicating liquors are in Entry 8 of List II (State List), which is why each State sets its own liquor policy.

## UPSC previous-year questions this connects to

- UPSC Prelims 2021, Prelims: A legislation which confers on the executive or administrative authority an unguided and uncontrolled discretionary power in the matter of application of law violates which one of the following articles of the Constitution of India? (a) Article 14 (b) Article 28 (c) Article 32 (d) Article 44 (https://upsc.help/pyq/q115-legislation-confers-executive-administrative-authority-unguided-uncontrolled/)
- UPSC Mains 2017, GS2: Examine the scope of Fundamental Rights in the light of the latest judgement of the Supreme Court on Right to Privacy. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q125-scope-fundamental-rights-light-latest-judgement-supreme/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Use as a recent example of the Supreme Court applying the proportionality test to define the scope of Articles 14 and 19(1)(g).

## Mains practice question

"Forced temperance is not a solution to alcoholism." In the light of the Supreme Court's recent observation, examine whether prohibition is the right way to give effect to Article 47 of the Constitution. (250 words)

### Model answer

Article 47 asks the State to endeavour to bring about prohibition of intoxicating drinks. Striking down Maharashtra's methanol rules in September 2026, the Supreme Court observed that 'forced temperance is not a solution to alcoholism'.

## The case for prohibition
- **Constitutional mandate:** Article 47 links prohibition to public health and nutrition.
- **Social harm:** alcohol abuse drives domestic violence and household debt; women's groups have often led demands for bans.
- **State competence:** liquor is in Entry 8 of List II, so States such as Gujarat, Bihar, Nagaland and Mizoram have chosen bans.

## The case against
- **Hooch deaths continue:** Gujarat, dry since 1960, has had more than 10 major hooch tragedies with over 600 deaths, the Court noted.
- **'Five evils':** lost tax revenue, high enforcement costs, police and excise corruption, illegal distilling and a rise in drug use.
- **Rights and proportionality:** blunt curbs on lawful trade must pass the proportionality test under Article 19(1)(g) and cannot be arbitrary under Article 14.

## A better route to Article 47
- **Supply-chain control:** track methanol, move it in dedicated tankers and check diversion of solvents, as the Court directed.
- **Enforcement against bootleggers:** inter-State border vigilance and action against collusion.
- **Public health approach:** de-addiction services, awareness and regulated, taxed sale.
- **Local choice:** community-led restrictions rather than blanket State-wide bans.

Article 47 is best served by reducing harm from alcohol, which regulation and public health can achieve better than a ban that drives the trade underground.

## The basics

## Why this matters
The Constitution asks the State to work towards prohibition, yet the Supreme Court has now said that 'forced temperance is not a solution to alcoholism'. The case was about a narrow set of rules on methanol in Maharashtra, but the Court's reasoning touches three things UPSC tests often: how Article 47 and prohibition works as a Directive Principle, how courts judge limits on trade under Article 19(1)(g) and reasonable restrictions, and the Proportionality test.

## What the rules did
Methanol is an industrial alcohol used in paints and solvents. It resembles the ethanol in drinks, so bootleggers mix it into cheap liquor. After the 1991 hooch tragedy in Mumbai, Maharashtra's rules tried to make methanol impossible to pass off as liquor.

## Why the Court struck them down
The Court accepted that stopping hooch deaths is a legitimate aim. But a restriction on a fundamental right must also be suitable and necessary. Dyeing methanol does not stop pilferage from tankers or collusion by officials, which is how methanol actually reaches bootleggers, while it adds cost for honest users such as paint makers. So the rules failed the test and were held arbitrary under Article 14 and an unreasonable restriction under Article 19(1)(g).

## The prohibition paradox
The Court went further and looked at prohibition itself. Gujarat has been dry since it was formed in 1960, under the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949. Yet the Court noted more than 10 major hooch tragedies there with over 600 deaths. A ban removes the legal, tested product, so drinkers turn to unregulated brews where Methanol and hooch tragedies become likely.

## The takeaway
Article 47 sets a goal, not a method. The method must work in practice and respect rights: control the supply of dangerous chemicals and act against bootleggers.

## Sources

- https://superkalam.com/current-affairs/20-09-2026/prohibition-is-no-solution-to-alcoholism-top-court-pg9-00fe03d4-cdf9-4938-be90-b2581d487786
- https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-updates/daily-news-analysis/sc-strikes-down-maharashtra-methanol-rules
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibition_in_India
