# A Supreme Court judge defends the Collegium and hits back at the Centre

URL: https://upsc.help/current-affairs/2026-09-24/collegium-defence/
Date: 24 September 2026 (2026-09-24)
Source: The Hindu, Page 12
UPSC papers: 
Publisher: upsc.help (Pratidin), free and open-source UPSC Civil Services current affairs. Not affiliated with UPSC. Every fact was checked against the source reports by a separate review before publishing.

**In one line:** The Collegium lets senior judges choose judges, and the latest clash is over who is really responsible for delays and vacancies.

Supreme Court judge Justice Dipankar Datta defended the Collegium system and said the clamour against it was a weak attempt to hide the government's own dereliction and failure. The Court described the government's recent remarks on the Collegium as 'disquieting'.

The exchange revives a long-running dispute over judicial appointments. Justice Datta has argued on earlier occasions that the idea of 'judges appointing judges' is misleading, because the government delays or does not act on many Collegium recommendations; he said in 2025 that a recommendation he had made as a Calcutta High Court Collegium member in 2019 was still pending. He has also criticised the Collegium's own opacity, remarking in March 2026 that even judges often do not know when it meets.

The Collegium system was created by the Second Judges Case (1993) and the Third Judges Case (1998). Parliament's attempt to replace it with the National Judicial Appointments Commission through the 99th Amendment (2014) was struck down by the Supreme Court in 2015, and the Memorandum of Procedure for appointments has still not been finalised.

## Prelims facts

- The Collegium emerged from the Second Judges Case (1993) and the Third Judges Case (1998).
- The 99th Amendment (2014) created the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which the Supreme Court struck down in 2015.
- Articles 124 and 217 govern the appointment of Supreme Court and High Court judges.

## Quick recall

- **Which cases created the Collegium system?** The Second Judges Case (1993) and the Third Judges Case (1998).
- **What did the First Judges Case (S.P. Gupta, 1981) hold?** That 'consultation' with the CJI did not mean concurrence, giving the executive primacy.
- **Which amendment created the NJAC?** The 99th Constitutional Amendment (2014).
- **When was the NJAC struck down?** In October 2015, in the Fourth Judges Case.
- **Who makes up the Supreme Court Collegium?** The Chief Justice of India and the four senior-most judges.
- **Which Articles govern appointment of Supreme Court and High Court judges?** Article 124 (Supreme Court) and Article 217 (High Courts).
- **What is the Memorandum of Procedure?** The document setting out the process for judicial appointments; a revised version has still not been finalised.
- **What is Justice Dipankar Datta's argument on the Collegium?** That 'judges appointing judges' is misleading, because the government delays or ignores many Collegium recommendations.

## Prelims practice question

The National Judicial Appointments Commission was created by which Constitutional Amendment?

(a) 97th
(b) 99th
(c) 101st
(d) 103rd

Answer: (b) 99th. The 99th Amendment (2014) created the NJAC; the Supreme Court struck it down in October 2015.

## UPSC previous-year questions this connects to

- UPSC Mains 2025, GS2: Discuss the evolution of collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q024-evolution-collegium-system-india-advantages-disadvantages-system/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Supplies the evolution of the Collegium, its defence and its criticisms for the Indian half of the answer.
- UPSC Mains 2025, GS2: "Constitutional morality is the fulcrum which acts as an essential check upon the high functionaries and citizens alike..." In view of the above observation of the Supreme Court, explain the concept of constitutional morality and its application to ensure balance between judicial independence and judicial accountability in India. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q027-constitutional-morality-fulcrum-acts-essential-check-upon/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Gives the independence versus accountability tension in judicial appointments and reforms that could balance the two.
- UPSC Mains 2023, GS2: "Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy". Comment. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q026-constitutionally-guaranteed-judicial-independence-prerequisite-democracy/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Use the Collegium row as a current example of how control over appointments is tied to judicial independence from the executive.
- UPSC Mains 2017, GS2: Critically examine the Supreme Court's judgement on 'National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014' with reference to appointment of judges of higher judiciary in India. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q025-supreme-court-s-judgement-national-judicial-appointments/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Gives the grounds and aftermath of the NJAC judgment, showing that the appointment dispute it settled remains alive.

## Mains practice question

The Collegium system protects judicial independence but lacks transparency. Evaluate the debate and suggest reforms. (250 words)

### Model answer

Under Articles 124 and 217, judges are appointed by the President after consultation with the judiciary. The Supreme Court's Second (1993) and Third (1998) Judges Cases turned 'consultation' into 'concurrence', creating the Collegium of senior judges.

## Case for the Collegium
- Insulates appointments from executive influence, protecting judicial independence, a part of the basic structure.
- The NJAC was struck down in 2015 because it gave the executive and non-judicial members a potential veto.

## Criticisms
- **Opacity:** no published criteria, reasons or records.
- **Nepotism and limited diversity:** few women, SC/ST and OBC judges.
- **Delays:** the Memorandum of Procedure is still not finalised; the government sits on names and the Collegium reiterates them, leaving vacancies.

## The present dispute
The Court argues that most delays arise from the government's failure to clear names, while the government questions the Collegium's accountability. Both share responsibility for pendency of over five crore cases.

## Reforms
- Finalise the Memorandum of Procedure with timelines for both sides.
- Publish eligibility criteria and reasons for selection.
- A permanent secretariat to assess candidates, as suggested in the 2015 NJAC judgment.
- Deemed approval if the government does not act within a fixed period.

Independence and accountability are not opposites. A transparent Collegium with enforceable timelines can deliver both.

## The basics

## Why this matters

Who appoints judges decides how independent the judiciary is. The Collegium system lets senior judges choose, and it faces criticism for opacity. In September 2026, a Supreme Court judge pushed back, arguing that the government's own delays are a bigger problem.

## From consultation to concurrence

The Constitution says the President appoints judges after consultation with the judiciary. The Supreme Court's reading of that word changed over three cases, creating the Collegium.

## Why the NJAC failed

The National Judicial Appointments Commission included the Law Minister and two eminent persons, and any two members could block a candidate. The Court held that this threatened judicial independence, part of the Basic structure doctrine.

## How an appointment moves

Even under the Collegium, the government has a role.

## What is unsolved

The Memorandum of Procedure is still not finalised, there are no timelines for the government to act, and the Collegium's criteria are not published. Both sides blame each other for vacancies.

## You now know
- The Collegium came from the Second (1993) and Third (1998) Judges Cases.
- The 99th Amendment's NJAC was struck down in 2015 to protect judicial independence.
- The Supreme Court Collegium is the CJI and four senior-most judges.
- The Memorandum of Procedure and timelines for the government remain unresolved.

