# Op-ed: Split verdict on the Election Commissioners Act exposes how the Supreme Court sits

URL: https://upsc.help/current-affairs/2026-10-03/cec-act-split-verdict-oped/
Date: 3 October 2026 (2026-10-03)
Source: The Hindu, Page 6
UPSC papers: GS2
Publisher: upsc.help (Pratidin), free and open-source UPSC Civil Services current affairs. Not affiliated with UPSC. Every fact was checked against the source reports by a separate review before publishing.

**In one line:** Two Supreme Court judges split on whether a Constitution Bench must hear the challenge to the 2023 law on appointing Election Commissioners, and a Hindu op-ed says the split reflects flaws in how the Court is organised.

A two-judge bench of the Supreme Court, Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, has delivered a split verdict in the challenge to the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023. The judges differed not on whether the law is valid but on whether a bench of two could decide that at all. Article 145(3) of the Constitution requires a bench of at least five judges for any case involving a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution. Justice Datta read this as applying where there are genuinely differing interpretations of a constitutional provision, not to every challenge to a new statute. Justice Sharma held that, with no authoritative precedent on the 2023 Act, a Constitution Bench should hear it. The judges jointly referred the matter to the Chief Justice of India to consider setting up a Constitution Bench.

The 2023 Act followed Anoop Baranwal v Union of India (March 2023), in which the Supreme Court held that, until Parliament made a law, the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners would be appointed on the advice of a committee of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and the Chief Justice of India. Before that ruling, the President appointed them on the recommendation of the Prime Minister. The 2023 Act kept the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition but replaced the Chief Justice with a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. Critics say this gives the government a two-to-one majority in choosing the officials who run elections; supporters of the law say Parliament has simply made the law that the Court's interim arrangement was waiting for.

The article, published in The Hindu on 3 October 2026, argues that the split is a symptom of the Court's design. It says heavy reliance on two-judge benches produces inconsistent rulings; that long delays can make decisions stale, noting that the Anoop Baranwal case took eight years; and that the Chief Justice's power as Master of the Roster needs transparent, pre-settled rules for composing benches. It recalls that the Law Commission's 229th Report (2009) proposed a permanent Constitution Bench in Delhi, with regional benches to hear ordinary appeals. In 2018, ruling on a petition by former law minister Shanti Bhushan, the Court held that the Chief Justice is the Master of the Roster; defenders of the present system also cite the flexibility that small benches give a court with a very large caseload.

## Prelims facts

- Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma split on whether a Constitution Bench must hear the challenge to the CEC and other Election Commissioners Act, 2023, and jointly referred the matter to the Chief Justice of India.
- Article 145(3) requires at least five judges to decide a case involving a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution.
- In Anoop Baranwal v Union of India (March 2023), the Supreme Court set an interim selection committee of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition and the Chief Justice of India.
- The 2023 Act's selection committee is the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.
- The Law Commission's 229th Report (2009) proposed a permanent Constitution Bench in Delhi with regional benches for ordinary appeals.

## Quick recall

- **Which two judges split over the challenge to the 2023 Election Commissioners Act?** Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma.
- **What did the two judges jointly do after splitting?** Referred the matter to the Chief Justice of India to consider setting up a Constitution Bench.
- **What does Article 145(3) require?** At least five judges for a case involving a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution, or a reference under Article 143.
- **Selection committee under Anoop Baranwal (2023)?** The Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and the Chief Justice of India, until Parliament made a law.
- **Selection committee under the 2023 Act?** The Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.
- **Which Article of the Constitution is the source of the Election Commission's powers?** Article 324.
- **Which Law Commission report proposed a permanent Constitution Bench in Delhi?** The 229th Report (2009), with regional benches for ordinary appeals.
- **Which 2018 case upheld the Chief Justice as Master of the Roster?** Shanti Bhushan v Supreme Court of India.

## Prelims practice question

Consider the following statements:
1. Article 145(3) of the Constitution requires at least five judges to decide a case involving a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution.
2. Under the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners Act, 2023, the Chief Justice of India is a member of the selection committee.
3. Before March 2023, Election Commissioners were appointed by the President on the recommendation of the Prime Minister.
Which of the statements given above are correct?

(a) 1 and 2 only
(b) 2 and 3 only
(c) 1 and 3 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3

Answer: (c) 1 and 3 only. Statement 1 is correct. Statement 2 is wrong: the 2023 Act's committee is the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister; the Chief Justice was on the interim committee set by Anoop Baranwal. Statement 3 is correct: that was the practice until the Anoop Baranwal ruling of March 2023.

## UPSC previous-year questions this connects to

- UPSC Mains 2023, GS2: "Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy". Comment. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q026-constitutionally-guaranteed-judicial-independence-prerequisite-democracy/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Use it to show that independence depends on who appoints key constitutional officials and on how the Supreme Court organises itself, both under strain in the CEC Act challenge.
- UPSC Prelims 2017, Prelims: Consider the following statements: 1. The Election Commission of India is a five-member body. 2. Union Ministry of Home Affairs decides the election schedule for the conduct of both general elections and bye-elections. 3. Election Commission resolves the disputes relating to splits/mergers of recognised political parties. Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 3 only (https://upsc.help/pyq/q004-consider-following-statements-1-election-commission-india/)
- UPSC Mains 2015, GS2: To achieve the desired objectives, it is necessary to ensure that the regulatory institutions remain independent and autonomous. Discuss in the light of experiences in the recent past. (https://upsc.help/pyq/q304-achieve-desired-objectives-necessary-ensure-regulatory-institutions/)
  How to use this story in the answer: Use the dispute over the selection committee for Election Commissioners as a recent experience of the contest over keeping a key institution autonomous from the executive.

## Mains practice question

The split verdict on whether a Constitution Bench must hear the challenge to the Election Commissioners Act, 2023 has revived the debate on how the Supreme Court is organised. Examine the case for a permanent Constitution Bench in India. (250 words)

### Model answer

A two-judge bench of the Supreme Court recently split on whether a challenge to the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners Act, 2023 must go to a Constitution Bench under Article 145(3), and referred the question to the Chief Justice of India. The episode shows how the Court's structure shapes its outcomes.

## Why the present design strains
- **Two-judge benches dominate:** the Court sits mostly in small benches, so rulings on similar questions can conflict.
- **Delay:** Anoop Baranwal took eight years; the op-ed warns such delay can make decisions moot.
- **Master of the Roster:** the op-ed says the Chief Justice's power to compose benches needs transparent, pre-settled rules; Shanti Bhushan v Supreme Court of India (2018) upheld the power itself.
- **Article 145(3) unclear:** judges can differ on when a five-judge bench is needed.

## The case for a permanent Constitution Bench
- **Consistency:** a standing bench would settle constitutional questions with authority.
- **Speed:** important matters such as the 2023 Act would not wait for ad hoc benches.
- **Law Commission support:** the 229th Report (2009) proposed a permanent Constitution Bench in Delhi with regional benches for ordinary appeals.

## Concerns
- Regional benches could dilute the Court's unity and raise forum shopping.
- A fixed bench may concentrate power in a few judges.
- Small benches give flexibility for a very large caseload.

## Way forward
- Publish roster and listing criteria.
- Refer substantial constitutional questions to five-judge benches early.

## Conclusion
The split verdict is less about one law than about a Court whose architecture needs to match its constitutional role.

## The basics

## Why this matters
The Election Commission conducts every election in India, and who appoints its members is a question about the fairness of democracy itself. A recent split verdict adds a second question: how the Supreme Court decides which judges hear such cases. Both are core GS2 themes.

## How Election Commissioners are chosen
The Election Commission draws its powers from Article 324. The President appoints the CEC and Election Commissioners, and until 2023 did so on the recommendation of the Prime Minister. Anoop Baranwal v Union of India filled the gap; Parliament then passed the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners Act, 2023.

## The bench question
Under Article 145(3) and Constitution Benches, a case involving a substantial question of law on interpreting the Constitution needs at least five judges.

## What happened, step by step

## The bigger design problem
The Chief Justice decides which judges hear which case as the Master of the Roster. The op-ed argues that heavy use of two-judge benches causes inconsistency and delay, and that the roster power needs transparent, pre-settled rules. The Law Commission's 229th Report (2009) proposed a permanent Constitution Bench in Delhi with regional benches for ordinary appeals.

## The takeaway
The merits of the 2023 Act are still undecided. What the split has settled is that the Court's own structure is now part of the debate.

## Sources

- https://superkalam.com/current-affairs/03-10-2026/a-court-divided-by-its-own-architecture-pg6-5d100f8d-653c-4027-98e5-430296fd448d
- https://superkalam.com/current-affairs/03-10-2026
