Pratidin
Polity and governance15 November 2026The Hindu, NationGS2GS1

Karnataka CM asks PM to place the State's 56% SC/ST quota law in the Ninth Schedule

In one line: After the Karnataka High Court struck down its 56% SC/ST quota law, the State has asked the Prime Minister to protect the law by placing it in the Ninth Schedule.

Published 15 November 2026. Written by Pratidin from the reports linked at the end; every fact checked by a separate review before publishing. How we work

Karnataka Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar has written to Prime Minister Narendra Modi asking that the State's enhanced reservation law be placed in the Ninth Schedule of the Constitution. The law is the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation of Seats in Educational Institutions and of Appointments or Posts in the Services under the State) Act, 2022 (Karnataka Act No. 1 of 2023). It raised the SC quota from 15% to 17% and the ST quota from 3% to 7%. With the 32% for Other Backward Classes unchanged, total reservation rose from 50% to 56%. The Act got the Governor's assent on 11 January 2023 and took effect from 1 November 2022. The letter asks the Union Law, Social Justice, Tribal Affairs and Home Ministries to carry out a coordinated, time-bound review so that a constitutional route can be placed before Parliament.

The request follows the Karnataka High Court's judgment of 12 October 2026. A Division Bench of Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice K.S. Hemalekha struck down Sections 3 and 4 of the Act. It held that taking total reservation above 50% violated Articles 14, 15 and 16, applying the ceiling set in Indra Sawhney (1992). It rejected the State's argument that the 10% EWS quota had removed the ceiling for other groups. It also found that the State had not consulted the National Commissions for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, as Articles 338(9) and 338A(9) require; letters sent in December 2025 and January 2026 came too late, because 'consultation, to be meaningful and effective, must precede the decision.' The State has appealed to the Supreme Court.

The letter says the quotas had not changed since 1958, while Census 2011 put SCs at 17.15% and STs at 6.95% of Karnataka's population. The 17% and 7% figures came from a commission headed by retired High Court judge H.N. Nagamohan Das, which also recommended Ninth Schedule protection. The State first sent a proposal on 23 March 2023, the Assembly passed a resolution on 18 December 2025, and then Chief Minister Siddaramaiah wrote to the Prime Minister on 16 April 2026. On 25 July 2026, the Union government told the Lok Sabha that inclusion was not appropriate while the case was pending in the High Court. Mr. Shivakumar cites Tamil Nadu's 69% law, placed in the Ninth Schedule by the 76th Amendment in 1994. But under I.R. Coelho (2007), laws added after 24 April 1973 can still be tested against the basic structure.

Practise this in the app: flashcards, quiz and a timed answer
Prelims

Prelims facts

  • Karnataka's 2022 Act raised SC reservation from 15% to 17% and ST reservation from 3% to 7%, taking the total from 50% to 56%.
  • The Karnataka High Court struck down Sections 3 and 4 of the Act on 12 October 2026 for breaching the 50% ceiling and for not consulting the NCSC and NCST under Articles 338(9) and 338A(9).
  • Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule were added by the First Amendment, 1951; Tamil Nadu's 69% law was placed there by the 76th Amendment, 1994.
  • Under I.R. Coelho (2007), laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 remain open to challenge for violating the basic structure.
  • The Union told the Lok Sabha on 25 July 2026 that Ninth Schedule inclusion was not appropriate while the case was pending in the High Court.

Quick recall

By how much did Karnataka's 2022 Act raise SC reservation?
From 15% to 17%.
By how much did it raise ST reservation?
From 3% to 7%.
Which amendment added Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule?
The First Amendment, 1951.
Which amendment placed Tamil Nadu's 69% reservation law in the Ninth Schedule?
The 76th Amendment, 1994.
What cut-off date did I.R. Coelho (2007) use?
24 April 1973, the date of the Kesavananda Bharati judgment.
Which Articles require consultation with the NCSC and NCST?
Article 338(9) and Article 338A(9).
Who headed the commission that recommended 17% for SCs and 7% for STs in Karnataka?
Justice H.N. Nagamohan Das, a retired Karnataka High Court judge.
When did the Karnataka High Court strike down the 56% law?
12 October 2026.

Prelims practice question

With reference to the Ninth Schedule of the Constitution of India, consider the following statements:
1. It was added by the Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951, along with Article 31B.
2. A law can be placed in it only by a constitutional amendment that is ratified by at least half of the State legislatures.
3. Laws placed in it after 24 April 1973 can be examined by courts for violation of the basic structure.
Which of the statements given above are correct?

  1. 1 and 2 only
  2. 2 and 3 only
  3. 1 and 3 only
  4. 1, 2 and 3
Show answer

Answer: (c) 1 and 3 only. Statement 1 is correct: the First Amendment, 1951 inserted Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule. Statement 2 is wrong: inclusion needs a constitutional amendment passed by a special majority of Parliament under Article 368, but State ratification is not required because the Ninth Schedule is not among the entrenched provisions in the proviso to Article 368(2). Statement 3 is correct: this is the I.R. Coelho (2007) holding.

Use this in UPSC Mains: previous-year questions

Recurring theme: The Ninth Schedule, judicial review and the 50% ceiling on reservation

  1. 2016 · GS2 · 12.5 marksAnswers it directlyUse it in the example

    What was held in the Coelho case? In this context, can you say that judicial review is of key importance amongst the basic features of the Constitution?

    How to use this

    Use Karnataka's 2026 request to show why, after Coelho, Ninth Schedule protection cannot bar judicial review of a post-1973 law.

    • Karnataka High Court struck down the 56% SC/ST quota law on 12 October 2026 for breaching the Indra Sawhney 50% ceiling under Articles 14, 15 and 16.
    • The State now seeks Ninth Schedule cover, citing Tamil Nadu's 69% law protected by the 76th Amendment, 1994.
    • Any new entry would postdate 24 April 1973, so courts could still test it against equality, a basic feature.
  2. 2022 · GS2 · 10 marksCovers one partUse it in the body

    Discuss the role of the National Commission for Backward Classes in the wake of its transformation from a statutory body to a constitutional body.

    How to use this

    Show that constitutional commissions for weaker sections have binding consultation powers, using the Karnataka High Court's 2026 ruling on Articles 338(9) and 338A(9).

    • Karnataka High Court held consultation with the NCSC and NCST mandatory and said it must precede the decision.
    • Letters sent in December 2025 and January 2026, years after the Act, did not satisfy Articles 338(9) and 338A(9).
Prelims
  1. 2018 · Prelims

    Consider the following statements: 1. The Parliament of India can place a particular law in the Ninth Schedule of the Constitution of India. 2. The validity of a law placed in the Ninth Schedule cannot be examined by any court and no judgement can be made on it. Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) 1 only (b) 2 only (c) Both 1 and 2 (d) Neither 1 nor 2

Mains practice question

Does placing a law in the Ninth Schedule still protect it from judicial review? Examine with reference to State laws that take reservation beyond 50%. (250 words)

Model answer

The Ninth Schedule, created with Article 31B by the First Amendment, 1951, was meant to shield land reform laws from Fundamental Rights challenges. Karnataka's request to place its 56% SC/ST quota law there tests whether that shield still works.

How the protection was narrowed

  • Article 31B says listed laws cannot be held void for violating Part III.
  • Kesavananda Bharati (24 April 1973) set the basic structure limit on amending power.
  • I.R. Coelho (2007): laws added after 24 April 1973 can be tested against the basic structure, including the equality code of Articles 14, 15 and 16.

The reservation ceiling

  • Indra Sawhney (1992) capped total reservation at 50%, save in extraordinary situations.
  • Karnataka's Act raised SC quota from 15% to 17% and ST from 3% to 7%; the High Court struck it down on 12 October 2026.
  • The Court also faulted the lack of prior consultation with the NCSC and NCST under Articles 338(9) and 338A(9).
  • Tamil Nadu's 69% law was placed in the Schedule by the 76th Amendment, 1994, the precedent Karnataka now cites.

Assessment

  • Inclusion can still delay or narrow review, and it is politically attractive.
  • But after Coelho, a breach of the 50% rule may be argued as a breach of equality, a basic feature.
  • The stronger defence is data: quantifiable proof of backwardness and of extraordinary circumstances, such as Census 2011 showing SCs at 17.15% and STs at 6.95% of Karnataka's population.

The Ninth Schedule is no longer a complete shield; reservation beyond 50% must be justified on evidence before the courts, not only protected by an amendment.

The basics

Why this matters

Reservation in India is held inside a 50% ceiling set by the Supreme Court. States that want to go higher have tried one route again and again: the Ninth Schedule. Karnataka's request shows the whole chain of ideas UPSC tests: Articles 15(4) and 16(4), the Indra Sawhney ceiling, Article 31B, and the basic structure limit from Kesavananda and Coelho.

What Karnataka changed

The 2022 Act changed only the SC and ST shares. The OBC share stayed at 32%.

Karnataka's reservation before and after the 2022 Act (%)
SC, before
15%
SC, after
17%
ST, before
3%
ST, after
7%
Total, before
50%
Total, after
56%
OBC reservation stayed at 32%. Census 2011 put Karnataka's SC population at 17.15% and ST at 6.95%.

What the Ninth Schedule is

In 1951 the First Amendment added Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule. A law listed there could not be struck down for violating Fundamental Rights. The idea was to protect zamindari abolition and land reform laws. The Schedule began with 13 laws and grew over decades, and laws that had little to do with land reform were also added. Placing a law there needs a constitutional amendment passed by a special majority of Parliament under Article 368.

How the shield was built and narrowed
  1. 1951First Amendment adds Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule
  2. 24 April 1973Kesavananda Bharati: amendments cannot destroy the basic structure
  3. 1992Indra Sawhney fixes a 50% ceiling on reservation, save in extraordinary situations
  4. 199476th Amendment places Tamil Nadu's 69% law in the Ninth Schedule
  5. 2007I.R. Coelho: post-1973 entries can be tested against the basic structure
  6. 12 October 2026Karnataka High Court strikes down the 56% law

Why the High Court struck it down

The Court gave two reasons. First, the total crossed 50%, and neither population share nor the 10% EWS quota justified that. Second, the State had not consulted the National Commissions for SCs and STs before deciding, as the Constitution requires. Consultation after the event, it said, is no consultation.

Does the Ninth Schedule still help?
Arguments for the route
  • Article 31B still bars challenges based only on Part III
  • Tamil Nadu's 69% law has operated for over three decades
  • It signals Parliament's political backing
vs
Arguments against
  • Coelho allows basic structure review of post-1973 entries
  • Equality under Articles 14 to 16 is part of the basic structure
  • Courts still ask for data showing extraordinary circumstances

Read next

The rabbithole covers Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule, the Indra Sawhney 50% ceiling and the I.R. Coelho judgment one at a time.

Go deeper

Why it matters for UPSC

The case joins three examinable ideas: the 50% ceiling on reservation, the Ninth Schedule shield, and the basic structure limit on that shield. Prelims 2018 asked directly about the Ninth Schedule, and Mains 2016 asked about the Coelho case.

The core idea

The Act raised SC reservation to 17% and ST to 7%, taking the total to 56%. The High Court held this breached the Indra Sawhney 50% ceiling and that the State had not consulted the National Commissions for SCs and STs. The State now wants Parliament to use Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule, as it did for Tamil Nadu's 69% law in 1994. But the I.R. Coelho judgment means such protection is not absolute for laws added after 24 April 1973.

Numbers and dates to remember

  • 15% to 17% (SC) and 3% to 7% (ST); total 50% to 56%.
  • 1 November 2022: date from which the Act took effect.
  • 12 October 2026: High Court judgment.
  • 25 July 2026: Union says in the Lok Sabha that inclusion is not appropriate while the case is pending.
  • 76th Amendment, 1994: Tamil Nadu's 69% law placed in the Schedule.

Where to go next

Go deeper: can States go above 50%?

The case for going above 50% is mainly about population. Karnataka says SCs and STs together were about 24% of its population in Census 2011, and that quotas fixed in 1958 had fallen behind. Supporters add that the 10% EWS quota, upheld in 2022, already takes many States beyond 50%, so the ceiling is no longer a fixed rule.

The case against starts with the Indra Sawhney 50% ceiling. The Supreme Court allowed exceptions only in extraordinary situations, such as far-flung and remote areas. In the Maratha quota case (2021) it refused to raise the ceiling. The Karnataka High Court followed this line, holding that population share alone does not create an extraordinary situation and that the EWS ruling did not remove the ceiling for other groups.

On the Ninth Schedule route, Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule still bars challenges based only on Fundamental Rights. But the I.R. Coelho judgment lets courts ask whether a post-1973 entry damages the basic structure, and equality is part of it. So a Ninth Schedule entry may slow a challenge but will not end it.

The procedural point may matter as much. The High Court said the State had to consult the National Commissions for SCs and STs before it acted. The Chief Minister's letter now asks the Centre to arrange those consultations. Whatever route is taken, the lesson for policy is to build the evidence and follow the procedure first.

Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule

What the shield is and how it is used.

In one line: Article 31B says that no law listed in the Ninth Schedule shall be void because it is inconsistent with the Fundamental Rights.

Origin

The First Amendment, 1951 added Article 31B and the Ninth Schedule after courts struck down land reform laws. The Schedule began with 13 laws. Over time, many other laws were added, including Tamil Nadu's reservation law by the 76th Amendment, 1994.

How a law gets in

Only Parliament can add a law, by a constitutional amendment passed by a special majority under Article 368. State ratification is not needed. A State can only ask the Centre to move such an amendment, which is what Karnataka has done.

Why it is in the news

Karnataka wants its 56% law listed, citing Tamil Nadu. The Centre has so far declined, saying the matter was pending in court.

Where to go next

Indra Sawhney 50% ceiling

Where the 50% rule comes from.

In one line: In Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992), a nine-judge Bench upheld OBC reservation but held that total reservation should not normally exceed 50%.

What the case decided

The Court upheld 27% reservation for OBCs in Central jobs, introduced the creamy layer exclusion, and said reservation under Article 16(4) cannot exceed 50% save in extraordinary situations, such as people in far-flung and remote areas.

Later tests

In the Maratha case (2021), the Court refused to revisit the ceiling. In Janhit Abhiyan (2022) it upheld the 10% EWS quota, which sits outside the 50% for backward classes. States have argued this shows the ceiling is not rigid; the Karnataka High Court disagreed for SC, ST and OBC quotas.

Why it is in the news

The High Court applied this ceiling to strike down Karnataka's 56% law on 12 October 2026.

Where to go next

I.R. Coelho judgment

Why the shield is no longer complete.

In one line: In I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu (2007), a nine-judge Bench held that laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 can be tested against the basic structure.

Why 24 April 1973

That is the date of the Kesavananda Bharati judgment, which held that Parliament cannot amend the Constitution to destroy its basic structure. Since putting a law in the Ninth Schedule needs an amendment, the Court held that such additions must also respect the basic structure.

What it means

A listed law is not automatically valid. If it damages a basic feature, such as equality under Articles 14, 15 and 16, the court can strike it down. Judicial review itself is part of the basic structure.

Why it is in the news

Karnataka's law, if added now, would be a post-1973 entry and so open to this test.

Where to go next

National Commissions for SCs and STs

The consultation the High Court found missing.

In one line: The National Commission for Scheduled Castes (Article 338) and the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes (Article 338A) are constitutional bodies that the Union and States must consult on major policy matters affecting these groups.

The consultation clause

Article 338(9) and Article 338A(9) say the Union and every State shall consult the Commission on all major policy matters affecting SCs or STs. The NCST was carved out as a separate body by the 89th Amendment, 2003.

Why it is in the news

The Karnataka High Court held that this consultation is mandatory and must come before the decision. The State's letters of December 2025 and January 2026, sent years after the law, did not count. The Chief Minister's letter now asks the Centre to arrange immediate consultations with both Commissions.

Where to go next

Syllabus

Related stories

Sources used for this summary