Op-ed: Judge India's rice exports by value per drop of water, not by tonnes shipped
In one line: A Hindu op-ed argues India should judge its rice exports by the value earned per unit of water and carbon, not by the tonnes shipped.
Published 16 November 2026. Written by Pratidin from the reports linked at the end; every fact checked by a separate review before publishing. How we work
An article in The Hindu on 16 November 2026 argues that India's position as the world's largest rice exporter rests on a model that is depleting water and adding greenhouse gases, and calls for a shift from volume to value through what it calls a "water-carbon-value framework". It cites APEDA (Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority) data for 2025-26: basmati exports of 6.52 million tonnes worth $5.67 billion, and non-basmati exports of 15.04 million tonnes worth $5.86 billion. Non-basmati thus moves more than twice the volume for only slightly more money, roughly $390 a tonne against about $870 for basmati. The backdrop is a record crop: the third advance estimates put 2025-26 rice production at 154.02 million tonnes, up from 150.18 million tonnes in 2024-25.
The writer's concern is water and carbon. Rice draws heavily on "blue water", that is irrigation from groundwater and surface sources, and the article says this is depleting aquifers in Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh. Flooded paddy fields also emit methane. Through exports, India in effect ships this water abroad, an idea called virtual water trade. The article recommends Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD) and Direct-Seeded Rice (DSR), matching cultivation to agro-climatic conditions, crop diversification in water-stressed areas and better irrigation efficiency. To raise value it suggests quality, branding, traceability, processing and Geographical Indications.
The article also proposes a new dashboard for policymakers: export value per tonne and per cubic metre of blue water, groundwater use, irrigation water productivity, emissions per kilogram of rice, and farmer income per unit of water. The techniques it names are proven at field scale: the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) says AWD saves up to 30% of water and cuts methane emissions from rice by 48%. Any shift has to keep farm incomes in view, which is why the writer counts income per unit of water as a measure of success. Punjab already regulates timing through the Punjab Preservation of Subsoil Water Act, 2009, which bars early transplanting of paddy to save groundwater.
Prelims facts
- APEDA 2025-26: basmati exports 6.52 million tonnes ($5.67 billion); non-basmati 15.04 million tonnes ($5.86 billion).
- Third advance estimates put 2025-26 rice production at a record 154.02 million tonnes, against 150.18 million tonnes in 2024-25.
- The op-ed calls for a 'water-carbon-value framework': judge exports by value per tonne and per cubic metre of blue water.
- IRRI says Alternate Wetting and Drying saves up to 30% of water and cuts methane emissions from rice by 48%.
- Virtual water trade means the water used to grow a crop is in effect exported with it.
Quick recall
- Basmati rice exports in 2025-26 (APEDA)?
- 6.52 million tonnes, worth $5.67 billion.
- Non-basmati rice exports in 2025-26 (APEDA)?
- 15.04 million tonnes, worth $5.86 billion.
- Rice production in 2025-26 (third advance estimates)?
- 154.02 million tonnes, up from 150.18 million tonnes in 2024-25.
- What is 'blue water'?
- Irrigation water drawn from rivers, canals and groundwater, as opposed to green water (rain stored in soil).
- Water saving and methane cut from AWD, according to IRRI?
- Up to 30% water saved and methane emissions cut by 48%.
- Why do flooded paddy fields emit methane?
- Without oxygen, microbes decompose organic matter in the soil and release methane.
- Punjab law that bars early transplanting of paddy?
- Punjab Preservation of Subsoil Water Act, 2009.
- Indian law under which GIs are registered?
- Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999 (in force 2003).
Prelims practice question
With reference to rice cultivation, consider the following statements:
1. Flooded paddy fields are a source of methane emissions.
2. Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD) keeps fields continuously flooded throughout the season.
3. In Direct-Seeded Rice (DSR), seeds are sown directly in the field without raising a nursery and transplanting.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
- 1 and 2 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1 and 3 only
- 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: (c) 1 and 3 only. 1 is correct: decomposition of organic matter without oxygen in flooded soil releases methane. 2 is wrong: AWD alternates flooding and drying. 3 is correct.
Use this in UPSC Mains: previous-year questions
Recurring theme: Rice cultivation, groundwater depletion and the sustainability of India's cropping pattern
- How to use this
Use 2025-26 production and export data to show the rice system's success, then its water and methane costs as the bane.
- Rice production hit a record 154.02 million tonnes in 2025-26 (third advance estimates); exports exceeded 21 million tonnes.
- Paddy's reliance on blue water is depleting aquifers in Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh, and flooded fields emit methane.
- Non-basmati exports were 15.04 million tonnes for $5.86 billion, low value for the water used.
- How to use this
Use paddy as a key cause of groundwater depletion and list water-saving remedies and regulation as steps taken or needed.
- Rice depends heavily on blue water, depleting aquifers in Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh.
- Alternate Wetting and Drying saves up to 30% of water (IRRI); Direct-Seeded Rice avoids water-heavy puddling.
- The Punjab Preservation of Subsoil Water Act, 2009 bars early transplanting of paddy to save groundwater.
Rice grown on groundwater in the Gangetic plains links groundwater decline to food security, though the story focuses on exports.
Mains practice question
India's rice exports are rising in volume, but their water and carbon costs are often ignored. Discuss how India can shift its rice economy from volume to value without hurting farmers. (250 words)
Model answer
India produced a record 154.02 million tonnes of rice in 2025-26 (third advance estimates) and exported over 21 million tonnes, but a Hindu op-ed of 16 November 2026 warns that the model is draining groundwater and raising emissions.
The problem
- Low value per tonne: non-basmati exports were 15.04 million tonnes for $5.86 billion, basmati 6.52 million tonnes for $5.67 billion (APEDA).
- Water: paddy relies on blue water, depleting aquifers in Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh; exports carry this as virtual water.
- Carbon: flooded fields emit methane.
Shifting to value
- Measure differently: track export value per tonne and per cubic metre of blue water, emissions per kg and farmer income per unit of water.
- Water-saving methods: Alternate Wetting and Drying saves up to 30% of water and cuts methane by 48% (IRRI); Direct-Seeded Rice skips the nursery and puddling.
- Higher value: quality, branding, traceability, processing and Geographical Indications.
- Diversify in water-stressed areas, matching crops to agro-climatic zones.
Protecting farmers
- Make farmer income per unit of water a core target.
- Support adoption of AWD and DSR through extension and equipment.
- Use existing rules, such as Punjab's Preservation of Subsoil Water Act, 2009, which bars early transplanting.
Way forward
- Pilot the water-carbon-value framework in groundwater-stressed districts.
India can stay a rice superpower only if it counts the water and carbon in every tonne it ships.
The basics
Why this matters
India grows and sells a great deal of rice. But every tonne carries water pumped from aquifers and methane released from flooded fields. A Hindu op-ed on 16 November 2026 asks a simple question: what does India earn for each unit of water it spends? The answer depends on what kind of rice it ships.
Where the water goes
Scientists divide crop water into green water (rain stored in soil) and blue water (irrigation from rivers, canals and groundwater). Paddy depends heavily on blue water in north-western India, where it is grown with tube-well irrigation. When rice is exported, the water used to grow it leaves the country too. This is Virtual water trade. A water-poor region that exports water-hungry crops is, in effect, exporting its groundwater.
- 1Standing water cuts off oxygen to the soil.
- 2Microbes break down organic matter without oxygen.
- 3These microbes produce methane, which escapes to the air.
- 4Fields are flooded again and the cycle repeats.
Growing rice with less water
Two techniques stand out. Alternate Wetting and Drying lets the field dry out between irrigations instead of staying flooded; IRRI says it saves up to 30% of water and cuts methane by 48%. Direct-Seeded Rice sows seed straight into the field, skipping the nursery and the water-heavy puddling and transplanting.
- Measure success in tonnes exported
- Continuous flooding
- Low price per tonne
- Measure value per cubic metre of blue water
- AWD and DSR to save water and methane
- Branding, traceability and GI to raise price
The takeaway
Raising value means selling quality, not just quantity. Tools such as Geographical Indications and traceability help. Success, the op-ed says, should be counted in farmer income per unit of water.
Go deeper
Why it matters for UPSC
Rice links GS3 agriculture (cropping patterns, irrigation, exports) with environment (groundwater depletion, methane) and GS1 geography (water stress in north-west India). Questions on the rice-wheat system and groundwater depletion draw directly on this.
The core idea
Exports of a water-hungry crop amount to Virtual water trade. The fix the article proposes has two halves. On the farm: grow rice with less water and less methane, using Alternate Wetting and Drying and Direct-Seeded Rice. In the market: earn more per tonne through quality, traceability and Geographical Indications, so that each cubic metre of water brings back more money.
Numbers and dates to remember
- 2025-26 basmati exports: 6.52 million tonnes, $5.67 billion (APEDA).
- 2025-26 non-basmati exports: 15.04 million tonnes, $5.86 billion.
- 2025-26 rice production: 154.02 million tonnes (third advance estimates); 2024-25: 150.18 million tonnes.
- AWD: up to 30% water saving, 48% less methane (IRRI).
- Punjab Preservation of Subsoil Water Act: 2009.
Where to go next
- Virtual water trade: why exports carry hidden water.
- Alternate Wetting and Drying: the irrigation method that saves water and cuts methane.
- Direct-Seeded Rice: sowing without a nursery.
- Geographical Indications: protecting a product's link to its place.
Go deeper: can India keep its rice crown and its groundwater?
The case for change. The article's numbers are stark: non-basmati moves more than twice the tonnage of basmati for only slightly more money. If much of that rice is grown with groundwater in Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh, India is exporting scarce Virtual water trade cheaply. Methane from flooded paddy adds a climate cost. Techniques like Alternate Wetting and Drying and Direct-Seeded Rice reduce both, and value tools like Geographical Indications raise what each tonne earns.
The case for caution. Rice is central to food security and to farm incomes, and farmers respond to the support and incentives they get. A push away from paddy in water-stressed areas needs a viable alternative crop and market, or it will fail. Field methods like AWD need careful water control and training, and DSR brings its own weed problems that farmers must manage.
What a middle path looks like. The article's dashboard offers one: track value per cubic metre of blue water, emissions per kilogram and farmer income per unit of water, and target the most stressed districts first. Punjab's 2009 law barring early transplanting shows that timing rules can save groundwater without banning the crop.
Virtual water trade
The idea that traded crops carry the water used to grow them.
In one line: Virtual water trade is the movement of water embedded in traded goods: when a country exports a crop, it effectively exports the water used to grow it.
The idea
Every crop uses water. A water-scarce country can save its own water by importing water-intensive crops, and a country that exports them is, in effect, sending its water abroad. The concept helps compare the true resource cost of different exports.
Why it is in the news
The Hindu op-ed of 16 November 2026 argues that India's rice exports carry large amounts of blue water, much of it groundwater from Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh, and that export success should be measured as value per cubic metre of blue water.
Where to go next
Alternate Wetting and Drying
An irrigation method that saves water and cuts methane from paddy.
In one line: Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD) is a way of irrigating rice in which the field is allowed to dry for some days before being flooded again, instead of being kept flooded all season.
How it works
Farmers watch the water level, often using a simple perforated tube in the field, and re-irrigate only when it drops below a set depth. Because the soil gets oxygen during dry spells, less methane is produced.
Why it matters
The International Rice Research Institute says AWD saves up to 30% of water and reduces methane emissions from rice by 48%. The Hindu op-ed lists it among the steps to cut the water and carbon cost of India's rice exports.
Where to go next
Direct-Seeded Rice
Sowing rice without a nursery or transplanting.
In one line: Direct-Seeded Rice (DSR) means sowing rice seed directly in the field, instead of raising seedlings in a nursery and transplanting them into flooded, puddled fields.
How it differs
In the usual method, fields are flooded and churned (puddled) before seedlings are transplanted by hand, which takes a lot of water and labour. DSR skips the nursery, puddling and transplanting, saving water and labour.
The trade-offs
Without standing water to suppress them, weeds can be a bigger problem, so DSR needs good weed management and suitable machines. The Hindu op-ed lists DSR with AWD as ways to improve resource efficiency.
Where to go next
Geographical Indications
Protecting a product whose quality comes from its place of origin.
In one line: A Geographical Indication (GI) is a sign used on products that have a specific geographical origin and qualities or a reputation due to that origin.
In India
GIs are registered under the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999, which came into force in 2003. Darjeeling tea was the first product registered. Basmati rice is also a GI product. GI status helps producers charge a premium and stops others from misusing the name.
Why it is in the news
The Hindu op-ed of 16 November 2026 lists GIs, along with branding, traceability and processing, as ways to raise the value India earns per tonne of rice exported.
Where to go next
Take the 16 November 2026 quiz: 30 Prelims-style questions with answers