Editorial: India should use the SCO forum in Delhi to seek cooperation, even with Pakistan
In one line: The Hindu argues that India should use the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in Delhi to find specific areas of cooperation, including with Pakistan on shared rivers, while holding firm on terrorism.
Published 17 November 2026. Written by Pratidin from the reports linked at the end; every fact checked by a separate review before publishing. How we work
India is hosting the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi from 20 to 22 November 2026, organised by the Ministries of Culture and External Affairs. Pakistan has said it will send Musadik Masood Malik, its Federal Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination. His visit would be the first by a high-level Pakistani leader since then Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari attended the SCO Foreign Ministers' meeting in Goa in May 2023. Culture Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat has reportedly said 15 countries have confirmed attendance. Relations remain strained after the April 2025 Pahalgam terror attack and the military confrontation of May 2025, after which India took the position that terrorism and talks cannot go together, and extended it to trade and water.
The Hindu's editorial on 17 November, "Clear the path", argues that while India keeps its hard line on cross-border terrorism, several of its other interests still merit sustained cooperation, including with Pakistan. It notes that South Asia is among the world's least integrated regions, with trade among its countries at barely 5%, and that the gaps left by India's strained ties with neighbours are being filled by Beijing through its own groupings. By inviting all SCO members to New Delhi ahead of the 2027 SCO summit in Islamabad, India has an opening. The editorial points to water: India is upstream of Pakistan and Bangladesh but downstream of China. After India stopped sharing routine hydrological data on the Indus and approved a new link-tunnel project, Pakistan's minister responded sharply. China, it says, has since restricted similar data on the Brahmaputra while building a massive dam in Tibet.
The editorial also notes that India has objected to Bangladesh's proposed barrage project, citing Dhaka's growing closeness to China, though India itself built the Farakka Barrage decades ago despite objections from across the border. It argues that climate change makes cooperation on shared rivers more necessary, since it threatens river systems and border communities and also offers clean hydropower. Cooperation on the Indus, it says, would not be a concession to Islamabad, and suspending all ties may show resolve but does little to weaken terror networks or improve security. Supporters of India's current line would answer that Pakistan has not acted against groups that attack India, and that dialogue without such action rewards it. The editorial's case is for picking specific areas where cooperation serves India's long-term interest.
Prelims facts
- India hosts the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi from 20 to 22 November 2026; Pakistan is sending Climate Change Minister Musadik Masood Malik.
- It would be the first high-level Pakistani visit to India since Bilawal Bhutto Zardari attended the SCO Foreign Ministers' meeting in Goa in May 2023.
- The Hindu editorial argues that India, upstream of Pakistan and Bangladesh but downstream of China, has a stake in cooperation on shared rivers.
- The editorial puts intra-regional trade in South Asia at barely 5%, among the lowest of any region.
- The next SCO summit is due in Islamabad in 2027.
Quick recall
- Dates and venue of the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum?
- New Delhi, 20 to 22 November 2026.
- Who is Pakistan sending to the forum?
- Musadik Masood Malik, Federal Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination.
- Last high-level Pakistani visit to India before this?
- Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, for the SCO Foreign Ministers' meeting in Goa, May 2023.
- When did India and Pakistan become full SCO members?
- 2017.
- Where are the SCO's two permanent bodies located?
- Secretariat in Beijing; Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure (RATS) in Tashkent.
- Which rivers are allocated to India under the Indus Waters Treaty?
- The eastern rivers: Ravi, Beas and Sutlej.
- Where is the next SCO summit due?
- Islamabad, in 2027.
- Which treaty governs Ganga water sharing at Farakka?
- The Ganga Water Treaty of 1996 between India and Bangladesh.
Prelims practice question
Consider the following countries:
1. Iran
2. Belarus
3. Afghanistan
4. Turkmenistan
Which of the above are full members of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation?
- 1 and 2 only
- 1, 2 and 3 only
- 2 and 4 only
- 1, 3 and 4 only
Show answer
Answer: (a) 1 and 2 only. Iran became a full member in 2023 and Belarus in 2024. Afghanistan and Turkmenistan are not full members of the SCO.
Use this in UPSC Mains: previous-year questions
Recurring theme: The SCO and India's neighbourhood diplomacy, including shared rivers
Critically examine the aims and objectives of SCO. What importance does it hold for India?
How to use thisUse the forum as a current example of the SCO's importance as a platform where India can engage Pakistan and others without bilateral talks.
- India hosts the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi, 20 to 22 November 2026, ahead of the 2027 Islamabad summit.
- Pakistan's Climate Change Minister Musadik Masood Malik is attending, the first high-level Pakistani visit since Goa in May 2023.
- SCO forums let India pursue issue-based cooperation, such as climate and water, while holding that terrorism and talks cannot go together.
- How to use this
Use the editorial's argument to suggest India's role: firmness on terrorism combined with narrow, issue-based cooperation through SCO platforms.
- Inviting all SCO members, including Pakistan, to the Delhi forum keeps channels open despite the post-Pahalgam freeze.
- Cooperation on shared rivers and climate can reduce tensions; India is upstream of Pakistan but downstream of China.
- South Asia's intra-regional trade is barely 5%, and the editorial notes that China fills the gaps left by India's strained ties with neighbours.
Mains practice question
Can multilateral platforms such as the SCO help India pursue cooperation with Pakistan on shared concerns like water and climate without diluting its position on terrorism? Examine. (250 words)
Model answer
India hosts the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi from 20 to 22 November 2026, and Pakistan is sending its Climate Change Minister, the first high-level Pakistani visit since May 2023.
How the SCO helps
- Cover for contact: multilateral meetings allow ministers to travel without a bilateral breakthrough, as with Bilawal Bhutto Zardari in Goa (2023).
- Issue focus: cultural and climate tracks are less charged than security talks.
- Regional stake: India invited all members ahead of the 2027 SCO summit in Islamabad.
The case for selective cooperation
- Water: India is upstream of Pakistan and Bangladesh but downstream of China; The Hindu's editorial notes China has restricted Brahmaputra data while building a dam in Tibet.
- Consistency: India built the Farakka Barrage despite objections, yet objects to Bangladesh's barrage.
- Integration: South Asia's intra-regional trade is barely 5%; China fills the gaps.
- Climate: shared rivers face climate risks and offer clean hydropower.
Limits
- After the Pahalgam attack (April 2025), India held that terrorism and talks cannot go together, extending it to trade and water.
- Critics of engagement argue that cooperation without action on terror groups rewards Pakistan.
- The SCO itself includes China, whose interests may not align with India's.
Way forward
- Keep terrorism as a red line on political dialogue.
- Use SCO platforms for narrow, technical cooperation on hydrological data, disasters and climate.
- Apply the same principles India seeks from China as an upstream state.
Multilateral forums can keep channels open, but they work only when the agenda is specific and serves India's long-term interests.
The basics
Why this matters
India's approach to Pakistan since 2025 rests on one rule: terrorism and talks cannot go together. Multilateral groups like the SCO test that rule, because India must host or attend meetings where Pakistan is present. The editorial asks whether such forums can carry narrow cooperation, especially on rivers, without weakening India's stand.
The SCO in brief
The SCO grew out of the Shanghai Five and was founded in 2001 by China, Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. India and Pakistan became full members in 2017, Iran in 2023 and Belarus in 2024. Its permanent bodies are the Secretariat in Beijing and the Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure (RATS) in Tashkent. See Shanghai Cooperation Organisation.
- 2001SCO founded by six States
- 2017India and Pakistan become full members
- May 2023Pakistan's Foreign Minister attends SCO Foreign Ministers' meeting in Goa
- April 2025Pahalgam terror attack; India places the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance
- 20 to 22 November 2026SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi
- 2027SCO summit due in Islamabad
India's place on shared rivers
Geography gives India two roles at once. On the Indus system it is upstream of Pakistan, governed by the Indus Waters Treaty. On the Ganga it is upstream of Bangladesh, where the Farakka Barrage and the Ganga Water Treaty have long shaped ties. On the Brahmaputra it is downstream of China. See Transboundary river data sharing.
- 1Indus systemIndia upstream of Pakistan
- 2GangaIndia upstream of Bangladesh
- 3BrahmaputraIndia downstream of China, upstream of Bangladesh
Two ways to read the moment
The argument is about means, not ends. Both sides want security; they differ on whether limited cooperation helps or hurts.
- Cooperation on the Indus is not a concession
- Suspending all ties does little to weaken terror networks
- China fills the gaps left by strained ties
- India wants upstream China to share data, so it should model the same
- Pakistan has not acted against groups that attack India
- Dialogue without such action may reward it
- Terrorism remains the central issue
- Leverage over water and trade backs the red line
Go deeper
Why it matters for UPSC
GS2 asks about the SCO's relevance to India, India's neighbourhood policy and water diplomacy. This editorial sets up a balanced Mains argument and links the SCO with the Indus, Ganga and Brahmaputra.
The core idea
The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation brings India and Pakistan into the same rooms. India has held since the Pahalgam attack that terrorism and talks cannot go together, and has placed the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance. The editorial says rivers show why some cooperation serves India: it is upstream of Pakistan and Bangladesh, and downstream of China. Its own record with the Farakka Barrage and the Ganga Water Treaty and its demands of China on Transboundary river data sharing argue for consistent principles.
Numbers and dates to remember
- SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum: New Delhi, 20 to 22 November 2026.
- Pakistan's delegate: Musadik Masood Malik, Federal Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination.
- Last high-level Pakistani visit: Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, Goa, May 2023.
- South Asia's intra-regional trade: barely 5%, per the editorial.
- Next SCO summit: Islamabad, 2027.
Where to go next
- Shanghai Cooperation Organisation: the grouping and India's stake in it.
- Indus Waters Treaty: the 1960 pact now in abeyance.
- Farakka Barrage and the Ganga Water Treaty: India as the upstream State.
- Transboundary river data sharing: why flood data matter across borders.
Go deeper: water diplomacy and the terror red line
The editorial's argument. India is right to be firm on cross-border terrorism, it says, but freezing every channel has costs. Suspending ties may signal resolve but does little to reduce the capacity of terror networks or improve security on the ground. South Asia's weak integration, with trade among its countries at barely 5%, leaves room that Beijing fills. Cooperation under the Indus Waters Treaty framework, it argues, is not a favour to Islamabad.
The consistency problem. India asks China, the upper riparian on the Brahmaputra, for flood-season data, and the editorial says China has restricted such data while building a massive dam in Tibet. Yet India has stopped sharing routine Indus data with Pakistan. With Bangladesh, India objects to a proposed barrage while having built the Farakka Barrage and the Ganga Water Treaty arrangement over Bangladesh's objections. Principles on Transboundary river data sharing that India wants from China are harder to claim if it does not apply them downstream.
The counter-argument. The government's position since the Pahalgam attack is that normal ties, including trade and water, cannot run while terror continues. Supporters argue that Pakistan has not acted against groups that target India, and that engagement would remove pressure. They see water as one of India's few levers.
The role of multilateralism. The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation offers a middle path: ministers can meet in a multilateral setting, as Bilawal Bhutto Zardari did in Goa in 2023 and as Pakistan's Climate Change Minister plans to now, without a bilateral breakthrough.
Shanghai Cooperation Organisation
The grouping that brings India and Pakistan to the same table.
In one line: The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) is a Eurasian political, security and economic grouping founded in 2001.
Members and bodies
It grew out of the Shanghai Five and was founded by China, Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. India and Pakistan joined as full members in 2017, Iran in 2023 and Belarus in 2024. Its Secretariat is in Beijing and its Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure (RATS) is in Tashkent.
Why India is in it
The SCO gives India access to Central Asia, a platform on terrorism and connectivity, and a forum where it can engage China and Russia. It also forces India and Pakistan into shared meetings. India is hosting the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in November 2026, ahead of the 2027 summit in Islamabad.
Where to go next
Shanghai Cooperation Organisation: every story that connects to it (3)
Indus Waters Treaty
The 1960 water pact India placed in abeyance in 2025.
In one line: The Indus Waters Treaty, signed in 1960 with the World Bank's help, divides the Indus river system between India and Pakistan.
What it provides
The three eastern rivers, Ravi, Beas and Sutlej, are allocated to India. The three western rivers, Indus, Jhelum and Chenab, are mainly for Pakistan, with India allowed limited uses such as run-of-river hydropower. A Permanent Indus Commission, with a commissioner from each side, was meant to exchange data and resolve questions.
Why it is in the news
After the Pahalgam attack in April 2025, India placed the treaty in abeyance. The editorial says India has also stopped sharing routine hydrological data on the Indus and approved a new link-tunnel project, drawing a sharp response from Pakistan's minister.
Where to go next
Farakka Barrage and the Ganga Water Treaty
Where India is the upstream State in a long dispute.
In one line: The Farakka Barrage on the Ganga in West Bengal diverts water to the Hooghly, and the 1996 Ganga Water Treaty sets how India and Bangladesh share the dry-season flow.
The history
India built the barrage to keep Kolkata port navigable, despite objections from across the border, and it was commissioned in 1975. Water sharing at Farakka became a lasting issue with Bangladesh. The 1996 treaty, for 30 years, fixed a formula for sharing lean-season flows.
Why it is in the editorial
The editorial notes that India now objects to Bangladesh's proposed barrage project, citing Dhaka's growing ties with China, while India's own Farakka Barrage was built over the other side's objections. It uses this to argue for consistent principles on shared rivers.
Where to go next
Transboundary river data sharing
Why flood data across borders can save lives.
In one line: Transboundary river data sharing is the exchange of water level, flow and rainfall data between countries that share a river, mainly to warn of floods.
Why it matters
Downstream countries need upstream data to forecast floods and plan water use. Without it, warnings come late. Such sharing usually rests on treaties or memoranda of understanding, and is often the first casualty when relations sour.
India's two positions
On the Brahmaputra, known in Tibet as the Yarlung Tsangpo, India is downstream of China and depends on Chinese flood-season data. The editorial says China has restricted such data while building a massive dam in Tibet. On the Indus, India is upstream and, the editorial says, has stopped sharing routine hydrological data with Pakistan. Climate change, which brings more extreme floods, raises the stakes for both.
Where to go next
Take the 17 November 2026 quiz: 30 Prelims-style questions with answers