Make a précis of the following passage in about one-third of its length. Do not give or suggest a title to it. The précis should be written in your own words. 75
We are not always able to read more than one history of an event. When we are not, we must admit that we do not have much chance of learning the truth of the matter in question–of learning what really happened. However, that is not the only reason to read history. It might be claimed that only the professional historian, the man who is writing a history himself, is required to cross-examine his sources by exhaustively checking one against the other. He must leave no stone unturned if he is to know what he ought to know about his subject. We, as lay readers of history, stand somewhere between the professional historian, on the one hand, and the irresponsible amateur, on the other hand, who reads history only for amusement.
Let us take the example of Thucydides. You may be aware that he wrote the only major contemporary history of the Peloponnesian War at the end of the fifth century B.C. In a sense, there is nothing to check his work against. What, then, can we expect to learn from it ?
Greece is now a tiny country; a war that occurred there twenty-five centuries ago can have little real effect on our life today. Everyone who fought in it is long dead, and the specific things for which they fought are long dead, too. The victories are now meaningless, and the defeats without pain. The cities that were taken and lost have crumbled into dust. Indeed, if we stop to think of it, almost all that remains of the Peloponnesian War is Thucydides’ account of it.
Yet that account is still important. For Thucydides’ story–we might as well use that word–has had an influence on the subsequent history of man. Leaders in later eras read Thucydides. When they found themselves in situations that even faintly approximated that of the tragically divided Greek city-states, they compared their own position to that of Athens or Sparta. They used Thucydides as an excuse and a justification, and even as a pattern of conduct. The result was that by ever so little, perhaps, but perceptibly, the history of the world was changed by the view held of a small portion of it by Thucydides in the fifth century B.C. Thus we read Thucydides not because he described perfectly what happened before he wrote his book, but because he to a certain extent determined what happened after. And we read him, strange as this may seem, to know what is happening now.
“Poetry is more philosophical than history,” wrote Aristotle. By this he meant that poetry is more general, more universal. A good poem is true not only in its own time and place; but in all times and places. It has meaning and force for all men. History is not quite so universal as that. It is tied to events in a way that poetry is not. But any good history is also universal.
Thucydides himself said that he was writing his history so that men of the future would not have to repeat the mistakes he had seen made and from which he had suffered personally and through the agony of his country. He described the kinds of human mistakes that would have meaning to men other than himself, to men other than Greeks. Yet some of the very same errors that the Athenians and the Spartans made 2,500 years ago, or at least very similar ones, are being made now, as they have been made over and over again since Thucydides’ time.
If your view of history is limited, if you go to it to discover only what really happened, you will not learn the main thing that Thucydides, or indeed any good historian, has to teach. If you read Thucydides well, you may even decide to give up trying to discover what really happened in the past.
History is the story of what led up to now. It is the present that interests us–that and the future. The future will be partly determined by the present. Thus, you can learn something about the future, too, from a historian, even from one who like Thucydides lived more than two thousand years ago.
Let us sum up these two suggestions for reading history. The first is: if you can, read more than one history of an event or period that interests you. The second is: read a history not only to learn what really happened at a particular time and place in the past, but also to learn the way men act in all times and places, especially now.
(773 words)
75 marks · directive: Make a précis
The core of a good answer
The passage argues that even when we cannot check a history against other accounts, a good history such as Thucydides' is worth reading because it shaped later events and teaches how people behave in all ages, including our own.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The passage has 773 words (as printed), so the précis should be about one-third of that: 773 ÷ 3 = 257.7, that is about 258 words (roughly 250 to 270 is safe). Write in your own words, in the third person and past or present tense consistently, keep the passage's line of argument, drop examples and repetition, and do not give a title. Count your words.
Answer outline
Introduction
Method: read twice, mark the main idea of each paragraph, write a rough draft of about 300 words, then cut to about 258.
Main ideas in order
- 1. Reading more than one account is the best way to learn what really happened; a lay reader stands between the professional historian, who must check every source, and the amateur who reads for fun.
- 2. Thucydides wrote the only major contemporary history of the Peloponnesian War, so it cannot be checked; the question is what we can learn from it.
- 3. The war itself no longer matters: its people, causes, victories and cities are gone, and almost only Thucydides' account remains.
- 4. Yet that account changed later history, because leaders compared their own situations to Athens or Sparta and used it as excuse, justification and model. We read him because he shaped what came after, and to understand the present.
- 5. Aristotle held poetry to be more universal than history; history is tied to events, but good history is universal too.
- 6. Thucydides wrote so that future generations would avoid the mistakes he saw; similar mistakes are still repeated.
- 7. Reading history only to find out what happened misses its main lesson; history explains how the present came about and so helps us understand the future.
- 8. Summing up: read more than one history where possible, and read history to learn how people behave in all times, especially now.
Conclusion
Check that the précis keeps both of the author's suggestions from the last paragraph, uses none of the passage's sentences word for word, and stays close to 258 words.
Facts to remember
- One-third of the printed 773 words is 257.7, that is about 258 words.
- A précis keeps the author's argument and order but leaves out examples, quotations and repetition; it is written in the writer's own words without a title when the paper says so.
- The Peloponnesian War between Athens and Sparta lasted from 431 to 404 BC; Thucydides began his History at its outbreak and it breaks off in 411 BC.