What do you mean by soil consistency and soil plasticity ? Briefly discuss the various forms of soil consistency found in soils.
20 marks · directive: Briefly discuss
The core of a good answer
Soil consistency is the ability of soil materials to stick together, which changes with water content, and soil plasticity is the ability to undergo permanent change of shape (moulding) without returning; with rising water content a fine-grained soil passes through solid, semi-solid, plastic and liquid states, separated by the Atterberg limits (shrinkage, plastic and liquid limits).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer needs crisp definitions, the sequence of consistency states with the limits that separate them, the soil properties behind them and their agricultural significance for tillage.
Answer outline
Introduction
Consistency describes how soil materials stick together; in fine-grained soils it depends strongly on water content and on the amount and type of clay.
Soil plasticity
- Plasticity is the ability of a material to undergo permanent deformation, a change of shape that does not reverse when the force is removed; soils, particularly clays, show it.
- Plastic behaviour in soils arises mainly from rearrangement of clusters of adjacent grains and depends on microstructure, chemical composition and water content.
- Measured by the plastic limit and the liquid limit; plasticity index = liquid limit - plastic limit, the range of water contents over which the soil behaves plastically.
- Vertisols, rich in expansive montmorillonite clays, are very hard when dry and very sticky when wet.
Forms (states) of consistency with increasing water
- Solid: below the shrinkage limit, further drying no longer reduces soil volume.
- Semi-solid: between the shrinkage limit and the plastic limit; a rolled thread crumbles before it can be rolled to 3.2 mm diameter.
- Plastic: between the plastic limit and the liquid limit, the soil can be moulded and keeps its new shape.
- Liquid: above the liquid limit, the soil flows; at the liquid limit a standard groove in the Casagrande cup closes after 25 drops.
Factors and significance
- Amount and type of clay (expansive montmorillonite gives Vertisols their hardness when dry and stickiness when wet) and water content.
- Determines the tillage window: Vertisols can be worked only within a very narrow range of moisture conditions.
Conclusion
Knowing the consistency limits of a soil tells a farmer when it can be worked: a heavy clay soil such as a Vertisol has only a narrow range of moisture in which tillage is practical.
Examples and data to cite
- Atterberg limits proposed by the Swedish chemist and agronomist Albert Atterberg in 1911, later refined by Arthur Casagrande.
- Vertisols of the Deccan Plateau are very hard when dry and very sticky when wet, so they can be worked only within a very narrow range of moisture.
- Casagrande method: the liquid limit is the water content at which a standard groove closes after 25 drops of the cup.
Facts to remember
- Plastic limit: water content at which a soil thread crumbles at about 3.2 mm diameter.
- Shrinkage limit: water content below which further drying does not reduce soil volume.
- Plasticity index classes: non-plastic 0, slightly plastic less than 7, medium 7 to 17, highly plastic above 17.