Define heritability. What do you mean by broad sense and narrow sense heritability ? Explain its applications in crop improvement.
20 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Heritability is the proportion of phenotypic variance in a population that is due to genetic differences; broad sense heritability H² = VG/VP uses total genetic variance, narrow sense heritability h² = VA/VP uses only additive variance, and h² predicts response to selection (R = h²S), guides the choice of breeding method and helps estimate genetic advance.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question has three parts: a definition, the distinction between broad and narrow sense with formulae, and applications. The applications part carries most marks and should be linked to selection, breeding method choice and genetic advance.
Answer outline
Introduction
Phenotypic variance is partitioned as VP = VG + VE, and VG = VA + VD + VI (additive, dominance and epistatic). Heritability expresses how much of VP is genetic, for a given population in a given environment.
Definitions
- Broad sense: H² = VG / VP = (VA + VD + VI) / VP; it shows how far the phenotype reflects genotype, useful for clonal and self pollinated pure line selection.
- Narrow sense: h² = VA / VP; only additive variance is transmitted from parent to offspring and fixed by selection, so h² measures breeding value.
- Both range from 0 to 1 (0 to 100 per cent); H² is always at least h².
- Estimated from variance components (ANOVA of replicated trials, generation means of P1, P2, F1, F2, backcrosses), parent offspring regression or realised response to selection.
Illustration
- If VA = 30, VD = 10, VI = 5 and VE = 55, then VG = 45 and VP = 100.
- H² = 45 / 100 = 0.45; h² = 30 / 100 = 0.30.
- With selection differential S = 20 units, response R = h²S = 0.30 × 20 = 6 units.
- Genetic advance at 5 per cent selection intensity GA = k σP h² = 2.06 × 10 × 0.30 = 6.18; for a mean of 50 this is 12.36 per cent of the mean.
Applications in crop improvement
- Predicting response to selection: R = h²S; high h² traits respond to simple mass or phenotypic selection.
- Choice of breeding method: high h² with high genetic advance shows additive gene action, so selection in early generations works; high heritability with low genetic advance indicates non-additive action, so heterosis breeding or delayed selection is better.
- Choosing traits for indirect selection and building selection indices.
- Deciding generation of selection, plot size and number of replications: low h² traits (yield) need replicated, later generation testing.
- Comparing populations and environments; heritability falls when environmental variance rises.
Limitations
- Specific to the population, environment and method of estimation; it says nothing about an individual plant.
- Genotype by environment interaction inflates single environment estimates.
Conclusion
Narrow sense heritability, read together with genetic advance, is the breeder's best quick guide to whether selection will pay off.
Examples and data to cite
- Grain yield usually shows low to moderate heritability, while traits like plant height, days to flowering and 1000 grain weight usually show high heritability in cereals.
- Robinson, Comstock and Harvey (1949) classified heritability as low (below 30 per cent), moderate (30 to 60 per cent) and high (above 60 per cent).
- Johnson, Robinson and Comstock (1955) showed that heritability is most meaningfully interpreted together with genetic advance.
Facts to remember
- H² = VG / VP; h² = VA / VP.
- Breeder's equation: R = h² S.
- Genetic advance GA = k σP h², with k = 2.06 at 5 per cent selection intensity.
- Only additive variance is fixable in self pollinated crops by selection.