Explain why chickens excrete nitrogenous waste primarily as uric acid rather than urea.
10 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Chickens are uricotelic because uric acid has low toxicity and very low water solubility, so it can be concentrated and passed as a pasty white suspension with the faeces using very little water; the saving in water outweighs the higher metabolic cost of making uric acid compared with urea.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain the physiological and biochemical reasons for uric acid excretion, its metabolic cost compared with urea, and the contrast with mammals.
Answer outline
Introduction
Ammonia is toxic and needs much water to excrete; urea is less toxic but very soluble; uric acid is the least soluble, about 6 mg per 100 mL of water at 20 °C.
Reasons
- Low toxicity: uric acid is not very toxic, so it need not be diluted in much water.
- Water conservation: it can be concentrated into a small volume and excreted as a pasty white suspension in the faeces, unlike the liquid urine of mammals.
- Birds share this pattern with reptiles; some desert mammals such as the kangaroo rat also excrete uric acid.
- Biochemistry: birds lack the specific enzymes to synthesise arginine, so arginine is an essential amino acid for poultry.
Synthesis and excretion
- Uric acid is the end product of purine metabolism in birds and reptiles: AMP to IMP to inosine to hypoxanthine to xanthine to uric acid.
- Xanthine oxidase, which works mainly as a dehydrogenase, converts hypoxanthine and xanthine to uric acid.
- Avian kidneys have reptilian type nephrons (more abundant, in the cortex) and mammalian type nephrons (in the medulla); urine passes through the ureters into the cloaca.
Costs
- Uric acid takes more metabolic energy to make than urea.
- Uric acid (C5H4N4O3, molar mass 168.11 g/mol) is 33.3 percent nitrogen against 46.6 percent for urea (CH4N2O), and carries 5 carbon atoms per 4 nitrogen atoms against 1 per 2 in urea, so more carbon leaves the body per unit of nitrogen excreted.
Comparison with mammals
- Mammals excrete urea in liquid urine, which needs more water.
- Most non primate mammals have uricase, which converts uric acid further to allantoin, so gout is rare in them; avian gout is known in some bird species.
Conclusion
Uric acid excretion suits birds by saving water, despite its higher energy cost.
Examples and data to cite
- White urate deposit in chicken droppings is the uric acid fraction.
- Arginine is an essential dietary amino acid for chickens.
- Reptiles and the kangaroo rat also excrete uric acid.
Facts to remember
- Uric acid C5H4N4O3 contains 33.3 percent nitrogen; urea CH4N2O contains 46.6 percent.
- Uric acid solubility in water is about 6 mg per 100 mL at 20 °C.
- Birds require dietary arginine.