How do you estimate the cost of milk production in organised and unorganised dairy sector in India?
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Cost of milk production is estimated by recording all variable costs (feed, fodder, labour, veterinary care, AI, electricity) and fixed costs (depreciation and interest on animals, sheds and equipment), deducting the value of by-products (dung, calves), and dividing the net cost by milk produced; organised farms use accounts and records, while the unorganised sector needs sample surveys with imputed values for family labour and home-grown feed.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Set out the costing method (cost items, concepts, allocation, per litre calculation) and show how data collection and valuation differ between commercial or cooperative farms and household dairying.
Answer outline
Introduction
Most milk in India comes from small household herds (unorganised), while organised farms and cooperative or private dairy plants keep formal records; the costing principle is the same but data sources and valuation differ.
Cost items
- Variable (operating) costs: green and dry fodder, concentrates and mineral mixture, hired and family labour, veterinary and AI charges, water, electricity, miscellaneous.
- Fixed costs: depreciation on animals, sheds and equipment; interest on fixed capital; insurance; rental value of land used for fodder.
- Feed and fodder is usually the largest single item.
Procedure
- Classify herds by species, breed (crossbred, indigenous, buffalo) and herd size; take a representative sample.
- Record inputs and milk output by daily or periodic visits over a full year (cost accounting or survey method).
- Gross cost = variable + fixed costs; net cost = gross cost − value of dung, calves and other by-products.
- Cost per litre = net cost ÷ total milk produced; also express per animal per day and per lactation, and for in-milk and dry animals.
- Use the herd or whole-lactation approach so that dry period and followers are charged to milk.
Organised sector
- Farm accounts, feed registers, payroll and asset registers give actual paid-out costs.
- Includes management overheads, chilling, transport and quality testing; economies of scale.
Unorganised sector
- Family labour and home-grown fodder and crop residues have no cash cost and must be imputed (wage rate, market or harvest price).
- Joint cost of crop and livestock enterprises must be apportioned; recall errors are large.
- Sample survey design across agro-climatic zones and seasons is needed.
Use of estimates
- Fixation of procurement prices by cooperatives; planning feed subsidies; comparing breeds and systems; testing profitability.
Conclusion
A clear set of cost concepts, careful imputation for family resources and deduction of by-product value give comparable cost estimates for both sectors and support fair milk pricing.
Examples and data to cite
- Milk production in India was about 239.3 million tonnes in 2023-24 (BAHS 2024).
- Amul, registered in 1946 as the Kaira District Co-operative Milk Producers' Union, follows the three-tier Anand pattern (village society, district union, state federation) through which procurement prices are paid.
Facts to remember
- Net cost = gross cost − value of by-products (dung, calf).
- Cost per litre = net cost ÷ milk yield.
- Depreciation of animals = (purchase value − salvage value) ÷ productive life.
- Family labour is valued at the prevailing wage rate (opportunity cost).