Discuss the role of the WTO in implementation of sanitary and phytosanitary measures related to milk and meat products.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Through the SPS Agreement (in force since 1995), the WTO lets members protect human and animal health in trade in milk and meat, but requires measures to be science-based, based on Codex and WOAH standards where these exist, applied with regionalisation, equivalence and transparency, and subject to WTO dispute settlement.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer should explain the SPS framework, the key disciplines and the bodies whose standards are used for milk and meat, and then discuss how these affect India as importer and exporter. Discuss calls for benefits and concerns.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures entered into force with the WTO on 1 January 1995; it governs food safety, animal health and plant health measures affecting trade.
Core disciplines
- Members may adopt measures needed to protect human, animal or plant life or health, but they must be based on scientific principles (Article 2).
- Harmonisation (Article 3): measures based on international standards are presumed consistent; higher protection needs scientific justification.
- Equivalence (Article 4): an importer accepts an exporter's different measures if they achieve the same protection.
- Risk assessment (Article 5); provisional measures under Article 5.7 when evidence is insufficient.
- Regionalisation (Article 6): recognition of pest- or disease-free areas and areas of low pest or disease prevalence.
- Transparency (Article 7 and Annex B): notification of new measures and enquiry points.
Three sister standard-setting bodies
- Codex Alimentarius Commission for food safety: standards on additives, veterinary drug and pesticide residues, contaminants, methods of analysis, and codes of hygienic practice.
- World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH, formerly OIE; named in Annex A as the International Office of Epizootics): animal health and zoonoses, through the Terrestrial Animal Health Code.
- International Plant Protection Convention for plant health (feed ingredients).
Role in milk and meat trade
- Gives exporters of milk and meat a right to challenge import bans not based on international standards or risk assessment.
- Restrains disguised protectionism: measures must not discriminate arbitrarily or be a disguised restriction on trade (Article 2.3).
- Equivalence and regionalisation let a country with disease in one region still export from disease-free areas.
- Technical assistance through the Standards and Trade Development Facility.
Concerns for India
- Exporters must meet Codex and WOAH-based requirements and allow importers reasonable access for inspection and testing (Articles 4 and 6).
- India's own measures can be challenged: in DS430 its avian influenza import ban on poultry products was found inconsistent with the Agreement.
- Even after a ruling, compliance can be slow, as in EC Hormones, where the DSB authorised countermeasures by the US and Canada.
Conclusion
The WTO does not set standards but makes Codex and WOAH standards the benchmark; India gains market access when its animal health and food safety systems meet them.
Examples and data to cite
- India - Agricultural Products (DS430): the panel (report circulated 14 October 2014) and Appellate Body (4 June 2015) found India's avian influenza import prohibitions on poultry products inconsistent with the SPS Agreement, including Articles 3, 5.1 and 5.2 (risk assessment) and 6 (regionalisation).
- EC - Hormones (DS26): the Appellate Body report (circulated 16 January 1998, adopted 13 February 1998) upheld that the EC ban on meat from hormone-treated cattle was inconsistent with Article 5.1.
- Annex A of the SPS Agreement lists Codex codes and guidelines of hygienic practice among the international standards for food safety.
Facts to remember
- SPS Agreement entered into force on 1 January 1995.
- Codex, WOAH and IPPC are named in Annex A of the SPS Agreement.
- Article 5.7 allows provisional measures pending further information.
- The STDF is a partnership of FAO, WOAH, the World Bank Group, WHO and WTO.