Write notes on the following in about 150 words each :
(e) Ethnoarchaeology and classical archaeology
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Write notes
The core of a good answer
Ethnoarchaeology studies living communities to understand how material remains are produced and discarded, so as to interpret prehistoric sites by analogy, while classical archaeology studies the material remains of ancient Greece and Rome alongside their written texts and art.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Define each, compare aims, methods and data, and give examples. About 150 words; a short comparison is expected.
Answer outline
Introduction
Both are branches of archaeology but work at opposite ends: one uses the ethnographic present to explain the unwritten past, the other uses texts and monuments of literate civilisations.
Ethnoarchaeology
- Jesse Walter Fewkes first spoke of the 'ethno-archaeologist' in 1900 and urged archaeologists to do their own ethnographic fieldwork.
- Lewis Binford worked among the Nunamiut of Alaska (Nunamiut Ethnoarchaeology, 1978) to see how hunter-gatherer behaviour is reflected in material remains; the work fed his middle-range theory.
- Ian Hodder, Symbols in Action: Ethnoarchaeological Studies of Material Culture (1982), drew on his surveys in Kenya.
- Uses formal analogy (similar looking objects assumed to share use), relational analogy (the link must be shown) and the direct historical approach (analogy from related living cultures).
Classical archaeology
- Studies the Mediterranean civilisations of ancient Greece and Rome; rooted in the art history of J. J. Winckelmann (1717 to 1768), often called the father of art history.
- Heinrich Schliemann began digging a trench at Hisarlik, the site of Troy, in 1870.
- Inspired by ancient texts and sometimes uses them to interpret artefacts; it also places provincial Roman art within art history.
Comparison
- Data: living behaviour versus ancient monuments and texts.
- Purpose: building interpretive analogies versus reconstructing a known historical civilisation.
- Chronology: mostly prehistory versus historical period.
Conclusion
The two complement each other: ethnoarchaeology supplies models of behaviour, while classical archaeology shows how material and textual evidence can be read together.
Examples and data to cite
- Lewis Binford, Nunamiut Ethnoarchaeology (1978).
- Ian Hodder, Symbols in Action (1982).
- Jesse Walter Fewkes on the 'ethno-archaeologist' (1900).
- Schliemann's excavations at Hisarlik (Troy) from 1870.
Facts to remember
- Ethnoarchaeology relies on analogy from living societies.
- Middle-range theory: Binford.
- Classical archaeology: the Mediterranean world of Greece and Rome.
- Direct historical approach uses related living cultures.