What is meant by a somatotype? Discuss the Heath-Carter anthropometric method, giving its advantages over that of Sheldon's method. How can somatotyping be applied in sports sciences?
20 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
A somatotype is a quantified description of present body shape and composition in three components (endomorphy, mesomorphy, ectomorphy); the Heath-Carter anthropometric method computes these from ten body measurements with fixed equations, making it more objective, open ended and applicable to both sexes from childhood to old age than Sheldon's photographic rating, and sports science uses it to match physique to events and to track training.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question has three parts: definition, the Heath-Carter method compared with Sheldon's, and sports applications. A 20 mark answer should state the measurements and equations accurately, give clear advantages, and end with concrete sports uses.
Answer outline
Introduction
W. H. Sheldon introduced somatotyping in the 1940s, naming three components after the embryonic germ layers; Barbara Heath and J. E. L. Carter published 'A modified somatotype method' in 1967.
Somatotype and Sheldon's method
- Somatotype: a three number rating, written endomorphy, mesomorphy, ectomorphy, for example 2-5-3.
- Endomorphy: relative fatness; mesomorphy: relative musculoskeletal robustness; ectomorphy: relative linearity.
- Sheldon rated each component on a 1 to 7 scale from photographs; in Atlas of Men (1954) the pure endomorph is 7-1-1, the pure mesomorph 1-7-1 and the pure ectomorph 1-1-7.
- His 'constitutional psychology' tied body type to temperament and even to criminality; these claims are now widely dismissed, and Barbara Heath accused him of falsifying data.
Heath-Carter anthropometric method
- Ten measurements: height, body mass, four skinfolds (triceps, subscapular, supraspinale, medial calf), two bone breadths (humerus and femur biepicondylar), two girths (flexed upper arm, calf).
- Endomorphy = -0.7182 + 0.1451X - 0.00068X² + 0.0000014X³, where X = sum of triceps, subscapular and supraspinale skinfolds (mm) × 170.18/height (cm).
- Mesomorphy = 0.858 humerus breadth + 0.601 femur breadth + 0.188 corrected arm girth + 0.161 corrected calf girth - 0.131 height + 4.5 (girths corrected by subtracting the skinfold in cm).
- Ectomorphy from HWR = height/cube root of weight: if HWR ≥ 40.75, 0.732 HWR - 28.58; if between 38.25 and 40.75, 0.463 HWR - 17.63; if HWR ≤ 38.25, 0.1.
- Plotted on a somatochart: X = ectomorphy - endomorphy, Y = 2 × mesomorphy - (endomorphy + ectomorphy).
- A photoscopic method rates from a standardised photograph; photographs are especially useful for longitudinal growth studies.
Advantages over Sheldon
- Objective and reproducible: equations replace subjective photo rating.
- Open ended scale: ratings of 7½ and above are possible, and half units are used.
- The rating is phenotypical: it describes present shape, so change with growth, training and diet can be followed.
- Applicable to both sexes from childhood to old age.
- Needs only body measurements, not standardised photographs.
- Allows group statistics such as the somatotype attitudinal mean (SAM), the mean of a group of somatotypes.
Applications in sports science
- Each event tends to a typical physique: long distance runners lean towards ectomorphy, weightlifters and shot putters towards mesomorphy, and gymnasts are typically mesomorph dominant.
- Comparing a young athlete's rating with such profiles helps identify events where the athlete may have a natural advantage.
- Repeated ratings track the effect of training and diet on physique over a season or a career.
- The Heath-Carter method remains in use in anthropometric research, sports science and physical education.
Conclusion
Somatotyping turned from Sheldon's typology into a quantitative tool through Heath and Carter, and it remains a widely used summary of body shape in sports science, though it must be combined with physiological and skill tests.
Examples and data to cite
- Heath and Carter, 'A modified somatotype method', American Journal of Physical Anthropology 27: 57 to 74 (1967).
- Carter and Heath, Somatotyping: Development and Applications (1990).
- W. H. Sheldon, Atlas of Men (1954).
Facts to remember
- Ten measurements in the Heath-Carter method; height corrected endomorphy multiplies the skinfold sum by 170.18/height (cm).
- HWR thresholds 40.75 and 38.25 for ectomorphy.
- Somatochart coordinates X = III - I, Y = 2II - (I + III).
- Sheldon's three components named after endoderm, mesoderm and ectoderm.