Discuss ‘incest taboo’ as the basis of development of kinship systems in human societies.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
The incest taboo, a near-universal prohibition on sex and marriage between close kin, forces people to seek spouses outside the family, so it creates exogamy, alliance between groups and rules of descent and marriage; Lévi-Strauss saw it as the start of culture and the foundation of kinship.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Define the taboo, review the theories of its origin, then show how it generates kinship structures (exogamy, alliance, clans, cross-cousin marriage) with examples, and note exceptions and limits.
Answer outline
Introduction
Every known society forbids sexual relations between some close relatives, usually parent and child and full siblings, though the range of prohibited kin varies by culture.
Theories of origin
- Biological: inbreeding raises homozygosity and the expression of harmful recessive traits, and children of close relatives have lower survival.
- Westermarck effect (1891), the most widely held hypothesis: those raised together form a non-erotic attachment; Joseph Shepher (1971) found no marriages within kibbutz peer groups, and Arthur Wolf's Taiwanese study of girls adopted into the groom's family found more divorce and infidelity and lower fertility.
- Psychoanalytic theory, through the Oedipus complex, treated incest as an instinctual desire, not an aversion.
- Alliance: Lévi-Strauss, The Elementary Structures of Kinship (1949), drawing on Mauss's The Gift.
Taboo as basis of kinship
- Converts a negative rule into a positive one: giving a daughter or sister outside creates a reciprocal circle in which the giver receives a woman from the other group.
- Restricted exchange: symmetric, between two groups, giving bilateral cross-cousins; generalised exchange: asymmetric, among at least three groups, through marriage with the matrilateral (MBD) or patrilateral (FZD) cross-cousin.
- Lévi-Strauss judged matrilateral marriage structurally superior because its longer cycles create more cohesion; generalised exchange can rank wife-givers above wife-takers.
- Extension to clans produces clan and gotra exogamy.
Examples
- Most forms of Hinduism require marriage outside one's gotra.
- Among the Baganda of Uganda, people of the same totem clan may not marry.
- Trobriand Islanders (Malinowski) forbid sex between a woman and her brother as a same-clan matter in their matrilineal system, and between a woman and her father for other reasons, while a man's relations with his father's sister are encouraged.
- Matrilateral cross-cousin marriage among the Kachin.
Exceptions and critique
- Brother and sister marriage, usually between half siblings, among ruling classes in Egypt, the Inca, China and Hawaii, mainly to keep power within the family.
- Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, Section 5: parties may not be within the degrees of prohibited relationship or sapindas of each other unless the custom or usage governing each of them permits.
- The relatives covered differ between cultures, so the taboo explains the existence but not the form of kinship systems.
Conclusion
The incest taboo is the hinge between biology and culture: by forcing marriage outside, it turns the family into a unit of exchange and so lays the base of all kinship systems.
Examples and data to cite
- Claude Lévi-Strauss, The Elementary Structures of Kinship (1949).
- Edvard Westermarck (1891) on childhood co-residence and sexual aversion.
- Joseph Shepher (1971), kibbutz peer group marriages.
- Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, Section 5 on prohibited degrees and sapinda relationships.
Facts to remember
- Incest taboo is almost universal for nuclear family members.
- Exogamy follows from the incest taboo.
- Westermarck effect: childhood co-residence produces sexual aversion.
- Restricted and generalised exchange: Lévi-Strauss.