Write notes on the following in about 150 words each : Ethics in anthropological fieldwork
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Write notes
The core of a good answer
Fieldwork ethics rests on the duty to do no harm, voluntary informed consent, honesty about the research, protection of informants' identity and data, and a fair return of results to the studied community; these duties became formal codes after controversies such as Project Camelot and the Human Terrain System.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A short note of about 150 words: define the ethical problem peculiar to fieldwork (long, intimate stay among people with less power than the researcher), list the core principles, and show with one or two cases why they matter. A line on the Indian context adds value.
Answer outline
Introduction
Anthropological fieldwork places the researcher inside people's lives for long periods, so the relationship carries obligations to the people studied that come before obligations to science, sponsors or career.
Core principles
- Do no harm: physical, social, legal or economic risk to informants must be anticipated and avoided.
- Informed consent: participants must understand the purpose, risks and use of the research and be free to refuse or withdraw; consent is an ongoing process, often oral in non-literate communities.
- Openness: no covert research or undisclosed sponsorship; the researcher's identity and funding should be clear.
- Confidentiality and anonymity: pseudonyms for persons and villages, secure storage of field notes, photographs and genetic samples.
- Reciprocity and accessibility: results shared with the community in usable form; respect for intellectual and cultural property.
Special problems in the field
- Power asymmetry between researcher and vulnerable groups such as tribes, migrants or refugees.
- Gatekeepers (headmen, officials) may give consent on behalf of others; individual consent is still needed.
- Collection of blood, DNA or skeletal material raises questions of secondary use and benefit sharing.
- Dual role dilemmas: the anthropologist as advocate, consultant to the state, or witness to illegal acts.
Landmark controversies
- Project Camelot (begun 1964, cancelled 8 July 1965), a US Army counterinsurgency study run through SORO with Latin America as its first target, led the AAA to resolve against participation in clandestine intelligence activities.
- The AAA's 1967 Statement on Problems of Anthropological Research and Ethics asked anthropologists not to serve as cover for clandestine intelligence work.
- The Human Terrain System, embedding social scientists with US military units, drew an AAA Executive Board statement on 31 October 2007 citing informed consent and the duty to do no harm.
- Patrick Tierney's book Darkness in El Dorado (2000) accused scientists who had worked among the Yanomami, including over a 1968 measles vaccination campaign, and set off a long debate in the AAA.
Conclusion
Ethics is not a form to be filled before entering the field but a continuing negotiation with the people studied; a good note ends by stressing community participation and benefit.
Examples and data to cite
- AAA Principles of Professional Responsibility: seven headings beginning with 'Do No Harm' and 'Obtain Informed Consent and Necessary Permissions'.
- AAA Code of Ethics, June 1998; Executive Board statement on the Human Terrain System, 31 October 2007.
- The Belmont Report (released 30 September 1978, USA) set out respect for persons, beneficence and justice for research on human subjects.
- In India, the ICMR National Ethical Guidelines for Biomedical and Health Research Involving Human Participants (2017) govern research that collects biological samples.
Facts to remember
- The seven AAA principles: Do No Harm; Be Open and Honest Regarding Your Work; Obtain Informed Consent and Necessary Permissions; Weigh Competing Ethical Obligations Due Collaborators and Affected Parties; Make Your Results Accessible; Protect and Preserve Your Records; Maintain Respectful and Ethical Professional Relationships.
- Informed consent must be voluntary, informed and revocable.
- Anonymity protects identity; confidentiality protects data.