How would you find out that a particular disease/disorder is inherited and, if so, in which manner? Elaborate with suitable examples.
20 marks · directive: Elaborate
The core of a good answer
A disorder is shown to be inherited by familial clustering, higher concordance in identical than fraternal twins, adoption studies, chromosomal and molecular findings and population data; its mode of inheritance (autosomal dominant or recessive, X-linked, Y-linked, mitochondrial or multifactorial) is then read from pedigree patterns and segregation ratios and confirmed by locating the gene.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question has two parts: methods to establish a genetic basis, and methods to identify the mode of transmission. 'Elaborate' requires each method to be explained with a named disorder, so the answer should move from family and twin studies to pedigree criteria and modern molecular tools.
Answer outline
Introduction
Clustering of a disease in families may reflect shared genes or shared environment, so human geneticists use several converging methods, since experimental breeding is impossible in humans.
Step 1: Is it genetic at all?
- Family studies: risk to first degree relatives compared with the general population (relative risk).
- Twin studies: concordance in monozygotic twins considerably higher than in dizygotic twins indicates a genetic component.
- Adoption studies: a natural experiment that sets the same genotype in a different environment.
- Consanguinity: excess of a disorder among offspring of cousin marriages suggests recessive inheritance.
- Population studies: ethnic or regional concentration, such as sickle cell disease among India's tribal communities.
- Cytogenetics: karyotyping detects chromosomal disorders such as Down syndrome (trisomy 21).
Step 2: Pedigree analysis for the mode of inheritance
- Autosomal dominant: every generation affected, affected child has an affected parent, both sexes equally, 50 percent risk to children of an affected parent; examples Huntington disease, achondroplasia, Marfan syndrome.
- Autosomal recessive: skips generations, unaffected carrier parents, 25 percent risk to sibs, both sexes equally; examples β-thalassaemia, oculocutaneous albinism.
- X-linked recessive: mostly males, affected sons usually have unaffected mothers, no father to son transmission; examples haemophilia in Queen Victoria's descendants (probably haemophilia B), Duchenne muscular dystrophy, red-green colour blindness.
- X-linked dominant: affected father passes it to all daughters and no sons; example X-linked hypophosphataemic (vitamin D resistant) rickets.
- Y-linked: only males, father to all sons; hairy ear rims were proposed as an example from Indian pedigrees, but a 2004 study in southern India found the trait not Y-linked there.
- Mitochondrial: transmitted by affected mothers to all children, never by fathers; example Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy.
Step 3: Statistical and molecular confirmation
- Linkage analysis with LOD scores maps the gene; the Huntington disease gene was approximately located on chromosome 4 in 1983 and identified in 1993.
- Complicating factors: variable expression, new mutations (about 80 percent of achondroplasia cases arise from a new mutation), and anticipation, as when Huntington CAG repeats grow between generations.
Multifactorial disorders
- Neural tube defects (spina bifida, anencephaly) and type 1 diabetes run in families but do not fit simple Mendelian ratios; disease appears past a threshold at one tail of a continuous liability.
Conclusion
Establishing inheritance is cumulative: family and twin data suggest it, pedigrees show its pattern, and molecular genetics proves it; this knowledge underlies genetic counselling, carrier screening and programmes such as India's sickle cell elimination mission.
Examples and data to cite
- The National Sickle Cell Anaemia Elimination Mission was launched on 1 July 2023 at Shahdol, Madhya Pradesh, focused on tribal communities, with the aim of eliminating the disease as a public health problem by 2047.
- Cystic fibrosis gene (CFTR) on chromosome 7 identified in 1989.
- Huntington disease gene HTT (CAG repeat expansion) on chromosome 4 identified in 1993.
- Haemophilia in European royal families traced to Queen Victoria; analysis of Tsarevich Alexei's remains in 2009 indicated haemophilia B.
Facts to remember
- Autosomal recessive cross of two carriers: 1 affected : 2 carriers : 1 normal.
- Autosomal dominant affected heterozygote × normal: 50 percent affected offspring.
- No male to male transmission rules out X-linked inheritance.
- LOD score of 3 or more is conventional evidence of linkage.