Critically discuss how culture determines human behaviour in the light of Leslie White's theory.
15 marks · directive: Critically discuss
The core of a good answer
For Leslie White culture is a symbolic system with its own laws (culturology), driven by technology and the capture of energy (White's law, C = E × T), so human behaviour is explained by culture rather than by individual psychology; the view clarified long term evolution but was criticised as deterministic, universalist and blind to agency and specific history.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must first set out White's culturology (symbol, three subsystems, energy law, cultural determinism) and then 'critically' assess it with counter arguments from Steward, Sahlins and Service and the Boasians.
Answer outline
Introduction
Leslie A. White (1900 to 1975), a neo-evolutionist who taught at the University of Michigan from 1930 to 1970, argued that culture can be studied as a thing in itself, a science he called culturology.
Culture as symbolic
- All human behaviour originates in the use of symbols; animals cannot grasp the meaning of, for example, the sign of the cross to a Christian ('The Symbol: The Origin and Basis of Human Behavior', 1940).
- Behaviour of a person (language, food habits, kinship terms) is therefore a function of the culture into which he is born, not of his biology or psychology.
Three subsystems and the energy law
- Technological, sociological and ideological components; technology is the primary determining factor (a cultural pyramid with technology at the base and philosophy at the top).
- Other factors constant, culture evolves as the amount of energy harnessed per capita per year increases or as the efficiency of the means of putting it to work increases: C = E × T (White's law, 1943).
- Stages of energy: human muscle power; domesticated animals; plants (agricultural revolution); fossil fuels; nuclear energy.
- Key books: The Science of Culture (1949), The Evolution of Culture (1959).
Strengths
- Revived evolutionism (The Evolution of Culture, 1959) against the Boasian anthropology of the time and gave it a materialist criterion.
- Trained later neo-evolutionists such as Marshall Sahlins at Michigan.
Criticisms
- Determinism: critics argue that culture does not act by itself; individuals interpret and change it.
- Universalism: White thought in broad, universal schemes, while Julian Steward preferred a limited, multilinear strategy stressing different adaptations to different environments.
- Sahlins and Service, Evolution and Culture (1960), tried to synthesise White and Steward; Sahlins separated general evolution (growing complexity and adaptiveness) from specific evolution (divergent development of particular cultures).
- Boasian opposition: Robert Lowie called White's work 'a farrago of immature metaphysical notions'.
Conclusion
White rightly showed that behaviour is learned and shaped by symbolic culture, but contemporary anthropology sees culture and individuals as mutually constituting rather than one simply determining the other.
Examples and data to cite
- Culturology, outlined in the essays of The Science of Culture (1949), was what White considered his greatest contribution.
- White was President of the American Anthropological Association in 1964.
- Kroeber's 'The Superorganic' (1917) had earlier treated culture as a level above the individual.
Facts to remember
- C = E × T, where C is the degree of cultural development, E energy consumed per capita per year, T the efficiency of the technical means of using it.
- Order of determination in White: technology, then social system, then philosophy (ideology).
- White's work is counted among neo-evolutionist works.