Compare Edmund Leach's structuralism with interpretive anthropology of Clifford Geertz.
20 marks · directive: Compare
The core of a good answer
Leach, adapting Lévi-Strauss, treated culture as a system of communication whose meaning lies in underlying binary oppositions and transformations, while Geertz treated culture as publicly shared 'webs of significance' to be interpreted through thick description of local meanings; both moved anthropology from function to meaning, but Leach sought hidden structure and Geertz sought context bound interpretation.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
'Compare' requires similarities and differences on the same axes (concept of culture, method, goal, data, view of the actor, strengths and criticisms), with each scholar's key works and examples. A comparison table followed by an evaluative conclusion fits 20 marks.
Answer outline
Introduction
Edmund Leach (1910 to 1989) was a central British interpreter of the structuralism of Claude Lévi-Strauss, while Clifford Geertz (1926 to 2006) led interpretive anthropology in the United States.
Leach's structuralism
- Political Systems of Highland Burma (1954): Kachin gumsa (hierarchical) and gumlao systems form an oscillatory model, gumsa polities becoming gumlao and back; he presented them as ideal models.
- A central British interpreter of Claude Lévi-Strauss (Lévi-Strauss, 1970), who applied structural analysis to myth (Genesis as Myth, 1969).
- Culture and Communication (1976) treated culture as communication.
- Considered himself 'at heart, still a functionalist', using structure to explain actual social choices.
Geertz's interpretive anthropology
- Man is 'an animal suspended in webs of significance he himself has spun'; culture is those webs, and its analysis is 'not an experimental science in search of law but an interpretative one in search of meaning' (The Interpretation of Cultures, 1973).
- Thick description, a term from the philosopher Gilbert Ryle, adds the context that gives behaviour its meaning, as against thin description of surface behaviour.
- 'Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight' (Daedalus, 1972) reads the cockfight as the Balinese commentary on themselves, with cocks standing for their owners' selves and status.
- 'Religion as a Cultural System' (1966), in Anthropological Approaches to the Study of Religion, ed. Michael Banton.
- Other works: The Religion of Java (1960), Agricultural Involution (1963), Negara (1980), Local Knowledge (1983).
Similarities
- Both treat culture as a symbolic system of meaning rather than a functional adaptation.
- Both draw on linguistics and semiotics and stress myth, ritual and classification.
- Both challenge positivist, natural science models of society.
Differences
- Locus of meaning: Leach looks for unconscious structures beneath the surface; Geertz holds meaning is public and located in social action.
- Goal: Leach seeks general logical principles; Geertz seeks particular, context specific understanding ('local knowledge').
- Method: formal analysis of oppositions and transformations versus ethnographic thick description.
- Generalisation: Leach compares across cultures; Geertz is wary of universals and wrote 'The Cerebral Savage: On the Work of Claude Lévi-Strauss' (Encounter, 1967).
Criticisms
- Leach: the oscillatory gumsa and gumlao model has been criticised as overly theoretical and inattentive to historical events.
- Geertz: Talal Asad argued that his universal definition of religion is Eurocentric, dualistic, and leaves a gap between 'cultural system' and 'social reality'.
Conclusion
Leach and Geertz represent two routes from function to meaning: structural explanation and hermeneutic interpretation; contemporary anthropology combines Geertz's attention to local meaning with Leach's concern for structure, power and change.
Examples and data to cite
- Kachin gumsa and gumlao oscillation (Leach, 1954).
- Balinese cockfight as 'deep play' (Geertz, 1972).
- Leach's Reith Lectures, A Runaway World? (1967).
- Talal Asad's critique of Geertz's concept of religion; Asad's 'The Idea of an Anthropology of Islam' also faulted Geertz for imposing a modern Western concept of religion.
Facts to remember
- Leach (1910 to 1989): Political Systems of Highland Burma 1954; Rethinking Anthropology 1961; Pul Eliya 1961; Genesis as Myth 1969; Lévi-Strauss 1970; Culture and Communication 1976.
- Geertz: The Religion of Java 1960; Agricultural Involution 1963; The Interpretation of Cultures 1973; Negara 1980; Local Knowledge 1983.
- Thick description: term introduced by Gilbert Ryle (1968).