Discuss, with appropriate examples, how basic personality types may lead towards building up of national character.
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Culture and personality theorists argued that common child rearing and primary institutions produce a basic or modal personality shared by members of a society, and that this shared personality, projected onto institutions, appears at the national level as national character; the idea was influential in wartime studies of Japan and Russia but was criticised for method, for treating one class's ideology as the whole culture, and for over generalisation.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain the concepts (basic personality structure, modal personality, national character), the mechanism linking them, the classic studies as examples, and a critical view. 'Discuss' allows assessment of how far the link holds.
Answer outline
Introduction
The culture and personality school (Benedict, Kardiner, Linton, Du Bois) held that each culture shapes a characteristic personality; during the Second World War this approach was scaled up to whole nations.
Basic and modal personality
- Abram Kardiner, a psychoanalyst who worked closely with anthropologists, wrote The Individual and His Society (1939) with Ralph Linton; the Culture and Personality school held that a basic personality structure is shared by members of a culture.
- Cora Du Bois, The People of Alor (1944): refined basic personality into modal personality structure; individuals vary, but each culture favours one or a few personality types that become the most common.
From personality type to national character
- When a nation shares socialisation practices, the modal personality shapes political style, work ethic and attitudes to authority.
- Ruth Benedict, The Chrysanthemum and the Sword (1946), compiled her wartime analyses of Japanese culture and popularised the contrast between a Japanese 'shame culture' and a Western 'guilt culture'.
- Geoffrey Gorer wrote The People of Great Russia (1949) while working in the United States.
- Benedict, Patterns of Culture (1934): each culture selects a few traits that become the leading personality traits of its members; restrained (Apollonian) Pueblo Zuni versus Dionysian abandon of the Great Plains nations, with the Kwakiutl and Dobu as further cases.
Criticisms
- Stereotyping: ignores class, regional, caste, gender and individual variation within nations.
- Studies of 'culture at a distance': as Japan could not be visited, Benedict worked from literature, newspapers, films, recordings and interviews with Japanese-Americans.
- Reductionism and method: critics, including Japanese scholars, found methodological errors in Benedict's book and argued it presented one class's ideology as the whole culture.
Continuing relevance
- Nation building programmes use education and media to cultivate shared values.
Conclusion
Shared socialisation can produce common personality tendencies that colour a nation's institutions, but national character is better seen as a set of probabilistic tendencies shaped by history and policy than as a fixed psychological essence.
Examples and data to cite
- Benedict's study of Japan was done for the US Office of War Information to understand and predict Japanese wartime behaviour.
- Du Bois's Alor fieldwork (1937 to 1939, among the Abui) used life histories and Rorschach and other personality tests, interpreted with Kardiner.
Facts to remember
- Basic personality structure: Culture and Personality school (Kardiner and Linton).
- Modal personality: Cora Du Bois (1944).
- National character studies: Benedict on Japan (1946), Gorer on Russia (1949).