What are the evidences available regarding crops and domesticated animals of Indus Valley Civilization ? What are the views of the scholars regarding Indus script ?
15 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Plant and animal remains show a mixed farming economy based on barley and wheat in winter and rice, millets and beans in summer, with peas, sesame, dates and cotton, and herds of cattle, buffalo, goat and pig; the script, with over 400 signs in very short inscriptions, remains undeciphered, with Dravidian, Indo-Aryan, Munda and non-linguistic interpretations competing.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question has two parts and both need balanced coverage: the evidence (sites, plant and animal remains, depictions) for subsistence, and a survey of scholarly positions on the script with their main arguments.
Answer outline
Introduction
From Neolithic Mehrgarh (from about 7000 BCE) to the Mature Harappan cities (about 2600 to 1900 BCE), farming and herding formed the economic base of the civilisation.
Crops
- Mehrgarh's farmers grew mostly barley with a small amount of wheat.
- Early Harappan villagers domesticated peas, sesame, dates and cotton.
- Bates and others (2016) show the Indus people were the earliest to multi-crop across both seasons: wheat, barley and pulses in winter; rice, millets and beans in summer; they also point to a separate rice domestication from wild Oryza nivara, with wetland japonica rice arriving around 2000 BCE.
- Kalibangan has the earliest ploughed field revealed by excavation (about 2800 BCE, pre-Harappan), with a grid of furrows, a pattern still used locally for growing mustard and gram together.
Animals
- The diet included cattle, buffalo, goat, pig and chicken.
- Seals show humped cattle like the zebu, which was probably domesticated independently in the subcontinent, likely in Baluchistan.
- Camel bones were found at Kalibangan.
Indus script: features
- Over 400 principal signs (Mahadevan's 1977 concordance listed 419), with inscriptions averaging about five signs.
- Mostly written right to left; no bilingual text exists, and over 100 published decipherment claims have won no consensus.
Scholarly views
- Dravidian: Henry Heras (1953), Yuri Knorozov (1965, using computer analysis), Asko Parpola (Deciphering the Indus Script, 1994) and Iravatham Mahadevan.
- Indo-Aryan: S. R. Rao (Lothal and the Indus Civilization, 1973) claimed a decipherment; John Mitchiner called it subjective and unconvincing.
- Munda: less popular, since reconstructed early Munda vocabulary does not reflect Harappan culture.
- Non-linguistic: Farmer, Sproat and Witzel (2004) argued the signs are not writing; Rajesh Rao and others (2009) found conditional entropy close to linguistic systems, a method Sproat said lacks discriminating power.
Conclusion
Subsistence evidence is strong and growing through archaeobotany, while the script remains the largest unsolved problem of South Asian archaeology.
Examples and data to cite
- Mehrgarh barley with some wheat, from about 7000 BCE.
- Kalibangan ploughed field, about 2800 BCE.
- Mahadevan's concordance (1977), 419 signs.
- Farmer, Sproat and Witzel (2004).
- Rao and others in Science (2009).
Facts to remember
- Winter crops: wheat, barley, pulses; summer crops: rice, millets, beans.
- Zebu likely domesticated independently in South Asia.
- Over 100 decipherment claims, none accepted.
- Script mainly right to left.