Make a critical appraisal of the mesolithic culture of Ganga basin with reference to artifacts, faunal and human skeletal remains excavated from different sites.
20 marks · directive: Critically appraise
The core of a good answer
The oxbow lake sites of Pratapgarh district, Sarai Nahar Rai, Mahadaha and Damdama, show semi-sedentary hunter-foragers with microliths, grinding stones, hearths, burnt plaster floors, rich fauna and cemeteries holding the largest collection of Mesolithic human skeletons in Asia, though dating, faunal identification and the question of incipient domestication remain debated.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A critical appraisal must describe the evidence site by site under the three heads named (artifacts, fauna, human skeletons), then evaluate what it does and does not prove about Mesolithic life, chronology and the transition to food production.
Answer outline
Introduction
The Mesolithic of the middle Ganga plain was revealed from the 1970s by the University of Allahabad (G. R. Sharma and colleagues) at sites on the banks of oxbow lakes in Pratapgarh district, Uttar Pradesh, contrasting with the Vindhyan rock shelters and open sites to the south.
Sarai Nahar Rai
- On a filled-up oxbow lake about 15 km south-west of Pratapgarh; about 1,800 sq m; excavated in 1973 and 1975 under G. R. Sharma.
- 11 burials with 14 individuals, including one quadruple burial; eight pit hearths and a hut floor.
- Fauna reported (Alur, 1980) as cattle, buffalo, gaur, elephant and rhinoceros, though the identifications are disputed.
- A date of 8395 plus or minus 110 BCE is regarded as highly questionable because of sample suitability, contamination and method.
Mahadaha
- About 8,000 sq m on the western bank of an oxbow lake, divided into a lake area and a combined cemetery-cum-habitation and butchering area; about 60 cm of deposit in four layers.
- 28 graves with 30 individuals, including two double burials.
- Fauna shows specialised hunting of swamp deer and hog deer and intensive use of aquatic resources; bandicoot rat remains increase in later phases.
- A charred animal bone gave an accelerator date of 6320 plus or minus 80 BP (OxA-1647).
Damdama
- About 8,750 sq m at the confluence of two branches of the Tambura nala, a tributary of the Pili river; 1.5 m of undisturbed deposit.
- 41 human graves in different layers; fauna of blackbuck, gazelle, wild pig and nilgai with no domestic animals; plant remains of wild grasses and goosefoot (Chenopodium album).
- Thermoluminescence suggests 7000 to 5000 BCE; AMS dates on human bone of 8865 and 8640 plus or minus 65 BP.
Artifacts and human skeletal remains
- Common finds across the three sites: microliths (retouched blades, points, awls, lunates, triangles and trapezes), querns, mullers, ring stones, sling stones, hammer stones and anvils, and simple bone and antler jewellery.
- The dead were buried in shallow rectangular graves, generally in extended position, within the habitation area.
- Skeletal studies by Lukacs (1977), Kennedy, Lovell and Burrow (1986), Kennedy and colleagues (1992) and Lukacs and Pal (2003); Lukacs and Pal concluded that Damdama reflects a hunting and foraging subsistence system.
- Dental pathology and tooth size at Damdama match those reported at Mahadaha and Sarai Nahar Rai.
Critical appraisal
- Strength: the largest collection of Mesolithic human skeletons in Asia allows study of health, diet and demography.
- Thick occupation deposits, querns and plaster floors point to a semi-sedentary way of life rather than periodic migration, a precondition for later farming.
- Weakness: dating is uneven, with a doubtful early date at Sarai Nahar Rai and only a few AMS dates.
- Alur's identification of domestic cattle, sheep and goat at Sarai Nahar Rai and Mahadaha is contested, and later Damdama faunal studies found no domestic animals.
Conclusion
The Ganga basin Mesolithic shows complex, semi-sedentary foragers exploiting lake ecologies, an important step towards the Neolithic, but firmer chronology and fresh analysis are needed before strong claims about early domestication can be made.
Examples and data to cite
- Sarai Nahar Rai: 11 burials, 14 individuals; excavated 1973 and 1975 by the University of Allahabad.
- Mahadaha: 28 graves, 30 individuals; AMS date 6320 plus or minus 80 BP (OxA-1647).
- Damdama: 41 graves; TL dates 7000 to 5000 BCE.
- Comparable Vindhyan evidence: Lekhahia rock shelter (17 fragmentary skeletons) and Chopani Mando (37 circular huts, cord-impressed pottery, wild rice husk on pottery).
Facts to remember
- All three sites lie on oxbow lakes or stream confluences in Pratapgarh district, Uttar Pradesh.
- Tool kit: microliths such as lunates, triangles and trapezes, grinding stones, and bone and antler artifacts.
- Skeletal studies: J. R. Lukacs, K. A. R. Kennedy and J. N. Pal.