Does caste as a social category exist among the non-Hindu communities in India ? Illustrate your answer with suitable examples.
15 marks · directive: Illustrate
The core of a good answer
Yes: although Islam, Christianity, Sikhism and Buddhism reject caste in doctrine, caste-like stratification based on descent, endogamy, occupation and ritual or social distance persists among Indian Muslims, Christians and Sikhs, though usually without the full Hindu ideology of purity and pollution.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must take a position and support it with ethnographic and legal examples from each major non-Hindu community, noting both similarities to and differences from Hindu caste.
Answer outline
Introduction
Caste is a hierarchy of endogamous, hereditary groups with occupational links; scholars debate whether caste outside Hinduism is 'real' caste or a weaker form of status stratification.
Muslims
- Broad division into Ashraf (claiming foreign descent, such as Syeds, who trace descent from Fatima, and Shaikhs), Ajlaf (non-Ashraf, generally backward-caste converts in menial occupations) and Arzal (converts from untouchable Hindu castes).
- Ashrafisation: weavers (julaha) began identifying as Ansaris and butchers as Qureshis to claim higher status.
- Studied by Ghaus Ansari, Muslim Caste in Uttar Pradesh: A Study of Culture Contact (1960), and in Imtiaz Ahmad's edited volume Caste and Social Stratification among the Muslims (1973).
- The term Pasmanda covers Ajlaf and Arzal Muslims, and campaigns seek affirmative action for lower Muslim groups.
Christians
- Syrian Christians of Kerala claim high status from a tradition of being elites evangelised by Thomas the Apostle, and do not marry Dalit Christians; the Knanaya form an endogamous subgroup.
- In some south Indian churches Dalits had separate seating or had to attend mass from outside.
- Indian law does not extend Scheduled Caste benefits to Christian converts from Scheduled Castes.
Sikhs and Buddhists
- Among Sikhs, ideas of purity and pollution are largely absent, but hierarchies of occupation and land persist: Jat Sikhs dominate, while Dalit Sikhs are mainly Mazhabis (from the Chuhra caste) and Ramdasias or Ravidasias (from the Chamar caste).
- As of 2003, around 10,000 of the 12,780 villages in Indian Punjab had separate gurdwaras for Dalit Sikhs.
- Scheduled Caste status was extended to Dalit converts to Sikhism nationwide in 1956 and to Buddhist converts in 1990.
- Neo-Buddhist (Navayana) converts followed Ambedkar's conversion at Nagpur in 1956 and remain recognised as Scheduled Castes.
Nature of non-Hindu caste
- Endogamy, occupational specialisation and hierarchy persist, but ritual purity is weaker, as the Sikh case shows.
- Caste survives because converts carried pre-existing social identities and because local society continued to treat them by origin.
Conclusion
Caste is better seen as a feature of South Asian social structure than of Hinduism alone; it survives across religions, which raises policy questions about extending SC status to Dalit Muslims and Christians.
Examples and data to cite
- Justice Ranganath Misra Commission, report submitted 21 May 2007, proposed allowing Dalits who convert to Islam or Christianity to avail of Scheduled Caste reservation.
- Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950, extended to Sikh converts (1956) and Buddhist converts (1990).
- Separate gurdwaras for Dalit Sikhs in about 10,000 Punjab villages (2003).
Facts to remember
- Ghaus Ansari, Muslim Caste in Uttar Pradesh (1960).
- Imtiaz Ahmad (ed.), Caste and Social Stratification among the Muslims (1973).
- B. R. Ambedkar's mass conversion to Buddhism at Nagpur, 14 October 1956.