Compare the ovule-bearing structures of Cycas and Pinus with the help of labelled diagrams.
15 marks · directive: Compare
The core of a good answer
Cycas bears its ovules on loose, leaf-like megasporophylls that are not organised into a cone and carry several large, erect, exposed ovules on their margins, whereas Pinus bears two inverted ovules on the upper surface of each ovuliferous scale, which sits in the axil of a bract scale in a compact, woody, compound female cone.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Three equal parts (5+5+5): describe the Cycas megasporophyll, describe the Pinus female cone and ovuliferous scale, then a point-by-point comparison. Diagrams expected: Cycas megasporophyll, longitudinal section of Cycas ovule, Pinus female cone, bract and ovuliferous scale with ovules (ventral view), and longitudinal section of Pinus ovule.
Answer outline
Introduction
Both are naked-seeded gymnosperms, but the female reproductive organ of Cycas is the most primitive among living seed plants, while that of Pinus is a highly condensed shoot system.
Cycas: megasporophylls
- Female plant has no compact cone; megasporophylls form a loose crown around the apex, and the stem apex continues vegetative growth through them.
- Each megasporophyll is leaf-like, covered with brown hairs: a distal lamina and a stalk.
- A few sessile ovules in two rows on the margins of the stalk, freely exposed.
- Ovules very large, orthotropous, with a single thick integument of three layers (outer fleshy, middle stony, inner fleshy) fused to the nucellus except at the apex.
- Nucellar beak and pollen chamber below the micropyle; a large female gametophyte with archegonia below an archegonial chamber; double vascular supply to the integument.
Pinus: female cone
- Compound strobilus: a central axis bearing spirally arranged bract scales, each with an ovuliferous (seed) scale in its axil.
- Ovuliferous scale is derived from a highly modified branchlet; in pines the exposed tip shows the umbo (first year's growth) and apophysis (second year's growth).
- Two ovules on the upper (adaxial) surface at the base of each ovuliferous scale, inverted so the micropyle faces the cone axis.
- Ovules small, with one integument and nucellus; female gametophyte with a few archegonia.
- Cone takes 18 to 24 months to mature in most pines; fertilisation is delayed about a year after pollination.
Point-by-point comparison
- Organisation: loose megasporophylls in Cycas versus a compact compound cone in Pinus.
- Nature: megasporophyll is a modified leaf in Cycas; ovuliferous scale is a reduced shoot in the axil of a bract in Pinus.
- Number of ovules: several per sporophyll in Cycas; always two per scale in Pinus.
- Position and orientation: marginal, erect (orthotropous) and exposed in Cycas; adaxial, inverted, protected between scales in Pinus.
- Size: Cycas ovules are large; Pinus ovules are small and its seeds mostly small and winged.
- Apex: female axis continues growth in Cycas; Pinus cone is determinate.
Conclusion
The series from the leafy, many-ovuled sporophyll of Cycas to the two-ovuled ovuliferous scale of Pinus illustrates reduction and condensation of female reproductive structures in gymnosperm evolution.
Examples and data to cite
- Cycas is the sole genus of the family Cycadaceae; its seeds have the double vascular system that characterises all living cycads.
- Conifer seed scales are interpreted as highly modified branchlets, that is, shoots rather than sporophylls.
- Cycas circinalis, endemic to India, was the first cycad described in western literature; C. revoluta is the most widely grown species.
Facts to remember
- Cycas ovule: orthotropous, single three-layered integument, pollen chamber and nucellar beak.
- Pinus ovule: inverted, two per ovuliferous scale, micropyle towards cone axis.
- Bract and ovuliferous scale are separate in Pinus but fully fused in Araucariaceae and Cupressaceae.
- Both are gymnosperms: ovules borne on the surface of the sporophyll or scale, with typically one integument.