Compare the sporophyte of Psilotum and Equisetum.
15 marks · directive: Compare
The core of a good answer
Both are homosporous, eusporangiate pteridophytes, but the Psilotum sporophyte lacks true roots and has dichotomous photosynthetic stems, vascular-less enations and three-lobed synangia, whereas Equisetum has adventitious roots, jointed ribbed stems with whorled scale leaves fused into sheaths, a canal-bearing stele and terminal strobili of peltate sporangiophores with elater-bearing spores.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A point-by-point comparison is expected: habit and organs, anatomy of stem, leaves, reproductive structures and spores, ideally in table form with diagrams of stem transverse sections and fertile parts.
Answer outline
Introduction
Psilotum (whisk fern, Psilotales) and Equisetum (horsetail, Equisetales) are both ferns in the broad sense: molecular studies place Psilotum as sister to the ophioglossoid ferns and Equisetum among the ferns.
Habit and organs
- Psilotum: no true roots; underground rhizome absorbs water and minerals with help from mycorrhizal fungi; aerial stems dichotomously branched and photosynthetic.
- Equisetum: deep underground rhizome bearing roots; aerial stems hollow, jointed into nodes and internodes, with usually 6 to 40 ridges, often with whorled branches; stems coated with abrasive silicates.
Leaves
- Psilotum: small scale-like enations spirally arranged, without vascular supply.
- Equisetum: reduced leaves in whorls at each node fused into a nodal sheath, each with a single unbranched vascular trace; photosynthesis is mainly by the stem in both.
Stem anatomy
- Psilotum: epidermis, photosynthetic outer cortex, inner cortex and endodermis around a central thick-walled protostele.
- Equisetum: ridges and furrows; sclerenchyma under ridges; vallecular canals in the cortex below furrows; vascular bundles opposite ridges each with a carinal canal (protoxylem lacuna); large central pith cavity; endarch xylem; siphonostele-like eustele.
Reproductive structures
- Psilotum: synangia, each formed by fusion of three eusporangia, borne laterally on the axes just above the enations; no strobilus.
- Equisetum: compact terminal strobilus of peltate, hexagonal sporangiophores in whorls, each bearing sac-like sporangia on its underside.
Spores and gametophyte link
- Psilotum: gametophyte small, colourless, underground and mycoheterotrophic, drawing carbon from mycorrhizal networks.
- Equisetum: each spore has four elaters that act as moisture-sensitive springs for dispersal.
- Both homosporous (Equisetum mostly so) with eusporangia.
Conclusion
Psilotum shows a simple, ancient body plan of stem and sporangia alone, while Equisetum has a highly organised jointed shoot, true roots and strobili; both nevertheless share homospory and eusporangia.
Examples and data to cite
- Psilotum is pantropical, and P. nudum also reaches the subtropics.
- Equisetum ramosissimum (branched horsetail), which now includes E. debile, occurs across Asia, Europe, Africa and the south-west Pacific.
- Field horsetail E. arvense has separate non-photosynthetic fertile shoots in early spring and green sterile shoots.
- Plants of the World Online accepts 18 Equisetum species; some researchers recognise 25.
Facts to remember
- Psilotum lacks true roots and true leaves.
- Equisetum stem: vallecular canals below furrows, carinal canals below ridges.
- Psilotum synangium is three-lobed; Equisetum sporangiophore is peltate.
- Each Equisetum spore bears four elaters.