Explain the structural variations of chromosomes and their significance.
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Structural variations (aberrations) of chromosomes arise from breakage and wrong rejoining and are of four kinds, deletion, duplication, inversion and translocation; each has a characteristic pairing configuration at meiosis and genetic effects, and together they have been important in evolution, speciation, disease and as tools in genetics and plant breeding.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain each type of structural change with its origin, meiotic behaviour (best shown by diagrams of pairing loops and translocation crosses) and genetic consequences, and then bring out their significance in evolution, breeding, gene mapping and human disease.
Answer outline
Introduction
Rearrangements arise when DNA breaks at two places and the broken ends rejoin in a new order, often in regions prone to misalign during repair; most change gene number or gene order without changing chromosome number.
Deletion (deficiency)
- Loss of a terminal or an interstitial (intercalary) segment; in heterozygotes the unpaired part of the normal homologue bulges out as a deletion loop.
- Pseudodominance: when the dominant allele is lost by a deletion, a recessive allele on the homologue is expressed, so a recessive trait mimics dominant inheritance.
- Example: cri du chat syndrome from a deletion in the short arm of human chromosome 5 (5p-).
Duplication
- Repetition of a chromosome segment; unequal crossing over is the process most responsible for creating regional duplications.
- A.H. Sturtevant demonstrated unequal crossing over in Drosophila and also discovered position effect.
- Duplications are an essential source of genetic novelty: one copy keeps the old function while the other is free to acquire a new one.
Inversion
- A segment turned through 180 degrees; paracentric (centromere outside the segment) or pericentric (centromere included).
- Heterozygotes form an inversion loop; crossing over within a paracentric inversion gives a dicentric bridge and an acentric fragment at anaphase I, and within a pericentric inversion gives duplication-deficiency gametes.
- Result: recombinant gametes are largely inviable, so recombination is effectively suppressed in the inverted region and gene combinations stay together, as with the colour-pattern genes linked by inversions in the butterfly Heliconius numata; Drosophila balancer chromosomes carry several nested inversions for this purpose.
Translocation
- Transfer of a segment to a non-homologous chromosome; reciprocal translocation exchanges segments.
- Reciprocal translocation heterozygotes pair as multivalents (rings or chains at metaphase I); some segregations give unbalanced gametes, so carriers have reduced fertility, while alternate disjunction gives balanced gametes.
- Robertsonian translocation: breaks at or near the centromeres of two acrocentric chromosomes and their fusion reduce the chromosome number (45 in human carriers). Human chromosome 2, by contrast, arose by end-to-end (telomere to telomere) fusion of two ancestral ape chromosomes.
Significance
- Evolution: inversions let inverted and standard arrangements evolve independently; Dobzhansky (1970) noted that genes within inversions had higher fitness. Oenothera lamarckiana forms a ring of 12 chromosomes plus one bivalent at meiosis because 6 of its 7 chromosomes are involved in reciprocal translocations; several of de Vries' 'mutants' were trisomics from irregular (3:1) separation of the ring, and gigas was a tetraploid.
- Plant breeding: Sears (1956) transferred leaf-rust resistance from Aegilops umbellulata to wheat, and radiation is used to transfer alien chromosome segments into wheat (Sears and Gustafson, 1993).
- Human disease and cancer: the Philadelphia chromosome t(9;22)(q34;q11) fuses BCR and ABL1 in most patients with chronic myeloid leukaemia; Robertsonian translocation causes about 3 to 4 percent of Down syndrome cases.
- Duplications supply new genes; position effects change gene expression when a gene is moved, often by translocation.
Conclusion
Structural changes alter gene dosage or gene order rather than gene content, which is why they matter so much for fertility, recombination and evolution, and why breeders and geneticists use them as tools.
Examples and data to cite
- E.R. Sears, transfer of leaf rust resistance from Aegilops umbellulata to wheat, 1956.
- R.E. Cleland explained Oenothera chromosome rings as translocation heterozygosity; O. lamarckiana forms a ring of 12 and one bivalent.
- Philadelphia chromosome discovered by Peter Nowell and David Hungerford, 1960.
Facts to remember
- Paracentric inversion crossing over: dicentric bridge and acentric fragment.
- Translocation heterozygotes: multivalent rings or chains at meiosis and reduced fertility.
- Pseudodominance can reveal a deletion.
- Inversions suppress the recovery of recombinants, because crossover products within the inversion are unbalanced.