Write short notes on the following in about 150 words each :
Munch hypothesis
10 marks · answer in 150 words · directive: Write short notes
The core of a good answer
The Munch (pressure flow or mass flow) hypothesis, proposed by Ernst Münch in 1930, explains phloem translocation as a bulk flow of sugar solution through sieve tubes, driven by a turgor pressure gradient that is set up osmotically between a source where sugar is loaded and a sink where it is unloaded.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A 150 word note: state who proposed it and when, explain the source to sink mechanism step by step, give the evidence for it and the main objections. A labelled sketch of the two osmometer model (source bulb, sink bulb, connecting tube) or of a leaf, sieve tube and root earns marks.
Answer outline
Introduction
Münch (1930) modelled the phloem on a physical system of two osmometers joined by a tube: the one with more solute takes up water, builds pressure and drives solution to the other.
Mechanism
- At the source (mature leaf) sucrose is actively loaded into companion cells and sieve elements, symplastically or by a sucrose and H+ symporter in the apoplastic route.
- The high solute concentration lowers water potential, so water enters the sieve tube from adjacent xylem by osmosis and turgor pressure rises.
- At the sink (roots, tubers, growing fruits, meristems) sucrose is unloaded and used in respiration or stored as starch; water leaves and pressure falls.
- The difference in hydrostatic pressure between source and sink drives a mass flow of sap through the sieve plate pores; water returns via the xylem, completing a circulation.
Evidence
- Sieve tube sap is under positive pressure: it exudes from cut stems and from severed aphid stylets.
- A sucrose concentration gradient from source to sink exists in many plants.
- Viruses and applied growth substances move with the assimilate stream only from photosynthesising leaves, which suggests bulk flow rather than diffusion.
- Defoliation (removing the source) or removing sinks stops or reverses flow.
Objections and limitations
- Mass flow is passive, but translocation depends on living sieve elements and companion cells and is sensitive to temperature and metabolic inhibitors.
- Different solutes may move at different speeds, which a pure bulk flow would not predict.
- Bidirectional movement in the same sieve tube is hard to explain; evidence on it is mixed.
- Sieve plates and P-protein offer resistance; the model needs a steep enough pressure gradient to overcome it.
Conclusion
Despite these objections the pressure flow model, combined with active loading and unloading, remains the most widely accepted explanation of phloem transport.
Examples and data to cite
- Ernst Münch, German plant physiologist, published the hypothesis in 1930 in 'Die Stoffbewegungen in der Pflanze'.
- The aphid stylet technique (1950s) gave pure sieve tube sap and direct evidence of positive pressure in the phloem.
- Polymer trap loading (Robert Turgeon) in plants such as cucurbits, where sucrose is converted to raffinose and stachyose that cannot diffuse back, is a variant source mechanism consistent with pressure flow.
Facts to remember
- Phloem translocation is from source to sink; a given organ (a young leaf) can change from sink to source as it matures.
- Sucrose is the main sugar translocated in most plants; sap is rich in sugar, amino acids and K+.
- Loading at the source and unloading at the sink are active, energy-using steps; the flow between them is passive.
- Rival older ideas: protoplasmic streaming (de Vries) and electro-osmotic theory (Spanner).