Differentiate between photophosphorylation and oxidative phosphorylation.
15 marks · directive: Differentiate
The core of a good answer
Both make ATP by chemiosmosis through an F-type ATP synthase, but photophosphorylation is light driven in the thylakoids with water as electron donor and NADP+ as acceptor, pumping protons into the lumen, while oxidative phosphorylation is driven by oxidation of NADH and FADH2 on the inner mitochondrial membrane with O2 as the final acceptor, pumping protons into the intermembrane space.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A comparison: start with what the two share (chemiosmotic coupling), then give point by point differences in a table (site, energy source, electron donor and acceptor, carriers, direction of proton pumping, products, inhibitors). Diagrams of the Z scheme and the respiratory chain help.
Answer outline
Introduction
Phosphorylation of ADP to ATP in cells happens by substrate level phosphorylation or by electron transport coupled phosphorylation; the latter occurs in chloroplasts and mitochondria.
Similarities
- Both use an electron transport chain in a membrane to set up a proton motive force (pH gradient plus membrane potential).
- Both use F0F1 type ATP synthase (CF0CF1 in chloroplasts); mechanism explained by Mitchell's chemiosmotic theory.
- Both involve quinones, cytochromes, iron sulphur proteins and Q cycle type complexes (cytochrome b6f and bc1).
Differences: site and energy
- Photo: thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts (plasma membrane of photosynthetic bacteria). Oxidative: inner mitochondrial membrane (cristae).
- Photo: energy from light absorbed by photosystems II and I. Oxidative: energy from oxidation of respiratory substrates.
- Photo: occurs only in light in green cells. Oxidative: in all aerobic cells, day and night.
Differences: electrons and protons
- Photo (non-cyclic): donor H2O, acceptor NADP+, O2 is released. Oxidative: donors NADH and FADH2, acceptor O2, water is formed.
- Photo: electrons move uphill from water to NADPH using light. Oxidative: electrons move downhill from NADH to O2.
- Photo: protons accumulate in the thylakoid lumen; ATP made on the stromal side. Oxidative: protons pumped into the intermembrane space; ATP made in the matrix.
- Photo: the proton gradient is mainly ΔpH (lumen pH about 5). Oxidative: mainly membrane potential.
Differences: forms, products and inhibitors
- Photo: cyclic (PS I only, ATP only) and non-cyclic (PS II and PS I, ATP, NADPH, O2). Oxidative: no such division; complexes I to IV.
- Photo: ATP and NADPH used mainly in the Calvin cycle in the stroma. Oxidative: ATP exported to the cytosol by the ADP/ATP translocator.
- Photo inhibitors: DCMU (diuron) blocks PS II to plastoquinone; paraquat diverts electrons from PS I. Oxidative inhibitors: rotenone (complex I), antimycin A (III), cyanide and CO (IV), oligomycin (ATP synthase).
- Uncouplers such as 2,4-dinitrophenol dissipate both gradients.
Conclusion
The two processes are mirror images in energy terms: one stores light energy in ATP and NADPH, the other releases chemical energy as ATP, but both rest on the same chemiosmotic machine.
Examples and data to cite
- Arnon and colleagues (1954) demonstrated photophosphorylation in isolated chloroplasts.
- Jagendorf and Uribe (1966) made chloroplasts synthesise ATP in the dark by an acid to base pH jump, supporting chemiosmosis.
- Peter Mitchell proposed the chemiosmotic theory in 1961 and received the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1978.
- Plant mitochondria have a cyanide resistant alternative oxidase that bypasses complexes III and IV (thermogenesis in Arum spadix).
Facts to remember
- About 3 to 4 protons cross ATP synthase per ATP; the chloroplast c ring has 14 subunits in spinach.
- Approximate P/O ratios: 2.5 for NADH and 1.5 for FADH2 (modern values).
- Linear (non-cyclic) electron flow alone yields somewhat less ATP per NADPH than the 3 ATP : 2 NADPH the Calvin cycle needs; cyclic flow makes up the deficit.
- Photorespiration and respiration interact through shared metabolites but are spatially separated.