Why is it necessary to measure the cell potential using potentiometer under zero-current conditions?
5 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
The thermodynamic emf (and hence ΔG = −nFE) is defined only for a cell working reversibly, which means with no net current; if current is drawn, the ohmic IR drop, electrode polarisation (overpotential) and concentration changes make the measured voltage smaller than the true emf, so a potentiometer, which balances the cell against an opposing voltage until the galvanometer shows null, is used.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Explain both the thermodynamic reason (reversibility) and the practical reasons (IR drop, polarisation, composition change), and say how the potentiometer achieves zero current.
Answer outline
Introduction
The emf of a cell is the potential difference between its electrodes when the cell reaction is at equilibrium with an exactly opposing external potential, i.e. when no current flows.
Thermodynamic reason
- Only a reversible process gives the maximum non-expansion work: ΔG = −nFE.
- A cell can be reversible only when it is balanced by an opposing voltage that differs from its own by an infinitesimal amount, i.e. at zero current.
- Values of E°, ΔG°, ΔH° (from dE/dT), ΔS° and K derived from cell measurements are valid only for zero current emf.
Practical reasons
- Ohmic (IR) drop: when current I flows through the internal resistance r of the cell, the terminal voltage V = E − Ir is less than E.
- Polarisation: current causes activation and concentration overpotentials at the electrodes, shifting their potentials from equilibrium values.
- Composition change: drawing current consumes reactants and forms products, so concentrations near the electrodes, and hence E from the Nernst equation, drift during measurement.
- An ordinary moving coil voltmeter draws current and therefore reads less than the emf.
How the potentiometer works
- A driver cell sends a steady current along a uniform wire; the test cell is connected in opposition through a galvanometer.
- The sliding contact is moved until the galvanometer shows no deflection (null point); at balance no current flows through the test cell.
- The emf is then compared with that of a standard cell (Weston cadmium cell, about 1.018 V near room temperature) from the ratio of balancing lengths.
Conclusion
Zero current makes the measurement both reversible (thermodynamically meaningful) and free of IR drop and polarisation.
Examples and data to cite
- Weston standard cell: Cd amalgam | CdSO₄ (saturated) | Hg₂SO₄ | Hg, emf about 1.0186 V, used as a laboratory standard for calibration and as the international standard of emf from 1911 until 1990; no current may be drawn from it.
Facts to remember
- ΔG = −nFE applies only to reversible (zero current) operation
- Terminal voltage V = E − Ir when current flows
- Overpotential η = E(under current) − E(equilibrium)
- Null method: balance length ratio gives E₁/E₂ = l₁/l₂