(i) Derive the expressions of chemical potential of a component in a mixture system in terms of extensive thermodynamic properties U, H, A and G.
(ii) Cadmium (m. pt. = 321 °C) and bismuth (m. pt. = 271 °C) do not form solid solutions or compounds with one another. Their eutectic point lies at 61 weight percent of bismuth and 146 °C. Sketch their phase diagram and label each region to show what phases are present. Explain the cooling curves of this eutectic mixture.
(iii) How does acetone-dry ice freezing mixture work?
25 marks · directive: Derive, sketch and explain
The core of a good answer
(i) μᵢ = (∂U/∂nᵢ)_S,V,nⱼ = (∂H/∂nᵢ)_S,P,nⱼ = (∂A/∂nᵢ)_T,V,nⱼ = (∂G/∂nᵢ)_T,P,nⱼ, obtained from the fundamental equation for U and its Legendre transforms; (ii) Cd and Bi form a simple eutectic system with two liquidus curves meeting at E (61 wt% Bi, 146 °C), and the eutectic melt cools like a pure substance with a single halt at 146 °C; (iii) solid CO₂ sublimes at −78.5 °C at 1 atm, and acetone, liquid down to about −95 °C, carries heat to the subliming solid, so the bath holds near −78 °C.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Three parts (10 + 10 + 5). (i) needs a clean derivation for an open multicomponent system. (ii) needs a labelled sketch (described here in words), the phase rule in each region, and cooling curves for pure metals, an off-eutectic mixture and the eutectic composition. (iii) needs the physical reason the temperature stays fixed.
Answer outline
Introduction
For an open system the internal energy depends on S, V and the amounts nᵢ of each component; the chemical potential is the change in a thermodynamic potential when a small amount of component i is added with the natural variables of that potential held fixed.
Step 1: (i) Fundamental equation for U
- U = U(S, V, n₁, n₂, ...)
- dU = (∂U/∂S)dS + (∂U/∂V)dV + Σ(∂U/∂nᵢ)dnᵢ = TdS − PdV + Σμᵢdnᵢ
- So μᵢ = (∂U/∂nᵢ) at constant S, V, nⱼ (j ≠ i)
Step 2: (i) H, A and G by Legendre transformation
- H = U + PV: dH = dU + PdV + VdP = TdS + VdP + Σμᵢdnᵢ, so μᵢ = (∂H/∂nᵢ)_S,P,nⱼ
- A = U − TS: dA = −SdT − PdV + Σμᵢdnᵢ, so μᵢ = (∂A/∂nᵢ)_T,V,nⱼ
- G = H − TS: dG = −SdT + VdP + Σμᵢdnᵢ, so μᵢ = (∂G/∂nᵢ)_T,P,nⱼ
- Only the last is a partial molar quantity (T and P intensive and held constant), so μᵢ is the partial molar Gibbs energy; integrating at constant T, P gives G = Σnᵢμᵢ and the Gibbs and Duhem equation Σnᵢdμᵢ = 0.
Step 3: (ii) The phase diagram (in words)
- Axes: composition, wt% Bi from 0 (pure Cd) to 100 (pure Bi), horizontally; temperature vertically.
- Point A at 321 °C on the Cd axis, point B at 271 °C on the Bi axis.
- Liquidus curve AE falls from 321 °C to the eutectic E (61 wt% Bi, 146 °C); liquidus curve BE falls from 271 °C to E.
- A horizontal eutectic (solidus) line runs at 146 °C across the full composition range.
Step 4: (ii) Labels and phase rule
- Above AEB: one phase, homogeneous liquid melt; condensed phase rule F′ = C − P + 1 = 2 − 1 + 1 = 2.
- Region AE and the 146 °C line (left): solid Cd + melt; F′ = 1.
- Region BE and the 146 °C line (right): solid Bi + melt; F′ = 1.
- Below 146 °C, left of E: solid Cd + eutectic solid (Cd + Bi); right of E: solid Bi + eutectic solid.
- At E: solid Cd + solid Bi + melt coexist, F′ = 0 (invariant point).
Step 5: (ii) Cooling curves
- Pure Cd (or pure Bi): smooth cooling of liquid, a horizontal halt at 321 °C (271 °C) while the metal freezes, then smooth cooling of the solid.
- Mixture richer in Cd than 61 wt% Bi, say 20 wt% Bi: smooth cooling until the liquidus; a break (change of slope) where Cd starts to crystallise and latent heat slows cooling; then a horizontal halt at 146 °C while the remaining melt freezes as eutectic.
- Eutectic mixture (61 wt% Bi): no break; the melt cools to 146 °C and freezes completely at constant temperature, giving a single halt like a pure substance, then the solid cools.
- The halt at 146 °C is longest for the eutectic composition (Tammann's method uses halt length to locate the eutectic).
Step 6: (iii) Acetone and dry ice bath
- At 1 atm solid CO₂ does not melt; it sublimes at −78.5 °C (triple point 5.1 atm, −56.6 °C).
- Heat from the flask is used to sublime the CO₂; as long as solid CO₂ remains in contact with the liquid at 1 atm, the bath is pinned at the sublimation temperature (solid and vapour in equilibrium at fixed P, F = 1 − 2 + 2 = 1, fixed by P).
- Acetone stays liquid (melting point −94.9 °C), so the bath does not freeze solid and the liquid gives good thermal contact with the flask, which dry ice lumps alone cannot.
- The steady bubbling is CO₂ gas escaping; the bath reaches about −78 °C.
Conclusion
μᵢ links all four potentials and is the quantity that is equal in every phase at equilibrium; the Cd and Bi system is the textbook simple eutectic, used to illustrate thermal analysis; the acetone and dry ice bath is a constant temperature bath fixed by sublimation equilibrium.
Examples and data to cite
- Low melting eutectic alloys containing bismuth, lead, tin and cadmium, such as Wood's metal (melting near 70 °C), are used for fusible links in fire sprinkler heads and fusible plugs in boilers.
- Other cold baths: ice and NaCl reaches about −21 °C (eutectic of NaCl and water, −21.2 °C at 23.3% salt by mass); dry ice with acetonitrile gives about −41 °C; liquid nitrogen −196 °C.
Facts to remember
- dU = TdS − PdV + Σμᵢdnᵢ
- μᵢ = (∂G/∂nᵢ)_T,P,nⱼ is the partial molar Gibbs energy
- Gibbs and Duhem: Σnᵢdμᵢ = 0 at constant T and P
- Condensed phase rule: F′ = C − P + 1
- CO₂ sublimes at −78.5 °C at 1 atm; triple point −56.6 °C, 5.11 atm