Out of three lattice structures SC, BCC and FCC, which one is most economically packed and which one least? Give your answer, calculating packing fraction of each lattice structure.
20 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
Packing fractions are SC = π/6 ≈ 0.524 (52.4%), BCC = √3π/8 ≈ 0.680 (68.0%) and FCC = π/(3√2) ≈ 0.740 (74.0%); FCC (cubic close packing) is the most economically packed and simple cubic the least.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Derive, for each cubic lattice, the number of atoms per unit cell, the relation between edge length a and atomic radius r (from the direction along which spheres touch), and then the packing fraction = volume occupied by atoms / volume of unit cell. Compare and conclude.
Answer outline
Introduction
Treat atoms as hard spheres of radius r. Packing fraction (PF) = Z × (4/3)πr³ / a³, where Z = effective number of atoms per cell. Corner atoms count 1/8, face-centre atoms 1/2, body-centre atom 1.
Step 1: Simple cubic (SC)
- Z = 8 × 1/8 = 1
- Atoms touch along the edge: a = 2r
- PF = (4/3)πr³ / (2r)³ = (4/3)πr³ / 8r³ = π/6
- PF = 0.5236 (52.4%); void 47.6%; coordination number 6
Step 2: Body-centred cubic (BCC)
- Z = 8 × 1/8 + 1 = 2
- Atoms touch along the body diagonal: √3 a = 4r, so a = 4r/√3
- a³ = 64r³/(3√3)
- PF = 2 × (4/3)πr³ × 3√3/(64r³) = √3π/8
- PF = 0.6802 (68.0%); void 32.0%; coordination number 8
Step 3: Face-centred cubic (FCC)
- Z = 8 × 1/8 + 6 × 1/2 = 4
- Atoms touch along the face diagonal: √2 a = 4r, so a = 2√2 r
- a³ = 16√2 r³
- PF = 4 × (4/3)πr³ / (16√2 r³) = π/(3√2)
- PF = 0.7405 (74.0%); void 26.0%; coordination number 12
Step 4: Comparison
- FCC (0.740) > BCC (0.680) > SC (0.524).
- FCC is the most economically packed; it is a close-packed (ABCABC) arrangement, and 74% is the maximum possible for equal spheres (same as hcp).
- SC is least efficient, leaving almost half the space empty; this is why it is rare among metals (polonium is the classic example).
- Packing efficiency rises with coordination number: 6 < 8 < 12.
Step 5: Density relation
- Density ρ = Z M / (Nₐ a³); for a given metal and radius, a higher PF means a higher density.
- Iron changes from bcc (α-Fe) to fcc (γ-Fe) on heating above 912 °C.
Conclusion
SC 52.4%, BCC 68.0%, FCC 74.0%: FCC most efficient, SC least. Check: each value is below π/(3√2), the Kepler limit for equal spheres.
Examples and data to cite
- Metals with fcc structure: Cu, Ag, Au, Al, γ-Fe.
- Metals with bcc structure: Cr, W, Nb, α-Fe.
- Simple cubic metal: α-polonium.
Facts to remember
- Packing fraction = (Z × 4/3 πr³)/a³.
- SC: a = 2r; BCC: a = 4r/√3; FCC: a = 2√2 r.
- Z: SC 1, BCC 2, FCC 4.
- Coordination numbers: SC 6, BCC 8, FCC 12.
- Maximum packing of equal spheres = π/(3√2) ≈ 0.7405 (fcc and hcp).