(i) Draw the structures of three possible geometrical isomers of [10] annulene and explain the aromaticity. [5 marks]
(ii) Explain the aromaticity of sydnone and tropolone. [5 marks]
10 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
[10]Annulene (cyclodecapentaene) can exist as the all-cis, mono-trans and di-trans (naphthalene-like) isomers; although each has 10 π electrons (4n + 2, n = 2), none is aromatic because angle strain or clashing internal hydrogens prevent a planar ring. Tropolone is aromatic through its tropylium-oxide (6π) form, and sydnone is a mesoionic ring whose 6π charge delocalisation gives it aromatic-like stability, although recent computations call it non-aromatic but well stabilised.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Part (i) asks for the three cis/trans arrangements of the double bonds in cyclodecapentaene and a test of Hückel's rule against the real geometry: electron count alone is not enough, the ring must be planar and cyclically conjugated. Part (ii) asks why two non-benzenoid compounds, a seven-membered carbocycle and a mesoionic five-membered heterocycle, behave as aromatic systems; draw the charge-separated resonance forms and count the π electrons.
Answer outline
Introduction
Hückel's rule requires a cyclic, planar, fully conjugated ring with (4n + 2) π electrons. [10]Annulene satisfies the count but fails the planarity test; tropolone and sydnone satisfy it through dipolar resonance forms.
(i) The three geometrical isomers of [10]annulene
- All-cis (cis,cis,cis,cis,cis)-cyclodecapentaene: a planar regular decagon needs internal angles of 144°, far above the 120° preferred by sp² carbon, so the ring puckers and conjugation is broken.
- Mono-trans (cis,cis,cis,cis,trans) isomer: one trans double bond turns one hydrogen into the ring; angle strain is less but the ring is still twisted out of plane.
- Di-trans (cis,trans,cis,cis,trans) isomer: two trans double bonds place two hydrogens inside the ring, pointing at each other across the positions that would be C1 and C6; these internal hydrogens would occupy almost the same space in a planar ring, so the molecule twists strongly.
- Conclusion for (i): all three have 10 π electrons (n = 2) but none can be planar without severe strain, so [10]annulene is non-aromatic, is unstable and has polyene-like NMR signals.
- Supporting evidence: replacing the two internal hydrogens by a CH₂ bridge (1,6-methano[10]annulene, Vogel 1964) removes the clash; although the bridge distorts the ring from planarity, this compound shows a diamagnetic ring current and nearly equal C-C bond lengths, so it is aromatic.
(ii) Tropolone
- Tropolone is 2-hydroxycyclohepta-2,4,6-trien-1-one (C₇H₆O₂).
- The C=O group is strongly polarised: in the resonance form C⁺ to O⁻ the ring becomes a tropylium (cycloheptatrienyl) cation with 6 π electrons over 7 sp² carbons, a Hückel aromatic system (n = 1).
- Evidence, shown for the parent tropone: a large dipole moment (4.17 D, against 3.04 D for cycloheptanone), which points to a large contribution from the dipolar tropylium-oxide form, and easy salt formation with acids.
- The OH is acidic (pKa about 7, between phenol at 10 and benzoic acid at 4) because tropolone behaves as a vinylogous carboxylic acid; hydrogen bonding between the OH and C=O leads to rapid tautomerisation, so on the NMR time scale the molecule appears symmetric.
(ii) Sydnone
- Sydnones are mesoionic compounds with a C5-oxygenated 1,2,3-oxadiazole core: a five-membered ring O1, N2, N3, C4, C5 with an exocyclic oxygen on C5 and a substituent (for example phenyl) on N3.
- As for all mesoionic compounds, no completely uncharged structure can be written; the positive and negative charges are both delocalised, the positive charge on the ring and the negative charge largely on the exocyclic oxygen.
- Counting π electrons in the dipolar form gives a sextet of 6 π electrons delocalised over five atoms, the same count as in furan.
- Classically, mesoionic compounds such as sydnones are grouped with the non-benzenoid aromatics; recent computational studies instead describe sydnones as non-aromatic, though well stabilised by electron and charge delocalisation in two separate regions. A good answer mentions both views.
Conclusion
Aromaticity needs both the (4n + 2) count and a planar, cyclically conjugated ring: [10]annulene shows that the count alone is not enough, while tropolone and sydnone show that dipolar resonance forms can create a 6π aromatic sextet.
Examples and data to cite
- Vogel's 1,6-methano[10]annulene (Vogel and Roth, 1964), the first stable aromatic cyclodecapentaene.
- N-Phenylsydnone, first prepared in 1935 by Earl and Mackney by cyclodehydration of N-nitroso-N-phenylglycine with acetic anhydride.
- Natural tropolone derivatives: hinokitiol (β-thujaplicin, 4-isopropyltropolone) from Cupressaceae trees; colchicine, from Colchicum autumnale, a tropone alkaloid used as a drug.
Facts to remember
- Hückel rule: planar monocyclic fully conjugated rings with (4n + 2) π electrons are aromatic.
- A planar regular decagon needs 144° internal angles; sp² carbon prefers 120°.
- Tropolone: C₇H₆O₂, pKa about 7; tropylium ion is a 6π aromatic cation.
- Sydnones are mesoionic compounds with a C5-oxygenated 1,2,3-oxadiazole core; N-phenylsydnone was first made by Earl and Mackney in 1935.