Through a proper mechanism, explain the difference in the reactivity of M and N in the following solvolysis reactions.
[Figure, described in words: Reaction 1 [5 marks]: M --CH₃COOH--> product. M is bicyclo[2.2.1]hept-2-ene (norbornene) carrying H and OTs on the one-carbon bridge C7, with OTs on the side away from the C2=C3 double bond (anti-7-norbornenyl tosylate); the product is the same skeleton with OAc in place of OTs, in the same orientation (anti-7-norbornenyl acetate).
Reaction 2 [5 marks]: N --CH₃COOH--> product. N is the isomer with OTs on C7 on the same side as the double bond (syn-7-norbornenyl tosylate); the product is a cyclopentene fused to a cyclobutane (bicyclo[3.2.0]hept-2-ene) with OAc on the sp³ carbon of the five-membered ring next to the ring fusion (bicyclo[3.2.0]hept-2-en-4-yl acetate).]
10 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
The anti tosylate M ionises with anchimeric assistance from the C2=C3 π bond, which sits directly behind the C7-OTs bond; it ionises very fast and gives the anti acetate with retention. In the syn isomer N the π bond is on the wrong side, so it ionises far more slowly, with help from the C1-C6 σ bond, and the cation rearranges to the allylic bicyclo[3.2.0]heptenyl cation that gives bicyclo[3.2.0]hept-2-en-4-yl acetate.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question is a classic of neighbouring group participation. It asks why two diastereomers that differ only in the side of C7 carrying the leaving group differ hugely in rate and give different products. The answer must show the geometry (anti-periplanar back-side participation), the intermediate ions and how they explain retention in one case and skeletal rearrangement in the other.
Answer outline
Introduction
In both substrates the leaving group is on C7, the one-carbon bridge of norbornene. What matters is whether the C2=C3 double bond can reach the back lobe of the C7-O bond as the tosylate leaves.
Reaction 1: anti isomer M
- In M the OTs points away from the double bond, so the π orbital of C2=C3 lies exactly behind the C7-O σ* orbital: ideal for back-side (anchimeric) assistance.
- Ionisation is concerted with π participation, giving the homoaromatic norbornen-7-yl cation, a non-classical ion in which positive charge is shared by C2, C3 and C7 (three-centre, two-electron bonding).
- Acetic acid attacks C7 from the side opposite the double bond (the side the tosylate left from), because the π electrons shield the other face.
- Result: two inversions at C7 (one by the π bond, one by solvent) give overall retention; the product is anti-7-norbornenyl acetate, as drawn.
- Rate: the π participation gives a very large rate enhancement over both the saturated 7-norbornyl ester and the syn isomer N.
Reaction 2: syn isomer N
- In N the OTs is on the same side as the double bond, so the π bond cannot reach the back of the C-O bond; π participation is impossible.
- Ionisation is therefore much slower than for the anti isomer M.
- The assistance that is available comes from the C1-C6 σ bond, which is anti-periplanar to the leaving group. As OTs leaves, C6 migrates from C1 to C7 (a Wagner-Meerwein shift).
- After the shift, C7, C6, C5 and C4 form a four-membered ring fused to a five-membered ring (C1, C2, C3, C4, C7 side), and C1 becomes a cationic centre next to C2=C3: an allylic cation within a bicyclo[3.2.0]heptenyl skeleton.
- Acetate captures the allylic cation at the terminus to give bicyclo[3.2.0]hept-2-en-4-yl acetate, the rearranged product shown.
Why the difference
- Geometry decides: participation needs the neighbouring group anti to the leaving group.
- M: π bond anti, very fast, retention, no skeletal change.
- N: only a σ bond anti, slow, rearranged allylic product.
Conclusion
The 7-norbornenyl pair shows that neighbouring π participation depends strictly on stereochemistry: anti gives huge rate acceleration with retention, syn gives a slow, σ-assisted ionisation with ring rearrangement.
Examples and data to cite
- The norbornen-7-yl cation is a strongly homoaromatic ion; Saul Winstein introduced the concept of homoaromaticity in 1959.
- 2-Norbornyl cation, the prototype non-classical ion, as a related σ-participation example.
Facts to remember
- Neighbouring bonds give charge delocalisation (participation) when they are close to and antiperiplanar to the leaving group.
- Double inversion (participation then solvent attack) gives overall retention of configuration.
- Wagner-Meerwein shifts are 1,2-migrations of H, alkyl or aryl groups to a neighbouring carbocation centre.
- Products: M gives anti-7-acetoxynorbornene; N gives bicyclo[3.2.0]hept-2-en-4-yl acetate.