The following reaction gives two products X and Y :
[Figure, described in words: Ph-C≡C-CH₃ --HCl, Al₂O₃--> X + Y. X: one alkene carbon carries Cl (upper) and Ph (lower), the other carries H (upper) and CH₃ (lower), so Cl is on the same side as H and Ph on the same side as CH₃. Y: one alkene carbon carries Ph (upper) and Cl (lower), the other carries H (upper) and CH₃ (lower), so Ph is on the same side as H and Cl on the same side as CH₃.]
(i) Assign E/Z configuration to the products X and Y.
(ii) Between X and Y, identify the kinetic and thermodynamic products. [(i) and (ii) together 5 marks]
(iii) Under the reaction conditions, the kinetic product slowly gets converted to a thermodynamic product, until the equilibrium is reached. Propose a probable mechanism for this conversion. [5 marks]
10 marks · directive: Identify
The core of a good answer
X is (E)-1-chloro-1-phenylprop-1-ene and Y is the (Z)-isomer. X, whose geometry corresponds to syn addition of H and Cl, is the kinetic product; Y, in which phenyl is cis to H rather than to the methyl group, is the less crowded thermodynamic product. X isomerises to Y by reversible protonation at C2 to an α-chloro benzylic cation, rotation about C1-C2 and loss of a proton.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Part (i) is a CIP priority exercise; part (ii) asks which isomer forms faster (mechanism of addition on alumina) and which is more stable (sterics and conjugation); part (iii) asks for an acid-catalysed path that connects the two alkenes.
Answer outline
Introduction
Adding alumina or silica gel to HCl speeds up hydrohalogenation (Kropp and co-workers, 1990). The question says the kinetic product turns into the thermodynamic one, so the less stable isomer must be the kinetic product.
(i) E/Z assignment
- C1 bears Cl and Ph: Cl (Z = 17) outranks Ph (C). C2 bears CH₃ and H: CH₃ outranks H.
- X: Cl and CH₃ are on opposite sides, so X is (E)-1-chloro-1-phenylprop-1-ene.
- Y: Cl and CH₃ are on the same side, so Y is (Z)-1-chloro-1-phenylprop-1-ene.
(ii) Kinetic and thermodynamic products
- In X, H and Cl (the two atoms added) are on the same side: X is the syn-addition product, as expected if H and Cl are delivered together from one face; X is the less stable isomer and the kinetic product.
- In X the phenyl ring is cis to CH₃; the A-strain forces the ring out of conjugation with the C=C.
- In Y the phenyl is cis to H, so it can stay coplanar and conjugated; Y is more stable and is the thermodynamic product (anti-addition-type product).
(iii) Mechanism of X to Y
- Step 1: H⁺ (from HCl on the acidic alumina surface) adds to C2 of X, giving the cation PhC⁺(Cl)-CH₂CH₃. It is stabilised by the phenyl ring (benzylic) and by back-donation from a chlorine lone pair (chloro-carbenium/chloronium resonance).
- Step 2: C1-C2 is now a single bond, so rotation exchanges the positions of the groups.
- Step 3: loss of H⁺ from C2 regenerates the double bond; it can give either isomer, but repeated protonation and deprotonation drains material into the more stable Y until the equilibrium ratio is reached.
- An equivalent path: reversible addition of HCl to give 1,1-dichloro-1-phenylpropane followed by E1 loss of HCl, which also passes through the same cation.
Conclusion
X (E) is the fast syn adduct; Y (Z) is the more stable isomer, and the two interconvert through the benzylic α-chloro carbocation formed by reversible protonation at C2.
Examples and data to cite
- Kropp and co-workers (J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1990), 'Surface-mediated reactions. 1. Hydrohalogenation of alkenes and alkynes': silica gel or alumina speeds up the addition of HCl and HBr.
- Addition of HBr to buta-1,3-diene as the textbook case of kinetic (1,2-adduct, low temperature) versus thermodynamic (1,4-adduct, higher temperature) control.
Facts to remember
- CIP rules: higher atomic number gets higher priority (Cl > C; C > H).
- Kinetic product forms fastest; thermodynamic product is the most stable and dominates at equilibrium.
- α-Chloro and benzylic substitution both stabilise carbocations through lone-pair and π donation.