(i) Write the product(s) of the following sigmatropic rearrangement and explain using the FMO approach : [10 marks]
[Figure, described in words: isopropylidenecyclopentane (a cyclopentane ring carrying an exocyclic C=C(CH₃)₂) --hν-->]
(ii) Write the major product showing correct stereochemistry of the following cycloaddition reaction : [5 marks]
[Figure, described in words: 1-methoxycyclopenta-1,3-diene (MeO on a diene terminus, next to the ring CH₂) + but-3-en-2-one (CH₂=CH-COCH₃) --Δ-->]
15 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
(i) Photochemical suprafacial [1,3]-hydrogen shifts move an allylic H to the other end of the allyl unit: shifting a ring CH₂ hydrogen gives 1-isopropylcyclopent-1-ene, and shifting a methyl hydrogen gives isopropenylcyclopentane; the suprafacial [1,3] shift is allowed photochemically because the excited-state HOMO of the allyl fragment (ψ3) has same-phase terminal lobes on one face. (ii) Diels-Alder addition gives the 'ortho' (1,2) adduct, endo: endo-1-(1-methoxybicyclo[2.2.1]hept-5-en-2-yl)ethan-1-one, as a racemate.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Part (i) asks the candidate to see that the only pericyclic change available to a simple alkene with allylic hydrogens under light is a [1,3]-H shift, to name both products, and to justify suprafacial migration from the excited-state orbital symmetry. Part (ii) tests regiochemistry (largest-coefficient matching) and the endo rule.
Answer outline
Introduction
Treat the migrating H and the allyl fragment as an H atom (1s orbital) moving across an allyl radical; in (ii) use the FMO coefficients of a 1-donor diene and an acceptor dienophile.
(i) FMO analysis of the [1,3]-H shift
- Divide the transition state into H· (1s) and an allyl radical. Ground state: the allyl SOMO is ψ2, with a node at C2 and opposite signs at C1 and C3 on the same face; a suprafacial shift is forbidden thermally, and the antarafacial path the rules would require is geometrically impossible.
- Photochemically the electron is promoted to ψ3, which has the same sign at C1 and C3 on the same face, so the H can bond to C1 and C3 on the same face: suprafacial [1,3]-H shift is photochemically allowed. (Many photochemical [1,3] shifts are in fact non-concerted, through a triplet diradical, but the question asks for the FMO picture.)
- Isopropylidenecyclopentane has two kinds of allylic H: on the ring CH₂ carbons and on the two methyl groups.
(i) Products
- Shift of a ring allylic H from C2 to the exocyclic carbon: the double bond moves into the ring, giving 1-isopropylcyclopent-1-ene (1-(propan-2-yl)cyclopentene).
- Shift of a methyl H to ring C1: the double bond moves out to the side chain, giving isopropenylcyclopentane (prop-1-en-2-ylcyclopentane).
- Both are isomers (C₈H₁₄) of the starting alkene; the endocyclic trisubstituted alkene is generally the more stable of the two.
(ii) Regiochemistry: ortho rule
- MeO at C1 of the diene raises the HOMO and gives the largest HOMO coefficient at C4 (the terminus remote from OMe).
- The enone's LUMO has its largest coefficient at the β-carbon (CH₂).
- Big-big overlap: diene C4 bonds to the dienophile CH₂, and diene C1 (carrying OMe) bonds to the carbon carrying COCH₃. So OMe and COCH₃ end up on adjacent carbons ('ortho' adduct).
- In bicyclic terms: OMe on bridgehead C1, COCH₃ on C2, new double bond C5=C6, CH₂ bridge C7.
(ii) Stereochemistry: endo rule
- Secondary orbital overlap between the acetyl C=O and C2/C3 of the diene stabilises the endo transition state, so the acetyl group points under the C5=C6 bridge (endo, anti to the CH₂ bridge).
- Product: endo-1-(1-methoxybicyclo[2.2.1]hept-5-en-2-yl)ethan-1-one, formed as a racemate.
Conclusion
(i) 1-Isopropylcyclopentene and isopropenylcyclopentane by photochemical suprafacial [1,3]-H shifts. (ii) The endo 'ortho' Diels-Alder adduct with OMe at the bridgehead and COCH₃ on the adjacent carbon.
Examples and data to cite
- Contrast: thermal [1,3]-H shifts are not seen (which is why enols need an acid or base catalyst to isomerise), while suprafacial [1,5]-H shifts occur thermally at or above about 200 °C.
- Diels and Alder (1928; Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1950); the endo preference explained by Woodward and Hoffmann as secondary orbital overlap.
Facts to remember
- Suprafacial [1,3] shifts are photochemically allowed and thermally forbidden; suprafacial [1,5]-H shifts are thermally allowed (Hückel-topology transition state).
- 1-Substituted dienes with donor groups give 'ortho' (1,2) adducts; 2-substituted dienes give 'para' (1,4) adducts.
- Endo adducts dominate under kinetic control because of secondary orbital interactions.