Explain and compare the chemical shifts of hydrogens in ¹H NMR spectra of ethene and ethyne.
5 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Ethene protons resonate downfield, in the alkene range of about δ 4.5 to 7.5, while ethyne protons appear upfield, in the alkyne range of about δ 2 to 3, even though sp carbon is more electronegative, because circulation of the π electrons of the triple bond in the applied field shields protons lying along the molecular axis (a cone-shaped shielding zone), whereas π circulation in ethene deshields protons lying in the molecular plane.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question tests diamagnetic anisotropy: the order of shifts (ethene downfield of ethyne) is the reverse of what hybridisation and electronegativity alone would predict. The answer must give the values, the inductive argument, and the anisotropy cones.
Answer outline
Introduction
Chemical shift depends on local electron density (inductive effects, hybridisation) and on secondary magnetic fields from circulating electrons in nearby bonds (magnetic anisotropy).
Observed positions
- Ethene, CH₂=CH₂: all 4 H equivalent, one singlet in the alkene region (about δ 4.5 to 7.5).
- Ethyne, HC≡CH: both H equivalent, one singlet in the alkyne region (about δ 2 to 3).
- So the ethyne protons are the more shielded of the two.
Expectation from hybridisation
- s character: sp³ 25%, sp² 33%, sp 50%; the electronegativity of carbon rises in that order.
- A nucleus near a more electronegative atom has reduced electron density and is deshielded, so on this basis ethyne H should be the more deshielded.
- The observed order is therefore not explained by electronegativity alone.
Anisotropy in ethene
- When the C=C bond is oriented perpendicular to the external field, π electrons circulate and generate an induced field that opposes B₀ above and below the plane but reinforces B₀ in the plane of the molecule.
- The vinylic H lie in the deshielding region, so alkene protons shift downfield (about δ 4.5 to 7.5).
Anisotropy in ethyne
- The π electrons of the triple bond circulate around the molecular axis when that axis is parallel to B₀.
- The induced field opposes B₀ along the axis, and the acetylenic protons are located in this cone-shaped shielding zone.
- Net effect: shielding outweighs the electronegativity effect, so alkyne protons resonate at high field (about δ 2 to 3).
Conclusion
Ethene H appears downfield of ethyne H because π electron circulation deshields in-plane alkene protons and shields axial alkyne protons; magnetic anisotropy dominates over hybridisation.
Examples and data to cite
- Benzene protons are deshielded by the diamagnetic ring current, a stronger version of the alkene effect; the same ring current shields the centre of the ring.
Facts to remember
- Alkene protons about δ 4.5 to 7.5; alkyne protons about δ 2 to 3.
- Shielding cone along the C≡C axis; deshielding region in the plane of C=C.
- sp carbon has 50% s character and is more electronegative than sp² carbon.
- Chemical shift depends on electron density, electronegativity of neighbouring groups and anisotropic induced magnetic fields.