Why is polystyrene brittle in nature, while polyethylene is flexible ? Explain.
5 marks · directive: Explain
The core of a good answer
Polystyrene is brittle because its rigid phenyl side groups stiffen the chain and, in the commercial atactic form, prevent crystallisation, giving a glassy solid with Tg of about 90 to 100 °C, so at room temperature it is below Tg and is clear, hard and brittle; polyethylene has a simple −CH₂−CH₂− chain with a glass transition far below room temperature (reported in the range −130 to −80 °C), so its amorphous regions are mobile and, held together by crystallites, give a tough, flexible solid.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must link mechanical behaviour to the glass transition temperature and to chain structure: side-group bulk, rotation about backbone bonds, tacticity and crystallinity.
Answer outline
Introduction
Whether a polymer is glassy and brittle or soft and flexible at room temperature depends mainly on where room temperature lies relative to its glass transition temperature (Tg) and on its degree of crystallinity.
Polystyrene
- Repeat unit −CH₂−CH(C₆H₅)−: a large, rigid phenyl group on every second carbon.
- Stiff groups such as benzene rings restrict rotation of backbone segments and raise Tg to about 90 to 100 °C.
- Commercial polystyrene is atactic: the random placement of phenyl groups prevents the chains from aligning with enough regularity to crystallise.
- Below Tg chain segments are frozen, so general-purpose polystyrene is clear, hard and brittle.
Polyethylene
- Repeat unit −CH₂−CH₂−: small H atoms, easy rotation about backbone bonds, only weak van der Waals forces between chains.
- Glass transition range about −130 to −80 °C, so at room temperature amorphous segments are mobile.
- Regular chains partly crystallise (crystallinity from about 35% for LDPE to 80% for HDPE); crystallites hold the solid together while amorphous parts give flexibility and toughness.
- LDPE has much short- and long-chain branching, which lowers tensile strength and increases ductility.
Modifying behaviour
- Impact-resistant polystyrene is made with polybutadiene dissolved in the styrene, adding a rubber phase that reduces brittleness.
- Plasticisers can lower Tg significantly; syndiotactic polystyrene, unlike the atactic form, is highly crystalline (melting point about 270 °C).
Conclusion
Polystyrene is a glass at room temperature and polyethylene is above its Tg with mobile chains: chain stiffness from the phenyl substituent is the root cause.
Examples and data to cite
- Optical disc (CD) jewel cases are typical clear, brittle general-purpose polystyrene products.
- LDPE plastic bags and film wrap show the flexibility of polyethylene.
Facts to remember
- Tg of polystyrene about 90 to 100 °C.
- Glass transition range of polyethylene about −130 to −80 °C.
- Stiff groups such as benzene rings increase Tg; plasticisers lower it.
- Atactic polystyrene cannot crystallise; PE crystallinity about 35% (LDPE) to 80% (HDPE).