Complete the following Norrish Type I reaction :
C₆H₅−CH(C₆H₅)−CO−CH(C₆H₄CH₃(4))−C₆H₄CH₃(4) →(hν)
[1,1-diphenyl-3,3-bis(4-methylphenyl)propan-2-one]
10 marks · directive: Complete
The core of a good answer
α-Cleavage of the excited ketone gives a diphenylmethyl radical and an acyl radical (or a bis(4-methylphenyl)methyl radical and the other acyl radical); because the ketone is heavily α-substituted, the acyl radical loses CO, and the two diarylmethyl radicals then combine to give 1,1,2,2-tetraphenylethane, 1,1-diphenyl-2,2-bis(4-methylphenyl)ethane and 1,1,2,2-tetrakis(4-methylphenyl)ethane, plus CO; if the radicals escape the solvent cage and combine at random, the three ethanes form in a statistical 1:2:1 ratio.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question wants the Norrish type I products: α-cleavage, decarbonylation and radical recombination, recognising that an unsymmetrical ketone gives crossed and uncrossed coupling products.
Answer outline
Introduction
Substrate: Ar₂CH−CO−CHAr'₂ with Ar = C₆H₅ and Ar' = 4-CH₃C₆H₄. In a Norrish type I reaction the excited carbonyl (singlet, or triplet after intersystem crossing) cleaves an α-carbon bond to give two radical fragments; loss of CO from the acyl radical is favoured when the ketone is more α-substituted.
Step 1: excitation and α-cleavage
- n→π* excitation to the singlet; intersystem crossing can give the triplet; α-cleavage can occur from either state.
- Path a: Ph₂CH−CO−CH(Tol)₂ → Ph₂CH• + •CO−CH(Tol)₂
- Path b: → Ph₂CH−CO• + •CH(Tol)₂ (Tol = 4-CH₃C₆H₄)
- The fragments can also recombine to the starting ketone, which is a wasted step.
Step 2: decarbonylation
- Ar₂CH−C•=O → Ar₂CH• + CO; favoured here because each α-carbon carries two aryl groups.
- Overall from either path: Ph₂CH• + (Tol)₂CH• + CO.
Step 3: radical combination
- Ph₂CH• + Ph₂CH• → Ph₂CH−CHPh₂ (1,1,2,2-tetraphenylethane), AA
- Ph₂CH• + (Tol)₂CH• → Ph₂CH−CH(Tol)₂, AB
- (Tol)₂CH• + (Tol)₂CH• → (Tol)₂CH−CH(Tol)₂, BB
- Overall: Ph₂CH−CO−CH(Tol)₂ → (hν) CO + AA + AB + BB
Product ratio and the cage effect
- If the two radicals diffuse apart before combining, each radical meets Ph₂CH• or (Tol)₂CH• with equal probability: AA:AB:BB = ¼:½:¼ = 1:2:1.
- If instead the pair recombines inside the solvent cage (geminate recombination, the cage effect), only the cross product AB forms; a share of AB above 50% therefore measures the cage effect.
- The diarylmethyl radicals have no β-hydrogen (the atoms next to each radical centre are aromatic ring carbons), so disproportionation cannot compete and coupling products dominate.
Conclusion
Products: CO plus the three ethanes Ph₂CH−CHPh₂, Ph₂CH−CH(Tol)₂ and (Tol)₂CH−CH(Tol)₂, in about 1:2:1 ratio when the radicals combine at random outside the solvent cage.
Examples and data to cite
- Norrish first reported the reaction in 1937.
- Cleavage of 2-butanone largely gives ethyl radicals rather than less stable methyl radicals, showing that the more stable radical is formed preferentially.
Facts to remember
- Norrish type I: α-cleavage of an excited ketone to an acyl and an alkyl radical.
- Loss of CO from the acyl radical is favoured in more α-substituted ketones.
- Random coupling of equal amounts of A• and B• gives AA:AB:BB = 1:2:1.
- Cage effect (geminate recombination): radical pairs recombining before they diffuse apart.