Arrange the following molecules in increasing order of vibrational frequency (cm⁻¹) :
HF, HI, NO, CO
5 marks · directive: Arrange
The core of a good answer
Increasing order: NO (fundamental about 1876 cm⁻¹) < CO (about 2143 cm⁻¹) < HI (about 2230 cm⁻¹) < HF (about 3959 cm⁻¹), decided by ν̃ = (1/2πc)√(k/μ): the hydrogen halides have reduced mass near 1 u, and HF also has a large force constant, while CO and NO have reduced masses near 7 u but very stiff bonds, CO (k about 1902 N m⁻¹) being stiffer than NO (about 1595 N m⁻¹).
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question tests the harmonic oscillator relation between frequency, force constant and reduced mass. The answer should give reduced masses and force constants (or bond orders) for each, and the observed values.
Answer outline
Introduction
For a diatomic, ν̃ = (1/2πc)√(k/μ) with μ = m₁m₂/(m₁ + m₂). Both factors must be considered: light atoms raise ν̃, strong bonds raise k.
Reduced masses (u)
- HF: 1.008 × 18.998 / 20.006 = 0.957
- HI: 1.008 × 126.904 / 127.912 = 1.000
- CO: 12.000 × 15.995 / 27.995 = 6.86
- NO: 14.003 × 15.995 / 29.998 = 7.47
Force constants (from NIST harmonic wavenumbers ωₑ, k = μ(2πcωₑ)²)
- HF: ωₑ = 4138.3 cm⁻¹, k ≈ 966 N m⁻¹
- HI: ωₑ = 2309.0 cm⁻¹, k ≈ 314 N m⁻¹
- CO: ωₑ = 2169.8 cm⁻¹, k ≈ 1902 N m⁻¹
- NO: ωₑ = 1904.0 cm⁻¹, k ≈ 1595 N m⁻¹
Reasoning
- HF and HI have nearly the same μ, but the H−F bond is about three times stiffer, so HF is highest.
- CO and NO have μ about 7 u, which pulls ν̃ down despite their large k; NO has one more electron than CO, in the 2π orbital, and its force constant is smaller.
- HI, with μ ≈ 1 u, stays above CO although its k is about six times smaller: ν̃ ∝ √(k/μ).
Fundamentals from NIST constants (ΔG₁/₂ ≈ ωₑ − 2ωₑxₑ)
- NO: 1904.0 − 2(14.10) ≈ 1876 cm⁻¹; CO: 2169.8 − 2(13.29) ≈ 2143 cm⁻¹; HI: 2309.0 − 2(39.64) ≈ 2230 cm⁻¹; HF: 4138.3 − 2(89.88) ≈ 3959 cm⁻¹.
Conclusion
NO < CO < HI < HF; the same order follows from the harmonic wavenumbers (1904 < 2170 < 2309 < 4138 cm⁻¹).
Examples and data to cite
- HCl (ωₑ = 2990.9 cm⁻¹, fundamental about 2885 cm⁻¹, k ≈ 516 N m⁻¹) lies between HF and HI, consistent with the force constant falling from HF to HCl to HI.
Facts to remember
- ν̃ = (1/2πc)√(k/μ).
- μ = m₁m₂/(m₁ + m₂).
- Force constants from NIST ωₑ: CO 1902, NO 1595, HF 966, HCl 516, HI 314 N m⁻¹.
- Fundamental ΔG₁/₂ ≈ ωₑ − 2ωₑxₑ for an anharmonic oscillator.