Identify the molecular ion peak(s) and peaks due to McLafferty rearrangement in the mass spectrum of ethyl 4-chlorobenzoate.
5 marks · directive: Identify
The core of a good answer
Ethyl 4-chlorobenzoate (C₉H₉ClO₂) gives molecular ions at m/z 184 (³⁵Cl) and 186 (³⁷Cl) in about 3:1 ratio; the McLafferty-type rearrangement transfers a γ-hydrogen from the ethyl group to the carbonyl oxygen and expels ethene (28), giving the 4-chlorobenzoic acid radical cation at m/z 156 and 158 (3:1); α-cleavage giving the acylium ion at m/z 139/141 and then 111/113 is the main competing route.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The answer must calculate M⁺• with the chlorine isotope pattern and show which fragment comes from McLafferty rearrangement, with a mechanism, while separating it from simple cleavage peaks.
Answer outline
Introduction
Chlorine has two isotopes, ³⁵Cl (about 75.8%) and ³⁷Cl (about 24.2%), so every chlorine-containing ion appears as a pair 2 units apart in about 3:1 ratio. McLafferty rearrangement needs a C=O (or other π bond) and a γ-hydrogen in a six-membered arrangement.
Molecular ion
- Formula C₉H₉ClO₂: nominal mass 9(12) + 9(1) + 35 + 2(16) = 184.
- M⁺• at m/z 184 and M+2 at 186, intensity ratio about 3:1.
McLafferty rearrangement
- In the ester Ar−C(=O)−O−CH₂−CH₃ the CH₃ hydrogens are γ to the carbonyl group (C=O, then O, CH₂, CH₃).
- The γ-hydrogen moves to the carbonyl oxygen and the bond β to the carbonyl breaks (a retro-ene, sigmatropic process through a six-membered cyclic arrangement), releasing CH₂=CH₂ (28 u) as the neutral alkene.
- Product: [4-Cl−C₆H₄−C(OH)₂]⁺•, the radical cation of 4-chlorobenzoic acid, m/z 156 and 158 (3:1).
- No McLafferty process is possible on the acyl side, because the aryl group has no γ-hydrogen.
Other main peaks
- α-Cleavage, loss of •OC₂H₅ (45): 4-Cl−C₆H₄−C≡O⁺, m/z 139/141.
- Loss of CO (28) from the acylium: 4-Cl−C₆H₄⁺, m/z 111/113.
- Loss of HCl (36) from m/z 111 would give C₆H₃⁺ at m/z 75 (loss of Cl alone would give 76).
Conclusion
Molecular ions: 184/186 (3:1). McLafferty product: 156/158 (3:1), from loss of ethene. Each chlorine-containing ion shows the 3:1 doublet.
Examples and data to cite
- By the same arithmetic, ethyl benzoate (M⁺• 150) would show the McLafferty ion at m/z 122 (benzoic acid radical cation) and the benzoyl ion at 105.
- Fred McLafferty published a description of the rearrangement in 1959; Anthony Nicholson first reported the process.
Facts to remember
- ³⁵Cl 75.8%, ³⁷Cl 24.2%, so M:M+2 ≈ 3:1 for one Cl.
- McLafferty rearrangement: γ-hydrogen transfer to the C=O group with β-cleavage, giving an alkene and a radical enol cation.
- Loss of 28 from an ethyl ester corresponds to ethene.
- Nominal mass of C₉H₉ClO₂ with ³⁵Cl: 108 + 9 + 35 + 32 = 184.