Determine the 'shape factor' for the diamond-shaped section shown in the figure :
[Figure, described in words: a rhombus (diamond) with total width b along its horizontal diagonal and total depth d along its vertical diagonal, symmetric about both diagonals; the horizontal diagonal divides the depth into two halves of d/2 each.]
10 marks · directive: Determine
The core of a good answer
Shape factor of a diamond section bent about its horizontal diagonal = Z_p/Z_e = (bd²/12)/(bd²/24) = 2.0.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
Shape factor is the ratio of the plastic moment to the yield moment, which equals the plastic section modulus divided by the elastic section modulus. The work is to find I and hence Z_e about the horizontal diagonal, and the plastic modulus from the first moment of the two equal halves about the plastic neutral axis (which coincides with the centroidal axis because the section is symmetric).
Answer outline
Introduction
Bending is taken about the horizontal diagonal (the dashed horizontal axis in the figure). Treat the diamond as two triangles of base b and height d/2 placed base to base on the horizontal axis.
Step 1: Second moment of area and elastic modulus
- I of a triangle about its base = b h³/12, with h = d/2
- I = 2 × b(d/2)³/12 = bd³/48
- y_max = d/2, so Z_e = I/y_max = (bd³/48)/(d/2) = bd²/24
- Yield moment M_y = f_y bd²/24
Step 2: Plastic neutral axis
- Area A = bd/2; by symmetry the equal-area axis is the horizontal diagonal.
- Each half (a triangle) has area A/2 = bd/4.
Step 3: Plastic modulus
- Centroid of each triangle from its base = (d/2)/3 = d/6
- Z_p = (A/2)(ȳ₁) + (A/2)(ȳ₂) = 2 × (bd/4) × (d/6) = bd²/12
- Plastic moment M_p = f_y bd²/12
Step 4: Shape factor
- S = Z_p/Z_e = (bd²/12)/(bd²/24) = 2.0
Conclusion
Shape factor = 2.0, independent of b and d. Check: it is higher than for a rectangle (1.5) because the diamond has little material near the extreme fibres, so the extreme fibre yields early and much reserve remains.
Examples and data to cite
- Shape factors for comparison: rectangle 1.5; solid circle Z_p/Z_e = (d³/6)/(πd³/32) = 16/(3π) ≈ 1.70; thin-walled circular tube 4/π ≈ 1.27; ISMB 400 with the values printed in Q4(b)(i): 1176/1023 ≈ 1.15.
- IS 800:2007 cl. 8.2.1.2 uses Z_p in the design bending strength of plastic and compact sections (β_b = 1.0), capped at 1.2 Z_e f_y/γ_m0 for simply supported beams, so the shape factor of a rolled section directly limits the reserve beyond first yield that a designer can use.
Facts to remember
- Shape factor S = M_p/M_y = Z_p/Z_e.
- Z_e = I/y_max; Z_p = sum of first moments of the compression and tension areas about the plastic neutral axis.
- The plastic neutral axis splits the section so that the compression area equals the tension area (for equal yield stress); for a doubly symmetric section it coincides with the centroidal axis.
- I of a triangle about its base = bh³/12 (about its centroidal axis bh³/36, so the centroid lies h/3 from the base by the parallel axis theorem).