A straight bar of alloy is mounted in a strut-testing machine with both ends pin jointed and loaded axially till it buckles. Using Euler's formula, calculate the maximum central deflection before the alloy material attains the yield point at 300 MN/m². Take bar length = 2·0 m, cross-section of the bar as 20 mm × 15 mm and modulus of elasticity E as 90 GN/m².
15 marks · directive: Calculate
The core of a good answer
Euler load = π²EI_min/L² ≈ 1249 N; with σ = P/A + Pδ/Z reaching 300 MPa, the maximum central deflection is δ ≈ 177.6 mm.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
After buckling, the axial load stays at the Euler value while the strut bows. The extreme fibre stress is the sum of the direct stress P/A and the bending stress Pδ/Z produced by the central deflection δ. Setting the extreme fibre stress equal to the yield stress gives the largest deflection possible before yielding.
Answer outline
Introduction
Pin-ended, L = 2000 mm, section 20 × 15 mm (buckling about the weaker axis, 15 mm dimension), E = 90,000 MPa, σ_y = 300 MPa.
Step 1: Section properties
- A = 20 × 15 = 300 mm²
- I_min = 20 × 15³/12 = 5625 mm⁴
- Z = I_min/(15/2) = 750 mm³
Step 2: Euler buckling load
- P_e = π²EI/L² = π² × 90000 × 5625/2000² = 1249.1 N
Step 3: Stress condition at mid-length
- σ_max = P_e/A + P_e δ/Z = 300 MPa
- P_e/A = 1249.1/300 = 4.164 MPa
- P_e δ/Z = 300 − 4.164 = 295.84 MPa
Step 4: Central deflection
- δ = 295.84 × 750/1249.1 = 177.6 mm
Conclusion
Maximum central deflection ≈ 177.6 mm (about L/11). Check: direct stress is only 1.4% of yield, so bending dominates, as expected for a very slender strut (L/r = 2000/4.33 ≈ 462).
Examples and data to cite
- Euler's formula assumes the column fails only by buckling, which holds while the compressive stress does not exceed the yield strength; here the direct stress at the Euler load is only 4.16 MPa against 300 MPa, so the formula is valid and the yield limit is reached only through bending.
- Slenderness: r_min = √(5625/300) = 4.33 mm and L/r = 462, a very slender strut whose critical stress (4.16 MPa) is far below yield.
Facts to remember
- Euler's critical load for a pin-ended strut: P_cr = π²EI/L², using the minimum I.
- Extreme fibre stress in a bowed strut: σ = P/A + M/Z with M = Pδ at mid-span.
- Slenderness ratio = effective length/radius of gyration, with r = √(I/A).
- Section modulus Z = I/y_max.