Using moment distribution method, analyse the structure ABCD shown in the figure (joint B is rigid). The loading on the structure, moment of inertia of the members and other dimensions are clearly mentioned in the figure. Give neat sketch of bending moment and shear force diagram, indicating their values in the diagram :
[Figure, described in words: a horizontal beam ABC with A and C fixed to walls; AB is 7 m long with moment of inertia 2I and carries a 100 kN downward point load 4 m from A (3 m from B); BC is 5 m long with moment of inertia I and carries an 80 kN downward point load 2 m from B (3 m from C). A vertical column BD, 5 m long with moment of inertia 2I, hangs from joint B down to a fixed support at D.]
20 marks · directive: Analyse
The core of a good answer
Joint B rotates only (no sway); final end moments are M_AB = −79.98, M_BA = +84.94, M_BC = −66.71, M_CB = +33.84, M_BD = −18.23 and M_DB = −9.11 kN·m (clockwise positive), with span sagging moments of 88.61 kN·m under the 100 kN load and 42.43 kN·m under the 80 kN load.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
A single-joint moment distribution problem. Because A, C and D are fixed and the beam ABC prevents horizontal movement of B, the only unknown is the rotation of B, so one distribution with carry-over gives exact answers. The answer must then derive span reactions, sagging moments, contraflexure points and column shear, and sketch the BMD and SFD.
Answer outline
Introduction
Clockwise end moments positive. Member stiffness 4EI/L (all far ends fixed). Fixed end moments for a point load W at distances a, b: −Wab²/L² (left end), +Wa²b/L² (right end).
Step 1: Fixed end moments
- AB: M_FAB = −100 × 4 × 3²/7² = −73.47 kN·m; M_FBA = +100 × 4² × 3/7² = +97.96 kN·m
- BC: M_FBC = −80 × 2 × 3²/5² = −57.60 kN·m; M_FCB = +80 × 2² × 3/5² = +38.40 kN·m
- BD: no load, 0
Step 2: Stiffness and distribution factors at B
- k_BA = 4E(2I)/7 = 1.143EI; k_BC = 4EI/5 = 0.800EI; k_BD = 4E(2I)/5 = 1.600EI; Σk = 3.543EI
- DF_BA = 0.323, DF_BC = 0.226, DF_BD = 0.452
Step 3: Distribution and carry-over
- Unbalanced moment at B = 97.96 − 57.60 = +40.36; balancing moment −40.36
- BA: −13.02, BC: −9.11, BD: −18.23
- Carry over (½): to A −6.51, to C −4.56, to D −9.11
Step 4: Final end moments (kN·m)
- M_AB = −73.47 − 6.51 = −79.98; M_BA = 97.96 − 13.02 = +84.94
- M_BC = −57.60 − 9.11 = −66.71; M_CB = 38.40 − 4.56 = +33.84
- M_BD = −18.23; M_DB = −9.11
- Check at B: 84.94 − 66.71 − 18.23 = 0
Step 5: Shears and reactions
- AB: R_A = (100 × 3 + 79.98 − 84.94)/7 = 42.15 kN; V_BA = 57.85 kN
- BC: V_BC = (80 × 3 + 66.71 − 33.84)/5 = 54.57 kN; R_C = 25.43 kN
- Column BD: axial compression = 57.85 + 54.57 = 112.43 kN; horizontal shear = (18.23 + 9.11)/5 = 5.47 kN, resisted by axial force in beam ABC
- SFD: AB +42.15 kN up to the load, then −57.85 kN; BC +54.57 kN up to the load, then −25.43 kN; BD constant 5.47 kN
Step 6: Bending moments for the BMD
- AB: hogging 79.98 at A, sagging 88.61 under the load (free moment 171.43 less 79.98 × 3/7 + 84.94 × 4/7), hogging 84.94 at B
- BC: hogging 66.71 at B, sagging 42.43 under the load (free moment 96.0 less 66.71 × 3/5 + 33.84 × 2/5), hogging 33.84 at C
- BD: 18.23 at B to 9.11 at D, varying linearly and changing side (contraflexure about 3.33 m below B)
- Contraflexure points: AB at 1.90 m and 5.53 m from A; BC at 1.22 m and 3.67 m from B
Conclusion
The joint B moments balance and reactions satisfy vertical equilibrium (42.15 + 112.43 + 25.43 = 180 kN = 100 + 80). Maximum moment is 88.61 kN·m sagging under the 100 kN load.
Examples and data to cite
- Hardy Cross developed the moment distribution method and published it in 1930 in an ASCE journal.
- The same problem can be checked by the slope deflection method with the single unknown rotation θ_B = −40.36/(3.543EI) = −11.39/EI (anticlockwise), which reproduces the end moments above.
Facts to remember
- Distribution factor = k_member/Σk at the joint; carry-over factor = ½ to a fixed far end.
- Stiffness of a member with far end fixed = 4EI/L.
- Fixed end moments for a point load: Wab²/L² and Wa²b/L².
- A frame without sway (here prevented by the fixed ends A and C of the continuous beam) needs no sway correction.
- Span reaction = simple support reaction ± (sum of end moments)/L.