The nominal flow rate of water over a weir is 2 m³/s. A 1 : 10 scale model of the weir is tested in a water channel. Answer the following :
(i) What is the expected flow rate for the model?
(ii) If a force of 12 N is measured on the model, what force would be expected on the prototype?
10 marks · directive: Answer
The core of a good answer
(i) Model discharge Qm = Qp/Lr^2.5 = 2/10^2.5 = 0.00632 m³/s (about 6.32 litres per second); (ii) prototype force Fp = Fm × Lr³ = 12 × 1000 = 12,000 N = 12 kN, using Froude similarity with water in both model and prototype.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question tests dynamic similarity for free surface flow. Flow over a weir is governed by gravity and inertia, so the model must be run at the same Froude number as the prototype. The answer must state why Froude (not Reynolds) similarity is chosen, derive the scale ratios for discharge and force, and then apply them.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given: prototype discharge Qp = 2 m³/s, length scale Lr = Lp/Lm = 10, model force Fm = 12 N, same fluid (water) in model and prototype so ρr = 1 and gr = 1.
Step 1: Choose the similarity law
- Weir flow is a gravity dominated free surface flow; viscous and surface tension effects are small if the model head is not too small.
- Froude similarity: Fr_m = Fr_p, that is Vm/√(g Lm) = Vp/√(g Lp).
- Hence velocity ratio Vr = Vp/Vm = √Lr = √10 = 3.162.
Step 2: Discharge ratio
- Qr = Ar × Vr = Lr² × Lr^0.5 = Lr^2.5
- Lr^2.5 = 10^2.5 = 316.23
- Qm = Qp/Qr = 2/316.23 = 0.006325 m³/s ≈ 6.32 L/s
Step 3: Force ratio
- Force scales as mass × acceleration: Fr = ρr × Lr³ × (Vr²/Lr) = ρr × Lr³ (with ρr = 1)
- Equivalently Fr = ρr Vr² Lr² = 1 × 10 × 100 = 1000
- Fp = Fm × 1000 = 12 × 1000 = 12,000 N = 12 kN
Step 4: Other useful Froude ratios
- Time ratio Tr = Lr/Vr = √Lr = 3.162
- Pressure ratio pr = ρr g Lr = 10
- Power ratio Pr = Fr × Vr = Lr^3.5 = 3162
Conclusion
The model should pass 0.00632 m³/s and a 12 N model force corresponds to 12 kN on the prototype. Check: Qm × 316.23 = 2.000 m³/s, which restores the prototype discharge.
Examples and data to cite
- Check of the result: 0.006325 m³/s × 316.23 = 2.000 m³/s and 12 N × 1000 = 12,000 N, so both scale ratios are applied consistently in the Froude model.
Facts to remember
- Froude number Fr = V/√(gL) expresses the ratio of inertia to gravity forces.
- Froude law ratios: velocity Lr^0.5, time Lr^0.5, discharge Lr^2.5, force Lr³ (same fluid), power Lr^3.5.
- Reynolds and Froude similarity cannot both be satisfied with the same fluid; free surface models use Froude similarity and accept small viscous scale effects.
- Scale ratio here is defined as prototype over model, Lr = 10.