Water flows in a triangular channel having side slope 1 Horizontal : 1 Vertical and longitudinal slope of 0.001. Estimate whether the channel is mild, steep or critical sloped when a discharge of 0.2 m³/s flows through it. Assume Manning's coefficient n = 0.015. Also, determine for what range of depths, the flow will be on type 1, 2 and 3 curve.
15 marks · directive: Estimate
The core of a good answer
Normal depth yn = 0.536 m exceeds critical depth yc = 0.382 m (critical slope 0.0061 > 0.001), so the channel is mild; M1 curves occur for y > 0.536 m, M2 for 0.382 m < y < 0.536 m and M3 for y < 0.382 m.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question asks for classification of the channel slope by comparing normal depth (Manning's equation) with critical depth (Q²T/gA³ = 1) for a triangular section, and then the three zones of gradually varied flow profiles for that slope.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given: triangular section with side slope m = 1 (1H : 1V), S0 = 0.001, Q = 0.2 m³/s, n = 0.015, g = 9.81 m/s².
Step 1: Section properties
- Area A = m y² = y²
- Wetted perimeter P = 2y√(1 + m²) = 2√2 y = 2.828 y
- Hydraulic radius R = A/P = y/(2√2)
- Top width T = 2my = 2y
Step 2: Normal depth
- Q = (1/n) A R^(2/3) S0^(1/2)
- 0.2 = (1/0.015) y² (y/2.828)^(2/3) (0.001)^(1/2)
- Solving by trial: yn = 0.536 m (A = 0.287 m², V = 0.70 m/s)
Step 3: Critical depth
- Q² T/(g A³) = 1 gives Q² (2y)/(g y⁶) = 1
- yc⁵ = 2Q²/g = 2 × 0.04/9.81 = 0.008155
- yc = 0.382 m
Step 4: Classification
- yn = 0.536 m > yc = 0.382 m, so the slope is mild.
- Check with critical slope: Sc = [n Q/(yc² (yc/2√2)^(2/3))]² = 0.0061; S0 = 0.001 < Sc, confirming a mild slope.
Step 5: Zones of flow profiles
- Type 1 (M1, backwater): y > yn, that is y > 0.536 m
- Type 2 (M2, drawdown): yc < y < yn, that is 0.382 m < y < 0.536 m
- Type 3 (M3): y < yc, that is y < 0.382 m (supercritical flow)
Conclusion
The channel is mild sloped; M1 above 0.536 m, M2 between 0.382 m and 0.536 m, M3 below 0.382 m. Check: Fr at normal depth = V/√(gA/T) = 0.70/√(9.81 × 0.268) = 0.43 < 1, consistent with subcritical uniform flow.
Examples and data to cite
- Hydraulic depth of the triangular section at normal depth: A/T = 0.536/2 = 0.268 m, used in the Froude number check Fr = V/√(gA/T).
Facts to remember
- Manning's equation V = (1/n) R^(2/3) S^(1/2), with R = A/P.
- Critical flow condition Q²T/(gA³) = 1; for a triangular section yc = (2Q²/(g m²))^(1/5).
- Mild slope: yn > yc (S0 < Sc); steep slope: yn < yc; critical slope: yn = yc.
- Zone 1: depth above both yn and yc; zone 2: between them; zone 3: below both.