Discuss the effect of earthquake forces on the stability of earth dams.
10 marks · directive: Discuss
The core of a good answer
Earthquakes threaten earth dams through inertial forces that reduce the factor of safety of slopes, build up pore pressure and liquefaction in saturated loose fills and foundations, crest settlement and loss of freeboard, and cracking of the core and piping; design therefore combines pseudo static and deformation based (Newmark type) analyses with good material choice, compaction and drainage.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The directive asks for a discussion of the mechanisms by which seismic loading affects embankment dam stability and how engineers account for them. A good answer explains each failure mode, mentions analysis methods (pseudo static, sliding block, dynamic analysis) and remedial and design measures, with a case example.
Answer outline
Introduction
An earth dam is a flexible structure, but strong ground shaking imposes cyclic inertia forces and alters pore water pressures in the dam body and foundation, so its stability must be checked for seismic as well as static loading.
Inertial forces on the slopes
- Horizontal and vertical ground accelerations act on the potential sliding mass and add a driving force; in the pseudo static method this is taken as a horizontal force kh W at the centroid of the sliding mass.
- The factor of safety of both upstream and downstream slopes is reduced.
Pore pressure rise and liquefaction
- Cyclic shear in saturated loose sands and silts (hydraulic fills, foundation alluvium) builds up excess pore pressure, reducing effective stress and shear strength.
- Liquefaction can cause flow slides of whole slopes, as at the Lower San Fernando Dam in 1971.
- Clayey, well compacted fills are much less prone to strength loss.
Deformation, settlement and cracking
- Shaking causes crest settlement and lateral spreading, reducing freeboard and risking overtopping.
- Transverse cracks in the crest or core, especially near abutments and conduits, can open seepage paths and later lead to piping and internal erosion.
- Differential settlement over compressible foundations or steep abutments aggravates cracking.
Analysis and design measures
- Pseudo static limit equilibrium analysis with a seismic coefficient, followed by Newmark's sliding block method to estimate permanent displacement when the factor of safety drops below one.
- Dynamic finite element analysis with cyclic soil models for high dams or liquefiable foundations.
- Measures: dense compaction, wide transition zones and filters that can self heal cracks, chimney and blanket drains, generous freeboard, flatter slopes and berms, removal or densification of liquefiable foundation layers, and avoidance of hydraulic fill construction.
Conclusion
Earthquake effects go beyond a reduction in the static factor of safety: liquefaction, deformation and cracking often govern, so modern practice checks deformations and builds defensive design features into the dam.
Examples and data to cite
- Lower San Fernando (Van Norman) Dam, California, 9 February 1971 (magnitude about 6.5): liquefaction of the hydraulic fill caused a slide that removed about 30 feet of the crest and upstream face, leaving about 5 feet of freeboard; about 80,000 people were evacuated downstream for three days, and the dam was later decommissioned.
- N. M. Newmark's 5th Rankine Lecture, 'Effects of earthquakes on dams and embankments' (Géotechnique, 1965), introduced the sliding block method for permanent displacement.
Facts to remember
- Pseudo static seismic force on a sliding mass: horizontal kh W (and vertical kv W where considered).
- Yield (critical) acceleration is the acceleration at which the factor of safety becomes 1; permanent displacement accumulates whenever ground acceleration exceeds it (Newmark).
- Loose, saturated, cohesionless soils are the most susceptible to liquefaction.