Consolidated drained tests on clay specimens were performed and the following results were obtained :
Specimen No. | Confining pressure (kPa) | Axial load (N) | Axial deformation (mm) | Volume change (cc)
1 | 200 | 410 | 11.0 | 7.0
2 | 400 | 850 | 12.3 | 8.5
3 | 600 | 1275 | 14.6 | 10.0
The initial diameter and length of saturated clay sample were 38 mm and 76 mm respectively. Determine the shear parameters in terms of total stress and effective stress. Also, comment on the results obtained and its application.
15 marks · directive: Determine
The core of a good answer
After area correction, the deviator stresses at failure are about 337, 697 and 1027 kPa; the Mohr circles give c' ≈ 0 and φ' ≈ 27.5°, and because pore pressure is zero in a drained test the total stress parameters are the same (c ≈ 0, φ ≈ 27.5°), showing a normally consolidated clay suited to long term (drained) stability analysis.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question requires area correction for a drained triaxial test with volume change, calculation of σ1 at failure, fitting the Mohr Coulomb envelope, and recognising that in a CD test effective and total stresses are equal. The comment should interpret the near zero cohesion and identify where CD parameters are used.
Answer outline
Introduction
Given: D0 = 38 mm, L0 = 76 mm. A0 = π × 19² = 1134.1 mm², V0 = A0 L0 = 86,193 mm³. The volume changes are taken as decreases (drained compression of a normally consolidated clay), and the given loads as the loads at failure.
Step 1: Corrected area
- Ac = (V0 − ΔV)/(L0 − ΔL)
- Specimen 1: (86,193 − 7,000)/(76 − 11.0) = 1218.3 mm²
- Specimen 2: (86,193 − 8,500)/(76 − 12.3) = 1219.7 mm²
- Specimen 3: (86,193 − 10,000)/(76 − 14.6) = 1240.9 mm²
Step 2: Deviator stress and σ1 at failure
- Specimen 1: σd = 410/1218.3 = 0.3365 N/mm² = 336.5 kPa; σ1 = 536.5 kPa
- Specimen 2: σd = 850/1219.7 = 696.9 kPa; σ1 = 1096.9 kPa
- Specimen 3: σd = 1275/1240.9 = 1027.5 kPa; σ1 = 1627.5 kPa
Step 3: Failure envelope
- p = (σ1 + σ3)/2: 368.3, 748.5, 1113.7 kPa; q = (σ1 − σ3)/2: 168.3, 348.5, 513.7 kPa
- Least squares line q = a + p tanα: tanα = 0.4635, a = −1.1 kPa
- sinφ' = tanα gives φ' = 27.6°; c' = a/cosφ' ≈ −1.3 kPa, taken as 0
- Each circle with c = 0 gives sinφ = q/p: φ = 27.2°, 27.7°, 27.5°, mean about 27.5°
Step 4: Total and effective parameters
- In a CD test drainage is allowed throughout and the load is applied slowly, so excess pore pressure u ≈ 0 and σ' = σ.
- Therefore c = c' ≈ 0 and φ = φ' ≈ 27.5°.
Step 5: Comment and application
- c' ≈ 0 indicates a normally consolidated clay; an overconsolidated clay would show a cohesion intercept.
- Volume decrease during shear (contraction) is also typical of normally consolidated clay.
- CD parameters govern long term (drained) analyses: long term stability of cut slopes and excavations in clay, earth dams under steady seepage, and long term bearing capacity and earth pressure.
Conclusion
c' = c ≈ 0 and φ' = φ ≈ 27.5°. The three Mohr circles touch a straight line through the origin closely, which supports the result.
Examples and data to cite
- Check: the three circles give sinφ = q/p of 0.457, 0.466 and 0.461, a spread of only about 0.5°, so a straight envelope through the origin is a good fit.
Facts to remember
- Area correction with volume change: Ac = (V0 − ΔV)/(L0 − ΔL), equivalently A0(1 − εv)/(1 − εa).
- Mohr Coulomb criterion: τf = c' + σ' tanφ'; on a p q plot, sinφ' = tanα and c' = a/cosφ'.
- In a consolidated drained test, pore pressure stays near zero, so total stress parameters equal effective stress parameters.
- Normally consolidated clays have c' close to zero in drained tests.