What is vibroflotation technique? The results of sieve analysis for the backfill material used in a vibroflotation project are as follows :
IS sieve | Mass of the soil retained (g)
4.75 mm | 9.40
2.36 mm | 54.00
1.18 mm | 78.20
600 μm | 83.10
300 μm | 86.20
150 μm | 75.30
75 μm | 13.80
Determine the suitability number. What would be its rating as a backfill?
15 marks · directive: Determine
The core of a good answer
Vibroflotation densifies loose granular soil by a vibrating probe with water jets while backfill is added around it; for the given backfill (total 400 g), D50 ≈ 0.73 mm, D20 ≈ 0.28 mm and D10 ≈ 0.19 mm, so Brown's suitability number SN = 1.7√(3/D50² + 1/D20² + 1/D10²) ≈ 11.5, which rates the material as good.
An outline written by upsc.help, not an official UPSC answer; every fact checked by a separate review. How we work
What the question asks
The question has a descriptive part (the vibroflotation process) and a numerical part: build the particle size distribution, read D10, D20 and D50, compute Brown's suitability number, and classify the backfill using his rating table.
Answer outline
Introduction
Vibroflotation (vibro compaction) is a deep compaction method for loose cohesionless deposits. A vibroflot, a cylindrical probe with an eccentric weight vibrator, is suspended from a crane and penetrates the ground with the help of water jets at its tip. It is then withdrawn in steps while vibrating, and granular backfill fed into the annular space around it is compacted, densifying the surrounding soil in a column.
Vibroflotation technique
- Stages: penetration with bottom jet; switching the water to upper jets; adding backfill around the probe; raising the probe in short lifts while vibrating until the required density is reached.
- Suited to clean granular soils; in soft cohesive soils vibro replacement (stone columns) is used instead.
- Can treat thick loose deposits, increases bearing capacity, reduces settlement and liquefaction potential.
- Probe points are laid out in a triangular or rectangular grid whose spacing is fixed by design.
Step 1: Percentage finer
- Total mass = 9.40 + 54.00 + 78.20 + 83.10 + 86.20 + 75.30 + 13.80 = 400.0 g
- Percent finer: 4.75 mm 97.65%; 2.36 mm 84.15%; 1.18 mm 64.60%; 600 μm 43.83%; 300 μm 22.28%; 150 μm 3.45%; 75 μm 0%
Step 2: Characteristic sizes (interpolation on log scale)
- D50 lies between 0.6 mm (43.83%) and 1.18 mm (64.60%): D50 ≈ 0.73 mm
- D20 lies between 0.15 mm (3.45%) and 0.3 mm (22.28%): D20 ≈ 0.28 mm
- D10 lies in the same interval: D10 ≈ 0.19 mm
Step 3: Suitability number
- SN = 1.7 √(3/D50² + 1/D20² + 1/D10²), with D in mm
- = 1.7 √(3/0.734² + 1/0.276² + 1/0.191²) = 1.7 √(5.57 + 13.14 + 27.44) = 1.7 × 6.79 = 11.5
- (Linear interpolation gives D50 0.77 mm, D20 0.28 mm, D10 0.20 mm and SN ≈ 11.0, the same rating.)
Step 4: Rating
- Brown's rating: 0 to 10 excellent; 10 to 20 good; 20 to 30 fair; 30 to 50 poor; above 50 unsuitable.
- SN ≈ 11.5 lies in 10 to 20, so the backfill is rated good.
Conclusion
The backfill has a suitability number of about 11.5 and is rated good; a coarser fill with fewer fine sand particles would push it into the excellent range.
Examples and data to cite
- R. E. Brown (1977), 'Vibroflotation compaction of cohesionless soils', Journal of the Geotechnical Engineering Division, ASCE, proposed the suitability number for backfill.
- Vibro stone columns have been used in Europe since the 1950s and in the United States since the 1970s for ground improvement.
Facts to remember
- Suitability number SN = 1.7√(3/D50² + 1/D20² + 1/D10²), smaller SN means faster settling backfill and better densification.
- Vibroflotation suits granular soils; vibro replacement (stone columns) is used in soft cohesive soils.
- Densification raises relative density and reduces liquefaction potential.